
ABSTRACT: Literary scholars have long studied the presence of religion within Evelyn Waugh’s fiction. In this article, I draw upon the work of postsecular scholars in order to propose a reading of religion’s apparent absence in The Loved One (1948). I argue that Waugh’s postwar satire does not bemoan religion’s disappearance, as one might suppose, but rather criticizes the presence of a particular, though unacknowledged, faith tradition. Through close analysis of the novel, I show how The Loved One depicts traces of Protestant belief and practice within the modern, ostensibly godless utopia of Whispering Glades. This depiction of secularism’s Protestant debt matters, in part, because Waugh publishes The Loved One shortly after his most famous Catholic novel, Brideshead Revisited . With its examination of death and mourning in Hollywood, The Loved One reveals how Protestantism infuses secularism’s rituals and rhetoric. The novel’s exploration of this Protestant presence within the secular contests the secular-religious binary that has shaped critical responses to Waugh’s oeuvre. Indeed, I suggest that The Loved One serves as a rejoinder to early criticism of Brideshead Revisited . The satire responds to accusations of Brideshead Revisited ’s superstitious Catholicism by exposing secularism’s own uncritical investment in Protestantism. In this way, a postsecular reading of The Loved One clarifies Waugh’s critique of secular society. Put plainly, secularism’s liberated milieu still harbors religious bias. I bring this assessment to contemporary criticism, for The Loved One ’s prescient depiction of Protestantism’s afterlife challenges literary scholars in the West to interrogate their own complex and contingent religious inheritance.
ABSTRACT: The Overstory by Richard Powers and the Mars trilogy by Kim Stanley both embody eco-postsecularity (EPS), a still nascent concept that brings together the insights of eco-criticism and postsecular studies. While eco-criticism highlights the importance of the nonhuman world, the postsecular describes a posture of spiritual curiosity that chafes equally against definitive claims about the nature of God and the idea of a purely naturalistic cosmos, devoid of mystery. EPS holds that human disregard for nonhuman nature and dissatisfaction with a purely secular society—two problems which we typically consider distinct—are deeply enmeshed. Treating these two problems as interconnected, eco-postsecular texts offer a joint solution. Both The Overstory and the Mars trilogy suggest that intimate encounters with the more-thanhuman world can be the foundation of new expressions of spirituality that transcend institutional religions and accommodate scientific inquiry. EPS rejects both religious orthodoxy suspicious of science and scientific orthodoxy derisive of faith. The Overstory urgently calls humans to embrace trees as fellow sacred beings, while the Mars trilogy imagines how a community might conceive a new spirituality grounded in reverence for an alien landscape. Combining eco-critical and postsecular approaches reveals a fuller picture of the ideas animating these novels. Moreover, it helps us address the intertwined spiritual and ecological crises we currently face because of climate change. Embracing an eco-postsecular framework helps us cultivate solidarity amid the climate crisis because by its very nature EPS is accessible to people from a wide range of disciplinary, religious, and cultural backgrounds.
ABSTRACT: This article shows how the literary form of prosimetrum used by Boethius in De consolatione Philosophiae draws upon Augustine of Hippo’s theological understanding of language. It traces how both Augustine and Boethius depict a person’s usage of speech, song, and silence as representative of their spiritual state. While both authors show how imitation of poetry can foster irrationality and how either wordy noise or speechless stupor can imprison a person, they also strategically use the pauses and punctuation built into speech and song to encourage the soul to draw closer to the divine Verbum . In this way, Boethius transforms the classical genre of prosimetrum to draw the reader into a fundamentally Augustinian understanding of prayer and rumination.
ABSTRACT: Taking issue with D. W. Robertson, Jr.’s influential analysis of De doctrina christiana in A Preface to Chaucer , which even his medievalist critics have assumed is correct, this paper argues that Augustine’s treatise justifies neither allegorical readings of pagan literature nor the writing of Christian poetry that imitates biblical obscurity. Instead, his interpretive theory hinges on the divine authorship of scripture, the only text lending itself to salvific interpretation and the sole basis for a community of exegetes, preachers, and their audience bound together by charity rather than being motivated by pride. Chaucer’s metaliterary statements in Troilus and Criseyde and the Canterbury Tales only pretend to appropriate biblical poetics. Subverting themselves, they exemplify the perils of vying with scripture. Whereas the former work uses its disparity with the Bible to convey sublunary existence in form as well as contents, the latter finds a novel way to relate to God’s Word by reflexively dramatizing its interpretation.
ABSTRACT: G. K. Chesterton’s early novels provide a scathing critique of what he considered the nihilism of German philosophy, as typified by Schopenhauer and Nietzsche. Readers often assume that Chesterton mostly stuck to strawman arguments and caricatures, or else they wonder whether Chesterton’s obsession was really a mask for a secret fascination. It is true that Chesterton and Nietzsche have a surprising amount in common, from their love of aphorism and paradox to their desire to examine received truths and rouse people from moral lethargy. Nevertheless, Chesterton saw Nietzsche as a dangerous opponent, and he took every opportunity to attack what he perceived as the latter’s moral relativism. This article focuses on Chesterton’s novel The Ball and the Cross (1909), and reveals a complex interaction with Nietzsche’s theory of the Apollonian and Dionysian modes of culture in The Birth of Tragedy (1872). Chesterton examines the political, theological, and aesthetic implications of Nietzsche’s theory of culture and he engages directly with contemporary English popularizers of Nietzsche such as Orage, Mencken, and Shaw. In the end, Chesterton rejected Nietzsche’s theory of the Superman in favor of a Christian emphasis on meekness, joy, and a belief in the miraculous. Chesterton’s profound opposition to Nietzsche is demonstrated across numerous writings, proving that despite certain temperamental affinities, the two writers came to different conclusions about how to live with purpose in a universe that often seems absurd and meaningless.