
During 1997, legislators in several US states have taken action to restrict or enhance the access of adolescents to contraceptive information and services. In Texas, a budget bill rider that mandates parental consent before minors can be given prescription drugs faces a legal challenge while, in Maine, a similar bill died in committee. Mississippi's welfare reform bill includes three adolescent pregnancy prevention programs: one meets federal abstinence-only sex education guidelines; one mandates employment of school nurses in each school district to coordinate health services, including reproductive health services; and the third is a school-based pilot program that seeks to reduce the incidence of adolescent pregnancy and to provide reproductive health education. Colorado created a voluntary school-based health program. The only family planning (FP) restriction in this program is that no funds may be spent on abortion (except as may be required by federal law). In Florida, legislation amended existing authorization of state-supported school-based health services and specified that state funds were not to be used for FP, immunization, or prenatal care. Similarly prescriptive measures died in Louisiana and South Carolina.
This review of conscience-clause legislation opens by noting that in the first years after the US Supreme Court issued its decisions that protected abortion rights, more than half of the states and the federal government adopted provisions permitting individuals and some medical facilities to invoke religious, ethical, or moral objections as a reason to decline to perform certain procedures. After a period of dormancy, 4 states considered conscience clauses in 1997, with 2 of these adopting provisions. While the emergence of managed care conglomerates, some of which merged religious and secular institutions, raises new questions about this issue, the fact that informed consent requires that a patient understand all treatment options has not changed. Abortion-related laws are on the books in 42 states that have conscience clauses covering individuals and facilities, and 4 states with clauses covering only individuals. A table illustrates whether specific state laws covering individuals apply to participation and/or information dissemination, are limited to religious/moral objections, and/or require notification; and whether other state laws apply to all or only private facilities, to participation and/or information provision, and/or require notification. Legislation applying to contraceptive service and/or information provision is on the books in 13 states and applies to individuals in 5 states, public employees in 7, and medical facilities in 6. Sterilization-specific laws exist in 11 states, 10 of which have statutes applying to individuals and 10 to facilities. A table illustrates the range of legislation covering contraceptive services and sterilization. The review ends by analyzing which state laws cover managed care explicitly or implicitly and by noting the reemergence of conscience-clause issues on the federal level.
During 1997, 9 bills mandating insurance coverage of contraceptive services and supplies were seriously considered by various US states, and a 10th is under consideration by the US Congress. Interest in this area was sparked in 1995 when California legislation mandating coverage of prescription contraceptives was vetoed by the governor. The legislation has been refashioned to mandate coverage of a range of approved methods, but it hit a snag with a committee recommendation that insurance companies must offer, but not mandate, such coverage in packages presented to employers. Legislation is pending in New York that will require insurance plans that cover prescription drugs to include prescription contraceptives. A contraceptive coverage bill died in Oregon, and a similar measure in Hawaii is not expected to be resurrected in the 1998 legislative session. On the federal level, a bill has been introduced in the US Senate to provide equity in prescription insurance and contraceptive coverage. This bill is cosponsored by 17 Senators and received endorsement from the American Medical Association.
The US Supreme Court's 1983 decision in the Akron case enjoined states from requiring that women seeking abortions submit to extensive biased counseling and waiting periods. The 1992 Casey ruling, however, found that a state can regulate abortion services so long as the regulations do not place an "undue burden" on the woman seeking abortion. Since then, 8 states have increased the total to 11 that mandate an enforced counseling/waiting period, and 9 more states have enacted counseling requirements but no mandated delay. In 1997, Florida enacted expanded "informed consent" provisions that force a woman to submit to state-scripted counseling. A lawsuit has already been filed to challenge this law. In Kansas, North Dakota, and Utah, existing counseling/waiting period policies were amended to make them more stringent. Similar legislation is pending but unlikely to be enacted in California and North Carolina, while legislators in Ohio are creating an amendment to require face-to-face counseling. Counseling/waiting period legislation died after serious consideration in Alabama, Arizona, Maine, and Virginia. A US District Court judge upheld Wisconsin's law mandating a 24-hour waiting period and state-scripted counseling while voicing her dismay about the law. The judge did, however, rule against several specific counseling requirements and delayed the law's implementation until she could review the state-scripted materials. A ruling in Michigan that upheld the state's counseling/waiting period has been appealed to Michigan's Supreme Court.
The 1997 US legislative session has featured a number of measures to mandate private insurance carriers to improve coverage for family planning services and supplies. Such legislation is in process in Illinois, Hawaii, and Connecticut. In addition, Virginia enacted legislation earlier this year requiring insurers to at least offer employers the option of including contraceptive coverage in the plans they purchase for employees. New insurance regulations issued in New Mexico mandate managed care plans to include coverage of voluntary family planning services and stipulate that women have direct access to obstetricians-gynecologists without having to obtain preauthorization. The proposed Illinois legislation requires that all insurance policies written in the state cover both contraceptive services and the full range of Food and Drug Administration (FDA)-approved prescription contraceptive methods. The Virginia law requires that coverage of FDA-approved contraceptive methods, but not the contraceptive services, be offered. Finally, a bill (The Equity in Prescription and Contraceptive Coverage Act) that mandates insurance plans covering general prescriptions and outpatient medical services also to provide coverage for contraceptive prescriptions and related medical services is expected in Congress in the near future.