
Recent decades have seen a significant increase of interest in and research on psychotherapy case formulation. This trend can be traced to at least three factors. First is the continued emphasis on briefer and briefer treatments. As treatments shorten, therapists must be increasingly active in identifying a focus early in treatment, which in turn requires a quick case formulation.1,2 The second factor is the move away from an etiological nosology to one that is primarily descriptive. This change has created an “explanatory gap” between diagnosis and treatment that a case formulation may fill. The third factor is the recognition among many psychotherapy researchers that a prerequisite for empirically studying individual cases is that those cases be reliably and validly formulated. Formulation has been considered a core clinical skill and can aid the practitioner in multiple ways. A good formulation helps organize complex and sometimes contradicting information about patients. It facilitates understanding of the patient and consequently may increase empathy. Ideally, a formulation guides treatment, increases the consistency of one's interventions, and serves as a marker for change. It is best considered a “work in progress” that is altered as new information emerges and as the patient responds to interventions based on a preliminary formulation. In the past several years, although primarily in the 1980s, more than 15 structured formulation methods were developed, several of which have been tested for reliability and validity. Characteristics these methods share are that 1) the formulation process is broken down into separate components; 2) they are based on clinician judgment rather than patient self-report; 3) inferences are relatively low-level; and 4) the methods include both cognitive and cyclical dynamic aspects. The first and most researched of these methods is Lester Luborsky's Core Conflictual Relationship Theme (CCRT).3 It focuses on identifying a patient's central relationship pattern by examining narratives, out of which are extracted a wish of the patient, an imagined or actual response from an other, and a response of the self. Examples of research findings based on the CCRT are that 1) interventions based on a patient's CCRT predict psychotherapy outcome; 2) gaining mastery of the CCRT is associated with successful outcome in therapy; and 3) CCRTs derived from dreams and from narratives elicited in structured interviews are similar to those derived from psychotherapy transcripts. In this set of research abstracts, I summarize and comment on recent research on psychotherapy case formulation. Of the six studies reviewed, three investigate the CCRT. One investigates another approach called the Plan Formulation Method.4 The remaining two examine patients' own formulations and a cognitive-behavioral case formulation method.
McCullough anad co-author Marvin Goldfried have produced a treatment manual for the Cognitive Behavioral Analysis System of Psychotherapy (CBASP), a new form of therapy for chronic depression. Many readers may be deterred by the description of it as a treatment manual and conclude that it is not of any further interest. Some authors have held that the trend toward manualized approaches to therapy is a bad thing for psychotherapy and leads to impoverished and perhaps hopelessly ineffective treatment.1 Those of us trained in cognitive behavioral models accept and value the movement. However, cognitive therapists might ask why we would need a new manual on treatment of depression. After all, didn't Beck2 set the standard for treatment manuals with the classic Cognitive Therapy of Depression? Furthermore, hasn't cognitive therapy demonstrated its efficacy in treatment of depression? This book speaks to these questions and makes it clear that is has an important place because it offers a new conceptualization that is testable and appears to be an effective method for treating patients with a frustrating, resistant, life-threatening condition. McCullough points out that neither standard cognitive therapy using Beck's model nor interpersonal therapy was specifically designed to deal with chronic depression. The book summarizes outcome data, which show an impressive response rate for CBASP especially when combined with antidepressant medication. The model of therapy is based on an etiological theory of chronic depression that is deceptively simple. McCullough first explains what led to development of the model he will work with throughout the book. He draws from Piaget and argues that the chronically depressed are functioning at a preoperational level of cognitive processing. This leads to patients not connecting their actions with the consequences in their lives. This disconnection is the fatal flaw in chronic depression, leading to the hopelessness and helplessness that characterize the disorder. According to McCullough, individuals with early-onset chronic depression have never reached a stage of formal operations, and those with late-onset chronic depression have lost the ability to think this way in interpersonal contexts. The goal of therapy in part, then, is to drag the patient to the point where he can function using formal operations and so understand the consequences of his own behavior. McCullough offers tools to facilitate this change and conceptualizes the learning that must take place in the language of operant conditioning. Motivation to change is elicited by skillful use of negative reinforcement. The principal technique of CBASP is the situation analysis, or SA. The book spells out in detail what is involved in conducting SAs and the rationale for each step. McCullough frequently points out mistakes of novice CBASP therapists and the traps that anyone trying to do this type of therapy will encounter. The most common one is doing the work for the patient. He simply enjoins us not to do it. The reader is given examples and specific questions to use in conducting the SA as well as a method to evaluate the patient's progress in learning to do these on his own. We are led to understand that only by therapists' shaping behavior and applying consequences, primarily in the form of negative reinforcement, will patients learn how their behavior affects their environment and begin to think in the formal operations mode. Only then will they realize they have the power to achieve their own desired outcomes in life and begin to relate to others in an empathetic way. Those of us who have cognitive-behavioral backgrounds do not focus on transference and will find McCullough's model and discussion clear and useful. My guess is readers with psychodynamic backgrounds will find his ideas disturbingly simplified. The therapy model does include the idea that learning from earlier relationships is played out in the therapy relationship. McCullough does suggest developing a hypothesis about how this will happen, based on data gathered in an early session. Unfortunately, he does not explain how to formulate the hypotheses. When transference hot spots do occur in session, the therapist uses the opportunity to teach the patient to discriminate between the different relationships. This is called an Interpersonal Discrimination Exercise or IDE. As in the SA, we are applying consequences to the patients' behavior in order to teach them how their behavior affects others and to lead them toward interacting with others in an empathetic formal operational manner. McCullough brings in a unique idea about use of the therapist's self in the therapy. He describes Kiesler's model of interpersonal interactions. Using this model and a measure of interactions, the Impact Message Inventory, McCullough describes how the typical chronically depressed patient will interact, and the pulls for the therapist to respond in certain ways. However, the response must not be the automatic one because that will lead to failure of the therapy. Instead, a disciplined use of self in the therapy, guided by an understanding of the psychopathology, is recommended. Let me end where I began: Do we need another treatment manual? McCullough reflects that the experience of treating the chronically depressed can be likened to pouring energy down a black hole. Since he has a new model and a method with which to approach this needy population, and the evidence seems to suggest it may work very well, I for one am encouraged and feeling less hopeless already. My answer is a resounding yes.
In the subtitle the authors refer to their book as a “guide.” Later in the text they describe it as a manual. Manuals on how to do psychotherapy have always somewhat put me off, since I have always experienced psychotherapy (whether in the role of patient or therapist) as a most unpredictable and hard-to-formulate enterprise. The authors, to their credit, are sensitive to this matter and address it immediately. They say they do not want to produce a “cookbook” that would mechanize the therapy process but rather wish to “strike a balance” between, on the one hand, treating new cases as unique and, on the other hand, refining existing theory and technique by relating it to the new situation. They have succeeded admirably in striking that balance, and in the process have produced a very rich book (or, if you will, manual) that I would recommend to clinicians from all schools of psychotherapy. Their central focus is, as the title indicates, on the therapeutic alliance, and more specifically on how clinicians can resolve ruptures in that alliance. Another way to say this is that the authors are describing and discussing various ideas and techniques for resolving the inevitable and often highly distressing transference–countertransference binds that occur in psychotherapy. They particularly emphasize the importance of therapists' focusing on their own contributions to the binds and, further, exploring and negotiating difficult moments in the relationship directly with the patients—something the authors refer to as “collaborative inquiry.” There are a number of wonderful and clearly written chapters in this book. The first one presents a historical review of the notion of the therapeutic alliance and then reconceptualizes it from a relational perspective, which asserts that a central change mechanism in psychotherapy is the negotiation and resolution of ruptures in the alliance. The authors then offer a very useful taxonomy of interventions for addressing ruptures, accompanied by helpful vignettes illustrating their ideas. The second chapter is a review and summary of the ideas of leading relational thinkers. Readers interested in learning about these ideas and the issues under development by this school of psychotherapy, as well as its historical origins, will be especially pleased by this chapter. The next chapter tackles the omnipresent problems of resistance of therapeutic impasses. The authors distinguish between intrapsychic, characterological, and relational views of resistance, demonstrating familiarity with thinkers from all schools of psychotherapy on this topic. In keeping with their central theme, they stress the importance of therapists' understanding their own contributions to enactments and impasses by paying vigorous attention to their feelings and countertransference experience. Following the discussion of ruptures and impasses is a chapter on “therapeutic metacommunication.” This term refers to procedures designed to help therapists disembed from relational cycles that are being enacted by focusing on the transactions and implicit communications taking place between therapist and patient. The goal of metacommunicating is to articulate the therapist's implicit sense of the interaction in order to initiate an explicit exploration of what is being unconsciously enacted. The authors provide a succinct and specific set of principles (e.g., “emphasize awareness rather than change,” “explore patient's experience of interventions”) to keep in mind as one uses this kind of communication when conducting therapy. The most original chapter in the book describes a stage-process model for resolving alliance ruptures. Stage-process models of psychotherapy are designed to help therapists recognize stages that are likely to recur in therapy and thus provide facilitating interventions. The authors list two basic rupture subtypes: withdrawal and confrontation. Patients vary in their use of these coping strategies but are likely to present a predominance of one type of rupture over another. The authors indicate that it is important to be sensitive to the specific qualities of a rupture and its stage in order to help clarify patient tasks and provide appropriate interventions. They acknowledge that models like this are oversimplifications of the processes they are striving to capture. However, the notions presented and the clinical illustrations are first rate and well worth consideration by clinicians looking for new ways to think about ruptures in the therapeutic process. The authors have also dedicated a chapter to explaining and demonstrating the application of their ideas to a short-term therapy process they call Brief Relational Therapy. The discussion is clear and sophisticated, but they do not adequately address what I see as the complex matter of differential diagnosis and short-term therapy. People recovering from trauma and certain kinds of depression often profit from short-term treatment. However, the picture is complex. For instance, Ablon and Jones1 in their analysis of the NIMH-sponsored Treatment of Depression Collaborative Research Program found that positive outcome in brief therapy correlated with pre-treatment patient characteristics of being accepting, compliant, and agreeable. Patients with personality disorders, on the other hand, are known to be difficult and often require intensive and long-term therapy. I would recommend that these authors apply their impressive research, writing, and clinical skills to addressing more fully the issue of differential diagnosis and the relational approach to treating the more formidable psychiatric disorders. The authors believe that the training of therapists is most critical and consequently devote an entire chapter to the topic. They stress the importance of training therapists to deal specifically with negative processes and therapeutic impasses. They also emphasize the experiential side of training over the conceptual and the value of self-exploration as a primary vehicle for learning. The ideas presented in this chapter are very creative and stimulating, and I would strongly recommend it to all training programs and institutes. In fact, I would recommend this book to all clinicians. It should be especially useful for beginning therapists, and experienced clinicians should also find it valuable because it provides such a clear, comprehensive discussion of the relational approach to psychotherapy.
Interpersonal psychotherapy (IPT) has demonstrated efficacy in protecting against a recurrence of major depression in elderly subjects when used alone on a monthly basis and when combined with antidepressant medication. The authors summarize their experience using IPT over the past 10 years and discuss a variety of treatment correlates. In addition, preliminary results using IPT combined with paroxetine in depressed elders reveals no difference in remission rates between cognitively intact and cognitively impaired depressed elders.