Code Review Guidelines for GUI-based Testing Artifacts.

Review of software artifacts, such as source or test code, is a common practice in industrial practice. However, although review guidelines are available for source and low-level test code, for GUI-based testing artifacts, such guidelines are missing. The goal of this work is to define a set of guidelines from literature about production and test code, that can be mapped to GUI-based testing artifacts. A systematic literature review is conducted, using white and gray literature to identify guidelines for source and test code. These synthesized guidelines are then mapped, through examples, to create actionable, and applicable, guidelines for GUI-based testing artifacts. The results of the study are 33 guidelines, summarized in nine guideline categories, that are successfully mapped as applicable to GUI-based testing artifacts. Of the collected literature, only 10 sources contained test-specific code review guidelines. These guideline categories are: perform automated checks, use checklists, provide context information, utilize metrics, ensure readability, visualize changes, reduce complexity, check conformity with the requirements and follow design principles and patterns . This pivotal set of guidelines provides an industrial contribution in filling the gap of general guidelines for review of GUI-based testing artifacts. Additionally, this work highlights, from an academic perspective, the need for future research in this area to also develop guidelines for other specific aspects of GUI-based testing practice, and to take into account other facets of the review process not covered by this work, such as reviewer selection.