Re-appraising Assays on Permeabilized Blood Cancer Cells Testing Venetoclax or Other BH3 Mimetic Agents Selectively Targeting Pro-Survival BCL2 Proteins

BH3 mimetic drugs that selectively target the pro-survival BCL2 proteins are highly promising for cancer treatment, most notably for treating blood cancers. Venetoclax, which inhibits BCL2, is now approved for treating chronic lymphocytic leukemia (CLL) and acute myeloid leukemia (AML). Preferably, robust and validated assays would identify patients most likely to benefit from therapy with venetoclax itself or with inhibitors of other pro-survival proteins. A sophisticated method that has been developed is the BH3 profiling assay. In this assay, permeabilized, instead of intact, cells are treated for a few hours with inhibitors of the pro-survival BCL2 proteins, and the resultant mitochondrial depolarization measured. Sensitivity to a specific inhibitor (e.g., venetoclax or other BH3 mimetics) is then used to infer the reliance of a tumor (e.g., CLL) on one or more pro-survival BCL2 proteins. However, we found that this methodology cannot reliably identify such dependencies. In part, this is because almost all cells express multiple pro-survival BCL2 proteins that restrain BAX and BAK which must be inhibited before mitochondrial depolarization and apoptosis can proceed. Using genetic and pharmacological tools across multiple cell line models of blood cancer, we demonstrated that selective BCL2 inhibitors have important flow-on effects that includes the redistribution of BH3-only proteins to ancillary pro-survival proteins not directly engaged by the inhibitor. These secondary effects, critical to the biological action of selective inhibitors, were not accurately recapitulated in permeabilized cells, probably due to the limited time frame possible in such assays or the altered biophysical conditions when cells are permeabilized. While we could consistently define the sensitivity of a tumor cell to a particular BH3 mimetic drugs using intact cells, this was not reliable with permeabilized cells. These studies emphasize the need to carefully evaluate assays on permeabilized cells undertaken with inhibitors of the pro-survival BCL2 proteins.