Abstract Domestic cats ( Felis catus ) are well-loved companion animals; however, cats easily become unsocialized if abandoned. Abandonment amplifies human concerns over increased predation on local wildlife and disease transmission to housed companion animals. Thus, attention must be given to limiting the “creation” of feral/unsocialized cats while also humanely managing existing cats within municipalities. To understand public attitudes toward domestic cats, including feral/unsocialized cats, a study was undertaken in Prince George, British Columbia, utilizing an online survey, with a mix of close- and open-ended questions. Results identified concerns about unsocialized/feral cats, including disease transmission, damage to private property, and killing birds. In response, spaying/neutering was strongly supported, as well as active management of feral colonies by responsible parties. The elimination of feral colonies, in contrast, was not widely supported; respondents called for compassion in any management approach, arguing for an organized, community-based solution. Examples of such an approach are considered.