Which Agroecology in Vegetable Production Systems? Typology Analysis of French West Indies Farms

Faced with current agricultural challenges, vegetable production systems in Martinique and Guadeloupe are being called to transition towards more environmentally-friendly practices. These territories hold significant potential to address these challenges in terms of food security, sustainability and resilience to climate change. In this context, having a better understanding of the diversity of vegetable farms is an essential step in shedding light on the dynamics of agroecological practices and chemicals use. The study is based on a typological analysis of 409 farms. We first categorize farms according to their structure, their economic performance, the individual characteristics of their farmers and their additional activities. Three clusters of farms emerged: (1) the survivors which are poorly diversified, generate low incomes and operate on small surfaces; (2) the diversified which are similar to the first group but are differentiated by their high diversity in terms of crops and para-agricultural activities and by a greater use of direct sales; and (3) the big farms which are cultivated on large surfaces, need more workforce and generate a higher income. Based on this typology, we characterize their agroecological profile according to their degree of agroecological practices, pesticides and chemical fertilizers use. The results show that diversified farms are the most engaged in agroecology with less reliance on chemicals and a greater adoption of agroecological practices compared to the survivors and the big farms. This study thus allows to characterize the vegetable production systems in the French West Indies and highlights the facilitating role of diversification and small farm size in the development of agroecology.