We examined the electrodynamic impact of four geomagnetic storms of increasing intensities on the equatorial ionosphere: a moderate storm (27–28 September 2017), a strong storm (17–18 April 2002), a severe storm (07–08 September 2017), and an extreme storm (09–10 November 2004). Using Jicamarca incoherent scatter radar data, we analyzed F‐region height‐averaged vertical drift residuals to study perturbations in the zonal equatorial electric field, including effects from the interplanetary magnetic field (IMF) B z component, substorms, and ionospheric disturbance dynamo (DD). We compared the zonal electric field effects from these storms with predictions from three empirical equatorial vertical drift models: Fejer and Scherliess (1997, https://doi.org/10.1029/97ja02164 ) (F‐S), Kelley and Retterer (2008, https://doi.org/10.1029/2007sw000381 ) (K‐R), and Manoj and Maus (2012, https://doi.org/10.1029/2012sw000825 ) (M‐M). Our findings show that these models often fail to predict equatorial disturbance electric fields accurately. The K‐R prompt penetration model performed best for the most intense storm, reflecting a strong correlation between the interplanetary electric field (IEF) and the equatorial zonal electric field. The F‐S prompt penetration model performed reasonably well in moderate storms, indicating that auroral electrojet indices alone are insufficient for accurate predictions. The M‐M model followed equatorial drift trends only during and shortly after significant IEF changes and away from the terminator. The F‐S DD model performed best for the postmidnight period during the recovery phase of moderate storms. These results highlight the need for models that incorporate additional parameters, such as the IMF By and substorm effects, to better predict ionospheric responses to geomagnetic storms.
The low latitude ionosphere and thermosphere are strongly disturbed during and shortly after geomagnetic storms. We use novel Jicamarca radar measurements, ACE satellite solar wind, and SuperMAG geomagnetic field observations to study the electrodynamic response of the equatorial ionosphere to the 23, 24 April 2023 geomagnetic storm. We also compare our data with results from previous experimental and modeling studies of equatorial storm-time electrodynamics. We show, for the first time, unusually large equatorial vertical and zonal plasma drift (zonal and meridional electric field) perturbations driven simultaneously by multi storm-time electric field mechanisms during both the storm main and recovery phases. These include daytime undershielding and overshielding prompt penetration electric fields driven by solar wind electric fields and dynamic pressure changes, substorms, as well as disturbance dynamo electric fields, which are not well reproduced by current empirical models. Our nighttime measurements, over an extended period of large and slowly decreasing southward IMF Bz, show very large, substorm-driven, vertical and zonal drift fluctuations superposed on large undershield driven upward and westward drifts up to about 01 LT, and the occurrence of equatorial spread F irregularities with very strong spatial and temporal structuring. These nighttime observations cannot be explained by present models of equatorial storm-time electrodynamics.
Storm-time ionospheric electrodynamics effects have been the subject of extensive studies. The solar wind/magnetosphere/ionosphere and thermosphere disturbance wind dynamos have long been identified as the main drivers of low latitude storm-time electrodynamics. Extensive detailed studies showed that climatology of low latitude disturbance electric fields and currents is in good agreement with results from global theoretical and numerical models. Over the last decade, however, numerous studies have highlighted that the response of low latitude electrodynamics to enhanced geomagnetic activity is significantly more complex than previously considered. It is now clear that the electrodynamic disturbance processes are affected by a larger number of solar wind and magnetospheric parameters and that they also have more significant spatial dependence. This is especially pronounced during and after large geomagnetic storms when multiple simultaneous disturbance processes are also active. In this work, we briefly review the main past experimental and modeling studies of low latitude disturbance electric fields, highlight new results, discuss outstanding questions, and present suggestions for future studies.
During a weak geomagnetic storm (Ap = 15) on 24 December 2014, the penetration electric field perturbations over the Indian dip equatorial sector are found to be anomalous on a number of occasions during postsunset hours. The event is anomalous as the magnitude and polarity of penetration electric fields do not obey the existing paradigm. The penetration electric field perturbations are investigated using the vertical drifts derived from the CADI (Canadian Advanced Digital Ionosonde) measurements at Tirunelveli (8.7°N, 77.7°E, dip angle: 1.7°). During this event, we observed postsunset vertical drift of ∼42 m s −1 not only at 18:10 LT but also ∼36 m s −1 at ∼21:00 LT which is anomalous. Interestingly, the dawn‐dusk component of interplanetary electric field (IEFy) is relatively less (<2 mV/m) at ∼21:00 LT compared to the interval 19:30–20:30 LT (IEFy ∼3 mV/m). Despite that, the vertical drift observed over Tirunelveli is very close to zero or nominally upward during 19:30–20:30 LT. In addition, the downward drift just after 21:30 LT on this night is found to be exceptionally large (∼−60 m s −1 ). By combining vertical total electron content over the Indian sector with the OI 630.0 nm airglow intensity from Mt. Abu, chain of magnetometer and Los Alamos National Laboratory geosynchronous satellite particle measurements, it is suggested that the anomalous penetration electric field perturbations on this night arise from the effects of interplanetary magnetic field By and substorm.
We performed, for the first time, a season-dependent geomagnetically quiet-time climatology of mid- and low-latitude ion densities during low and moderate solar flux conditions using Floating Potential Measurement Unit (FPMU) observations aboard the International Space Station (ISS) from 2008 to 2019. Our daytime observations indicate that the main characteristics of the equatorial ionization anomaly (EIA) at similar to 400 km are consistent with those from other in situ and remote sensing probes. The FPMU daytime densities are also generally in good agreement with the corresponding results from the International Reference Ionosphere (IRI). However, the IRI does not reproduce the mid-solar flux evening low-latitude measured densities. In this period, the EIA exhibits strong longitude-dependent crest-to-trough ratios and asymmetries due to the pre-reversal enhancement (PRE) of the zonal electric field and thermospheric neutral winds. Our data also show strong structuring of the daytime and nighttime plasma densities. This includes a bulge, discussed for the first time here, in the EIA southern crest in the South Atlantic sector during the December solstice and equinox data, which we suggest being generated by the transport of plasma from the Weddell Sea anomaly (WSA). We also highlight and show the evolution of a midlatitude summer nighttime anomaly (MSNA) during the June solstice data in the North Atlantic sector. Our results give new insights into these two anomalies, where we show that they are stronger with increasing solar flux levels and that they last until the early morning. These latter results are not consistent with those from previous studies. The FPMU daytime densities are generally in good agreement with the results from the International Reference Ionosphere (IRI)A bulge in the EIA southern crest possibly associated with the Weddell Sea anomaly (WSA) was observed during the daytimeTwo midlatitude summer nighttime anomalies (MSNAs) were observed until the early morning and were stronger in a higher solar flux period
Dataset of the article entitled "Multi-process driven unusually large equatorial perturbation electric fields during the April 2023 geomagnetic storm" submitted to Frontiers in Astronomy and Space Sciences. The data include the outputs of simulations from the four empirical vertical drift models used in the article: Fejer and Scherliess (1997), Scherliess and Fejer (1999), Kelley and Retterer (2008), and Manoj and Maus (2012).
The 14-panel Advanced Modular Incoherent Scatter Radar (AMISR-14) system deployed at Jicamarca observed equatorial spread F plumes on two consecutive nights under unfavorable seasonal and solar flux conditions during a period that can be categorized as geomagnetically quiet. The AMISR-14 capability of observing in multiple pointing directions allowed the characterization of the irregularity zonal drifts revealing that, in addition to their atypical occurrence, the zonal drifts of these plumes/irregularities also presented distinct patterns from one night to another, reversing from east to west on the second night. This work addresses two main subjects: (a) the mechanisms that may have led to the generation of these irregularities, despite the unfavorable conditions, and (b) the mechanisms that possibly led to the reversal (east-to-west) in the zonal plasma drift on the second night. To do so a multi-instrumented and multi-location investigation was performed. The results indicate the occurrence of simultaneous spread-F events over the Peruvian and the Brazilian regions, evidencing a non-local process favoring the development of the irregularities. The results also suggest that, even under very mild geomagnetic perturbation conditions, the recurring penetration of electric fields in the equatorial ionosphere can occur promptly, modifying the equatorial electrodynamics and providing favorable conditions for the plume development. Moreover, the results confirm that the eastward penetration electric fields, combined with the upsurge of Hall conductivity in the nighttime typically associated with the presence of sporadic-E layers, are likely to be the mechanism leading to the reversal in the irregularity zonal drifts over these regions.
The “zebra stripes” are drift-periodic structures present in the form of peaks and valleys in energetic (tens to hundreds of keV) electron spectrograms in the Earth’s inner belt and slot region. Their characteristics inform of preceding electric field disturbances. Specifically, their amplitude contains information on the radial transport of trapped particles generated by azimuthal electric field disturbances. We introduce a method to quantify radial transport from the measured amplitude of the zebra stripes, and we apply it to the zebra stripes observed on 16 February 2014. The findings are compared with results from a particle tracing code that leverages an empirical analytical model for the electric field disturbances. The measured amplitude of the zebra stripes indicates that the electric field disturbances transported the trapped population coherently, over radial distances spanning several hundreds to thousands of kilometers. The magnitude of radial transport is shown to depend on angular drift frequency and initial location (equatorial radial distance and magnetic local time) in the disturbance. The model-observation comparison suggests that the timing for electric field variations provided by the model is valid for studying radial transport in the inner belt and slot region. On the other hand, we found discrepancies when comparing radial transport magnitudes. When assuming that radial transport varies as L 3 , as weakly suggested by the data for set angular drift frequencies, and extrapolating observations to L = 1, the amount of experimental transport obtained is two to three times greater than numerical estimates. Outputs from the standalone version of the Rice Convection Model (RCM) suggests that the electric field disturbances are likely greater than the estimates provided by the empirical model. RCM also supports the idea that radial transport driven by the prompt penetration of magnetospheric convection varies as L 3 in the inner belt and slot region.
Electron density measurements from the Floating Potential Measurement Unit (FPMU) onboard the International Space Station allow us to observe the structure of the equatorial ionosphere. During two geomagnetically quiet time periods, we examined the equatorial F‐region structure at night using FPMU electron density measurements along with Swarm spacecraft electron density measurements and Total Electron Content from ground‐based Global Navigation Satellite System receivers for comparison. During these time periods, the equatorial ionization anomaly (EIA) extended to local times late as post‐midnight in some cases. The EIA occurrences at night showed a longitudinal dependence. The mean density of the EIA peaks exhibited a 3‐wave pattern in longitude likely due to lower atmospheric planetary wave activity, similar to the longitudinal dependence previously observed in the EIA.
Geomagnetic storm ionospheric electrodynamics at the magnetic equator are examined in detail using upgraded, higher time resolution, Jicamarca incoherent scatter radar drift observations, SuperMAG geomagnetic field, and solar wind data to study equatorial ionospheric electric fields during the 8 September 2017 storm main and early recovery phases. We show that during a period of mostly large and southward Interplanetary Magnetic Field (IMF) Bz there were numerous daytime prompt penetration vertical and zonal plasma drifts. These prompt penetration events were closely associated with rapidly recurring (quasi‐periods ∼30 − 60 min) magnetospheric substorms with expansion phases corresponding to upward and westward drift (eastward and downward electric field) perturbations, and recovery phases to opposite polarity changes. The magnitudes of the zonal prompt penetration drifts were about twice larger than those of the vertical drifts. Our study suggests that magnetospheric substorms are the main drivers of prompt penetration electric fields during extended periods (over ∼2 hr) of nearly steady southward IMF Bz. We also find that in general substorms are major driving factors for disturbance electric fields during geomagnetic active times. Our data highlight the powerful capabilities of the Jicamarca incoherent scatter radar as a tool for detailed studies of short‐lived solar wind‐magnetosphere‐ionosphere coupling processes.
Based on 10 years' (2010–2019) of vertical total electron content (VTEC) data from Ahmedabad (23.0°N, 72.6°E, dip angle 35.2°) and campaign based OI 630.0 nm airglow intensity measurements from Mt. Abu (24.6°N, 72.7°E, dip angle 38.0°), it is shown that plasma density over the equatorial ionization anomaly (EIA) crest region increases in varying degrees during post‐sunset hours (2000–2100 LT) in magnetically quiet periods. The post‐sunset peak in VTEC precedes the corresponding peak in airglow intensity. By comparing post‐sunset VTEC enhancements with ionosonde observations from Tirunelveli (8.7°N, 77.7°E, dip angle 1.7°), it is shown that pre‐reversal enhancement (PRE) of the zonal electric field causes these enhancements over the EIA crest region. These observations are supported by TEC measurements by GAGAN (GPS Aided Geo Augmented navigation), the Indian Satellite‐based Augmentation System (SBAS). Comparison of average VTEC variations with global empirical model drifts reveals that the post‐sunset enhancements in VTEC occurs ∼1.7 h after the PRE and are significant only during December solstice and equinoctial months in high solar activity years similar to seasonal variations in PRE amplitudes. This time delay (response time of EIA crest) is almost half compared to the average response time (3–4 h) associated with the daytime fountain. Based on the latitudinal gradient in SBAS‐TEC, it is proposed that the PRE drives plasma from 5°N to 10°N magnetic latitudes to the EIA crest region leading to shorter response time. These results show the important role of the PRE in conditioning the EIA crest region.
We use novel radar observations at the Jicamarca Radio Observatory to study the first observations of highly enhanced plasma temperatures in the evening equatorial ionosphere. These short‐lived solstice evening events occurred following large upward plasma drifts and sharply reduced plasma densities. The electron temperatures increase during the August 5 and 6, 2011 moderate solar event reached peak values of about 1,000 K near 350 km. Smaller electron temperature increases were observed to altitudes up to about 500 km. There were also smaller concurrent ion temperature enhancements. During the very low solar flux January 20 and 21, 2020 event, a peak electron temperature increase of about 700 K occurred at an altitude of about 270 km. We also show that SAMI2‐PE simulations using the measured vertical plasma drifts reproduce the main characteristics of the measured plasma densities and temperatures up to 300 km, but not at higher altitudes. These simulations indicate that the evening anomalous plasma heating below about 300 km is due to the decrease in the electron‐ion cooling rate resulting from upward plasma drift driven decrease in the plasma density. Plasma transport and reduced cooling rate is a potential source of higher altitude heating.
The low-latitude ionosphere is one of the most dynamic regions of the Earth's upper atmosphere. The morphology of this region is controlled by radiative and coupled chemical, neutral, and plasma transport processes. Equatorial electrodynamics plays a fundamental role on the low-latitude plasma density, total electron content (TEC), and plasma structures and waves extending from the E-region to the protonosphere. Ground-based and satellite measurements over the last six decades determined the climatology of quiet- and storm-time equatorial electrodynamic processes. Extensive theoretical and numerical simulations, particularly in the last two decades, investigated the main electrodynamic driving mechanisms. These combined studies have led to major advances in the understanding of the short-term variability of equatorial electrodynamics, which is essential for the accurate forecast of low-latitude ionospheric weather, and its effects on ground- and space-based technological systems. In this work, we review the main properties of low-latitude electrodynamics, focusing on recent results of the equatorial ambient plasma drifts, which are the main drivers of low-latitude ionospheric weather. We also briefly mention some outstanding questions and suggest possible future directions for their more complete understanding.
We used reanalyzed Jicamarca radar measurements to study the response of equatorial ionospheric electrodynamics and spread F during the main phase of the large September 2017 geomagnetic storm. Our observations near dusk on 7 September show very large upward drifts followed by a large short‐lived downward drift perturbation that completely suppressed the lower F region plasma irregularities and severely decreased the backscattered power from the higher altitude spread F. We suggest that this large short‐lived westward electric field perturbation is most likely of magnetospheric origin and is due to a sudden and very strong magnetic field reconfiguration. Later in the early night period, data indicate large, mostly upward, drift perturbations generally consistent with standard undershielding and overshielding electric field effects, but with amplitudes significantly larger than expected. Our analysis suggests that occurrence of storm‐time substorms is one of the major factors causing the large nighttime westward and eastward electric field perturbations observed at Jicamarca near the storm main phase. Our analysis also suggests that magnetospheric substorms play far more important roles on the electrodynamics of the equatorial nighttime ionosphere than has generally been thought.
We used observations from the Peruvian Fabry‐Perot Interferometer network and from the Jicamarca radar to study the coupling of equatorial nighttime thermospheric winds and ionospheric drifts under moderate solar flux conditions. We show that the coupling of the extended quiet time zonal winds and drifts increases from dusk to midnight and is stronger during equinox than during June solstice. After midnight, they are strongly coupled, except during December solstice when the drifts are stronger. The nighttime disturbance zonal winds and drifts, derived by removing the corresponding quiet time values, are westward with peak magnitudes around midnight. They are in close agreement, except at early night when the winds are stronger, and have strongest (weakest) magnitudes during equinox (June solstice). We also present observations showing the strong neutral wind‐plasma drift coupling during the September 2017 and August 2015 large geomagnetic storms. We show that during the early phase of the September 2017 storm there were large and short‐lived, prompt penetration electric field‐driven, correlated oscillations (~1 hr) in the vertical and zonal plasma drifts, and in the zonal and meridional winds. These are the first observations of prompt penetration‐driven equatorial zonal and meridional wind disturbances. In this event, the vertical and zonal drift oscillations were anticorrelated, and the zonal winds followed the zonal drift oscillations with a delay of ~15 min. Our results illustrate the strong coupling of equatorial thermospheric winds and plasma drifts during geomagnetically quiet as well as during short‐lived prompt penetration and long‐lasting disturbance dynamo events.
We present the results of an analysis of long-term measurements of ionospheric F region ExB plasma drifts in the American/Peruvian sector. The analysis used observations made between 1986 and 2017 by the incoherent scatter radar of the Jicamarca Radio Observatory. Unlike previous studies, we analyzed both vertical and zonal components of the plasma drifts to derive the geomagnetically quiet time climatological variation of the drifts as a function of height and local time. We determine the average behavior of the height profiles of the drifts for different seasons and distinct solar flux conditions. Our results show good agreement with previous height-averaged climatological results of vertical and zonal plasma drifts, despite that they are obtained from different sets of measurements. More importantly, our results quantify average height variations in the drifts. The results show, for example, the solar flux control over the height variation of the vertical drifts. The results also show the weak dependence of the daytime zonal drift profiles on solar and seasonal variations. We quantify the effects of seasonal and solar flux variations on the morphology of the vertical shear in the zonal plasma drifts associated with the evening plasma vortex. Assuming interchangeability between local time and longitude, we tested the curl-free condition for the F region electric fields with very good results for all seasons and solar flux conditions. We envision the use of our results to aid numerical modeling of ionospheric electrodynamics and structuring and to assist with the interpretation of satellite observations of low-latitude plasma drifts.
We used Fabry‐Perot Interferometer (FPI) observations at Jicamarca, Nasca, and Arequipa, Peru, from 2011 to 2017 to study the nighttime zonal and meridional disturbance winds over the Peruvian equatorial region. We derived initially the seasonal‐dependent average thermospheric winds corresponding to 12 hr of continuous geomagnetically quiet conditions. These quiet‐time climatological winds, which are in general agreement with results from the Horizontal Wind Model (HWM14), were then used as baselines for the calculation of the disturbance winds. Our results indicate that the nighttime zonal disturbance winds are westward with peak values near midnight and with magnitudes much larger than predicted by the Disturbance Wind Model (DWM07). The premidnight equinoctial and June solstice westward disturbance winds have comparable values and increase with local time. The postmidnight westward disturbance winds decrease toward dawn and are largest during equinox and smallest during June solstice. The meridional average disturbance winds have small values throughout the night. They are northward in the premidnight sector, and southward with larger (smaller) values during December solstice (equinox) in the postmidnight sector. We also present observations showing that during the main and recovery phases of the April 2012 and May 2016 geomagnetic storms the zonal disturbance winds have much larger magnitudes and lifetimes (up to about 48 hr) than suggested by the HWM14. These observations highlight the importance of longer‐term disturbance wind effects. The large and short‐lived (about 2 hr) observed meridional wind disturbances are not reproduced by current climatological empirical models.