Multi-messenger, multi-viewpoint, and time-resolved observations of solar flares are now providing unprecedented constraints on particle acceleration sites, energy conversion, and energy transport. The interpretation of current observations, including microwave imaging spectroscopy from EOVSA, hard x-ray (HXR) imaging from Solar Orbiter/STIX, gamma-ray diagnostics from Fermi, and in situ measurements from Parker Solar Probe and Solar Orbiter, collectively demands modeling frameworks that go beyond traditional spatially unresolved, one-zone models or single-mechanism descriptions. This review surveys multiscale and multidimensional modeling approaches, including kinetic, magnetohydrodynamic (MHD), and macroscopic particle models, that are being developed to meet the need. Kinetic simulations reveal that three-dimensional (3D) effects, including field-line chaos and self-generated turbulence, are essential for sustained power-law particle acceleration. MHD simulations now capture flux-rope eruptions, plasmoid-unstable current sheets, and turbulent flare regions in realistic magnetic topologies. Macroscopic models coupling MHD with energetic-particle models produce spatially resolved electron distributions and synthetic HXR and microwave emissions for direct comparison with observations. Despite these advances, outstanding challenges remain in bridging kinetic and global scales, improving MHD simulations and macroscopic particle models, and achieving quantitative model-observation closure.
Low-frequency turbulence in the solar chromosphere remains poorly understood. We address (1) the sources of low-frequency turbulence that potentially heat the chromosphere, and (2) how turbulence is transported and dissipated throughout the chromosphere and lower corona. We use particle-in-cell simulations to investigate mixed polarity magnetic fields corresponding to emergent magnetic carpet field in coronal holes or quiet Sun regions for strong (imbalanced) and weak (balanced) guide magnetic fields. The initial mixed polarity magnetic field transitions rapidly to a turbulent state dominated by advected small-scale nonlinear structures, with a minority slab turbulence population, and the emergent field is largely annihilated. Turbulence is anisotropic for an imbalanced magnetic field and more isotropic for balanced cases. We develop a transport model for turbulence advected and dissipated throughout the chromosphere by randomly distributed energy-containing scale dynamical flows described by log-normal statistics. We compute the expectations for the total energy per unit volume < y >(h) J m-3, the Els & auml;sser specific energy << Z infinity 2 >>(h) m2 s-2, the heating rate < H >(h) J m-3 s-1, and the correlation length (h) in kilometers as functions of height h above the photosphere. Turbulent energy is injected into the low corona by a random "patchwork" of sites across the transition region surface. The expected energy injection rates < S > J m-2 s-1 for the chromosphere and at the base of the corona exceed the estimated energy requirements needed to heat both the chromosphere and corona. Similarly, we show that spicules can be heated gradually with increasing height by entrained magnetic carpet and photospheric turbulence.
Solar flares are among the most dramatic events in the solar system, releasing substantial magnetic energy and accelerating a large number of electrons to high energies. Notably, in certain events, the above-the-looptop region may contain a significant population of nonthermal electrons, both in number and energy. For the first time, we adopt a novel numerical method that combines magnetohydrodynamics with energetic particles incorporating feedback from nonthermal electrons to investigate electron acceleration and transport in solar flares. We find that a large fraction of energetic electrons are accelerated via the current sheet and termination shock regions. Most energetic electrons are concentrated in the above-the-looptop region, carrying a sizable amount of the released energy. We observe that greater feedback of nonthermal electrons leads to steeper energy spectra. The energy density of the nonthermal electrons oscillates due to the periodic impact of magnetic islands into the above-the-looptop region, which may help explain the observed quasiperiodic pulsations. Our simulations provide new insights into the origin of nonthermal electrons and associated emissions in the above-the-looptop region.
Identifying the physical mechanism driving blazar flares remains a central challenge in high-energy astrophysics. We show that the energy dependence of the standard deviation of the polarization angle variability (sigma PA) provides a powerful and robust discriminator of blazar flaring mechanisms. Using particle-in-cell-integrated polarized radiative transfer simulations, we perform the most rigorous statistical analyses of polarization variability to date. We demonstrate that magnetic reconnection and magnetized turbulence imprint qualitatively distinct energy dependence of sigma PA that directly reflects their different magnetic field evolution and particle transport. Reconnection predicts higher sigma PA with higher photon energy until the synchrotron spectral peak, whereas turbulence produces nearly flat sigma PA across the synchrotron spectral component. These trends are resilient to realistic observational limitations. Applying our results to optical and IXPE data of Mrk 421 and 1ES 1959+650, we find strong evidence for reconnection-driven flares embedded in a turbulent blazar zone. Energy-dependent sigma PA emerges as a decisive new probe of particle acceleration in relativistic jets.
In situ observations of energetic particles associated with interplanetary (IP) shocks, known as energetic storm particle (ESP) events, often show time-intensity profiles quite different from predictions of classical diffusive shock acceleration theory. We use numerical simulations, including test-particle simulations and hybrid simulations (with fluid electrons and kinetic protons) for shocks propagating into a turbulent magnetic field to study the ESP intensity-time profiles across a strong IP shock. We find that several types of energetic particle intensity profiles similar to in situ observations can be produced in our simulations. The peak of energetic particle count is often near, but can be shifted from, the locations of the shock front, with the peak usually being observed downstream of the shock. These findings may help understand particle acceleration at both traveling IP shocks and shocks in other heliospheric and astrophysical environments.
Certain solar flares exhibit a distinctive candle-flame or cusp-shaped feature above the bright flare arcade visible in extreme ultraviolet (EUV) and X-ray channels sensitive to high-temperature plasma. The presence of a cusp-like structure is generally regarded as a key piece of morphological evidence for magnetic reconnection to power explosive energy release in solar flares. In addition, downward-propagating plasma flows above the flare arcade have often been interpreted as outflows driven by magnetic reconnection. However, the relationship between the observed candle-flame-shaped morphology and the underlying magnetic field geometry for reconnection remains unclear. Likewise, the observed speed of the plasma downflows has been found to be too low compared to the upstream Alfv & eacute;n speed predicted by reconnection theories. With the help of a recently developed three-dimensional magnetohydrodynamics model, we examine the locations where magnetic topology changes from antiparallel to closed (Y-points) in a candle-flame-shaped flare, compare the observational emission features with synthetic EUV images generated from the model, and analyze their time evolutions. We also investigate the role of projection effects and line-of-sight integration in the measurements of plasma downflow speeds. Our analysis reveals that the Y-points do not necessarily coincide with the apparent cusp tip. Also, the apparent speeds of the supra-arcade downflows, as derived from tracks in the time-distance plots, underestimate the true Alfv & eacute;n speeds in the reconnection inflow region by at least a factor of 2 up to an order of magnitude.
The secondary energetic neutral atom (ENA) mechanism proposed to explain the ribbon-like enhancement of ENA emission observed by Interplanetary Boundary Explorer (IBEX) involves a pickup ion (PUI) ring-beam population beyond the heliopause. The stability of this highly anisotropic PUI distribution is crucial for determining the physical process responsible for the ribbon formation. It has been proposed that PUIs with pitch angles near 90 degrees can become trapped via the magnetic mirroring process in the turbulent magnetic field of the local interstellar medium. However, the turbulent mirroring scenario typically neglects self-generated waves excited by the kinetic instabilities of the ring-beam PUIs, which can efficiently scatter PUIs in pitch angle. Using a magnetohydrodynamics-particle-in-cell approach implemented in ATHENA++, we simulate the evolution of the ring-beam PUIs, incorporating both large-scale interstellar magnetic fluctuations and microscale self-excited instabilities. We examine the competition between turbulent mirroring and pitch-angle scattering by the self-generated waves. Our results show that the PUIs can be rapidly scattered toward a nearly isotropic distribution on the order of one day, much shorter than their characteristic lifetime of a couple of years. This suggests that theoretical difficulties remain for maintaining an anisotropic PUI distribution in physical models of the IBEX ribbon.
During near-Sun crossings of the heliospheric current sheet (HCS), Parker Solar Probe (PSP) observed populations of high-energy protons and heavier ions, indicating possible energization by magnetic reconnection up to 10 s-100 s keV nucleon-1. Here we study ion acceleration by magnetic reconnection at the HCS. To estimate ion energization, we solve the Parker transport equation coupled to a large-scale 2D MHD reconnection simulation. We find that multiple ion species develop power-law distributions with both spectral index and high-energy cutoff Emax consistent with in situ data. By accounting for the injection physics determined by kinetic simulations, we confirm that the charge-to-mass ratio scales as Emax proportional to (Q/M)alpha with alpha similar to 0.8-1.1, approximately consistent with PSP measurements in the broader range alpha similar to 0.6-1.7. In the limit where ions are injected at the same energy per nucleon, alpha can be as low as similar to 0.3. These findings further support the role of magnetic reconnection in producing high-energy heavy ions at the HCS.
Simulations have played a critical role in the advancement of our knowledge of magnetic reconnection. However, due to the inherently multiscale nature of reconnection, it is impossible to simulate all physics at all scales. For this reason, a wide range of simulation methods have been crafted to study particular aspects and consequences of magnetic reconnection. This article reviews many of these methods, laying out critical assumptions, numerical techniques, and giving examples of scientific results. Plasma models described include magnetohydrodynamics (MHD), Hall MHD, Hybrid, kinetic particle-in-cell (PIC), kinetic Vlasov, Fluid models with embedded PIC, Fluid models with direct feedback from energetic populations, and the Rice Convection Model (RCM).
We present particle-in-cell simulations of one dimensional relativistic electromagnetic shocks in a uniform magnetic field, for a range of magnetic field strengths, plasma temperatures and numerical initial conditions. We show that the particle energy distributions of these shocks can develop a state of population inversion in the precursor and shock regions, which may allow for synchrotron maser (or maser-like, coherent) emission. Our set-up is applicable to conditions expected in models of fast radio bursts and therefore lends credence to the synchrotron maser model for these transients. We also show, for the first time, how a newly developed “analytic particle pusher” for kinetic simulations gives similar results to the commonly-used Boris pusher, but for larger timesteps and without the need to resolve the gyro-radius and gyro-period of the system. This has important implications for modeling astrophysical plasmas in extreme magnetic fields as well as for bridging scales between kinetic and fluid regimes.
In astronomical environments, the high-temperature emission of plasma mainly depends on ion charge states, requiring accurate analysis of the ionization and recombination processes. For various phenomena involving energetic particles, non-Maxwellian distributions of electrons exhibiting high-energy tails can significantly enhance the ionization process. Therefore, accurately computing ionization and recombination rates with non-Maxwellian electron distributions is essential for emission diagnostic analysis. In this work, we report two methods for fitting various non-Maxwellian distributions by using the Maxwellian decomposition strategy. For standard κ -distributions, the calculated ionization and recombination rate coefficients show comparable accuracy to other public packages. Additionally, our methods support arbitrary electron distributions and can be easily extended to updated atomic databases. We apply the above methods to two specific non-Maxwellian distribution scenarios: (i) accelerated electron distributions due to magnetic reconnection revealed in a combined MHD–particle simulation; and (ii) the high-energy truncated κ -distribution predicted by the exospheric model of the solar wind. During the electron acceleration process, we show that the ionization rates of high-temperature iron ions increase significantly compared to their initial Maxwellian distribution, while the recombination rates may decrease due to the electron distribution changes in low-energy ranges. This can potentially lead to an overestimation of the plasma temperature when analyzing the Fe emission lines under the Maxwellian distribution assumption. For the truncated κ -distribution in the solar wind, our results show that the ionization rates are lower than those for the standard κ -distribution, while the recombination rates remain similar. This leads to an overestimation of the plasma temperature when assuming a κ -distribution.
Magnetic reconnection and turbulence in magnetically-dominated environments have been proposed as important nonthermal particle acceleration mechanisms that generate high energy particles and associated emissions. While the acceleration to high energy that produces the power-law energy distribution has drawn strong interest, recent studies actively discuss pre-acceleration, or injection, to a sufficient energy for a sustained and prolonged Fermi-like acceleration. The injection process is important for determining the fraction of nonthermal particles and energy partition between thermal and nonthermal particles. We review recent advances in understanding the injection mechanisms responsible for populating these nonthermal power-law spectra, and conclude with an outlook for studies and applications of injection models.
This paper reports a dispersion analysis of two wave packets simultaneously observed near the local proton gyrofrequency by the Parker Solar Probe. The observed wave event exhibits clear two-banded wave packets both propagating along the magnetic field, characterized by left-handed (L-mode) and right-handed (R-mode) polarizations simultaneously. By incorporating the Doppler shift effect into a linear dispersion analysis, we find two possible scenarios that explain these simultaneous opposite polarizations: (1) Two inherently L-mode waves in the plasma frame, propagate parallel and antiparallel to the solar wind velocity, with similar wave frequencies and wave numbers. The polarization of the antiparallel propagating wave reverses as it moves sunward in the plasma frame while still comoving with the solar wind in the stationary frame. This reversal manifests the polarization of the wave as an R-mode in the spacecraft frame. (2) Simultaneous L-mode and R-mode waves propagate parallel to the solar wind velocity, with different wave frequencies and wave numbers. Concurrent proton observations during the wave event reveal a dominant anisotropic ( T ⊥ / T ∥ > 1 ) core distribution with a drifting beam population. Estimation of the linear growth rate for both L-mode and R-mode waves suggests that both scenarios are plausible, indicating that the observation is near the wave-generation region. We explore the potential impact of these simultaneous waves on solar wind heating and scattering effects, hypothesizing that such waves might enhance efficiency compared to waves with a single wave packet, contingent upon the statistical significance of such waves.
Relativistic magnetic turbulence has been proposed as a process for producing nonthermal particles in high-energy astrophysics. The particle energization may be contributed by both magnetic reconnection and turbulent fluctuations, but their interplay is poorly understood. It has been suggested that during magnetic reconnection the parallel electric field dominates the particle acceleration up to the lower bound of the power-law particle spectrum, but recent studies show that electric fields perpendicular to the magnetic field can play an important, if not dominant role. In this study, we carry out two-dimensional fully kinetic particle-in-cell simulations of magnetically dominated decaying turbulence in a relativistic pair plasma. For a fixed magnetization parameter σ _0 = 20, we find that the injection energy ε _inj converges with increasing domain size to ε _inj ≃ 10 m _e c ^2 . In contrast, the power-law index, the cut-off energy, and the power-law extent increase steadily with domain size. We trace a large number of particles and evaluate the contributions of the work done by the parallel ( W _∥ ) and perpendicular ( W _⊥ ) electric fields during both the injection phase and the postinjection phase. We find that during the injection phase, the W _⊥ contribution increases with domain size, suggesting that it may eventually dominate injection for a sufficiently large domain. In contrast, on average, both components contribute equally during the postinjection phase, insensitive to the domain size. For high energy ( ε ≫ ε _inj ) particles, W _⊥ dominates the subsequent energization. These findings may improve our understanding of nonthermal particles and their emissions in astrophysical plasmas.
Alfvén waves play a significant role in solar coronal heating, solar wind acceleration, and Alfvénic turbulence formation. As a fundamental process, magnetic reconnection has long been credited as a crucial source of Alfvén waves. However, how magnetic reconnection triggers Alfvén waves remains unclear. Here, employing high-resolution simulations of three-dimensional bursty interchange magnetic reconnection in the solar corona, we unveil that Alfvén waves are spontaneously excited in the reconnecting current sheet and propagate bidirectionally, mainly along unreconnected magnetic fields. Generated by the transient reconnection events, flux ropes with enhanced total pressure persistently displace the magnetic fields in their surrounding, launching the observed large-amplitude and quasi-linearly polarized Alfvén waves, which carry substantial energy for heating the quiet corona and accelerating the solar wind. Our findings underscore the natural association between Alfvén waves and intermittent magnetic reconnection, which can be generalized to various plasma systems in astrophysical and laboratorial environments.
The leading mechanism for the origin of the Interstellar Boundary Explorer (IBEX) “ribbon” of enhanced energetic neutral atoms (ENAs) from the outer heliosphere is the so-called secondary ENA process. In this mechanism, neutralized ions escape the heliosphere, and after several times of charge exchange collision,s some propagate back toward Earth in directions nearly perpendicular to the local interstellar magnetic field. However, the physical processes governing the distribution of the pickup ions (PUIs) outside the heliopause are still unclear. In this study, we build a new global model of the IBEX ribbon, where a key component is to calculate the dynamics of the PUIs outside the heliopause by solving the gyrophase-averaged focused transport equations on top of the background magnetohydrodynamic-kinetic model for the heliosphere-interstellar medium interaction. We discuss how the properties of the simulated ribbon change with different scattering parameters and show simulation results of the ENA sky maps, ribbon centers, ribbon profiles at several azimuthal slices, the ribbon ENA source region, and the velocity distribution of PUIs in the ENA source region for different scattering frequencies. Our results show that the model can provide reasonable ribbon sky maps comparable to the observed ribbon when the PUI mean free path is on the order of several thousand astronomical units.
On 2022 September 5, a large solar energetic particle (SEP) event was detected by Parker Solar Probe (PSP) and Solar Orbiter (SolO) at heliocentric distances of 0.07 and 0.71 au, respectively. PSP observed an unusual velocity dispersion signature: particles below ∼1 MeV exhibited a normal velocity dispersion, while higher-energy particles displayed an inverse velocity arrival (IVA) feature, with the most energetic particles arriving later than those at lower energies. The maximum energy increased from about 20–30 MeV upstream to over 60 MeV downstream of the shock. The arrival of SEPs at PSP was significantly delayed relative to the expected onset of the eruption. In contrast, SolO detected a typical large SEP event characterized by a regular velocity dispersion at all energies up to 100 MeV. To understand these features, we simulate particle acceleration and transport from the shock to the observers with our newly developed SEP model—Particle ARizona and MIchigan Solver on Advected Nodes. Our results reveal that the IVA and delayed particle onset detected by PSP originate from the time-dependent diffusive shock acceleration processes. After shock passage, PSP’s magnetic connectivity gradually shifted due to its high velocity near perihelion, detecting high-energy SEPs streaming sunward. Conversely, SolO maintained a stable magnetic connection to the strong shock region where efficient acceleration was achieved. These results underscore the importance of spatial and temporal dependence in SEP acceleration at interplanetary shocks and provide new insights to understand SEP variations in the inner heliosphere.
We present a comprehensive statistical analysis of ion-scale waves including dual-band ion-scale waves (DBIWs) observed by the Parker Solar Probe in the solar wind. DBIWs are characterized by the simultaneous occurrence of distinct left- and right-handed polarized wave packets at higher and lower frequencies, respectively, in the spacecraft frame, implying the presence of bidirectionally propagating L-mode waves. We identify and compare DBIWs to single-band ion-scale waves (SBIWs) and investigate their spatial distributions, background magnetic field conditions, and associated inertial range turbulence characteristics. We find that DBIWs exhibit a strong preferential occurrence at heliocentric distances between 0.2 and 0.25 au (equivalently 43 and 54 R _S ) in contrast to SBIWs, the occurrence rate of which peaks closer to the Sun and decreases with the heliocentric distance. DBIWs are also preferentially observed under conditions of strong Alfvénic turbulence, characterized by low magnetic compressibility and perpendicular-dominant fluctuations. These findings support a scenario in which stochastic ion heating via sufficiently large perpendicular Alfvénic fluctuation generates the ion temperature anisotropies required to excite bidirectional ion cyclotron waves. This work advances our understanding of kinetic wave generation in the solar wind and its connection to large-scale turbulence.
We have analyzed the solar wind properties associated with a comparable number of the heliospheric current sheet (HCS) crossing events by Parker Solar Probe (PSP) ranging from 0.07 to 0.3 au and Advanced Composition Explorer (ACE) at 0.99 au. Nearly all PSP events (7 out of 8) show signatures of magnetic reconnection, which are more frequent than the ACE events (5 out of 8) that show reconnection. Because the HCS reconnection events have occurred in a variety of wind speeds and plasma conditions, for each event, we propose to define an approximate aspect ratio (width/length) of HCS as the ratio between the absolute HCS width (derived from observations) and the distance traveled by Alfvén waves over the propagation time of the solar wind. We find that the aspect ratio defined in such a way tends to be smaller than 0.01 for most reconnecting events, and becomes much larger than 0.01 for non-reconnecting events. This analysis also explains the different occurrence rates of reconnection observed by PSP and ACE. Potential consequences of magnetic reconnection at the HCS are discussed.
This paper presents a comprehensive exploration of the Interstellar Boundary Explorer energetic neutral atom (ENA) ribbon, focusing on its spatial and temporal variations over 14 yr. Methodological advancements, including a refined map modeling procedure and a new ribbon separation technique with appropriate error propagation, enable a detailed investigation of the ribbon’s features. Utilizing statistically robust metrics, this study reveals details of the ribbon across energy and time. Key findings include energy- and time-dependent variations in flux, angular radius, ribbon profile width, and higher moments. By applying these metrics, we reveal new complexity to the evolution of the ribbon over time, highlighting the nuanced relationship between it and the solar wind. Furthermore, the study examines for the first time the ribbon as it passes through the starboard/heliotail region (Lon _EC 120°–180°), revealing properties distinct from other portions of the ribbon. The analysis uncovers an anticorrelation between ribbon width and flux, which provides quantitative support for a multisource ribbon created by a combination of solar wind neutrals that generate a spatiall narrow ribbon component and heliosheath neutrals giving rise to a broad component. Finally, differences in the temporal evolution of the ENA flux at different energies provide additional support that the location of the ribbon source region is beyond the heliopause.