Understanding the mechanical effects of crystals on degassing kinetics and permeability development in silicic magmas is important for modeling eruptions and examining first order controls on eruption style. We conducted high-pressure-high-temperature isothermal decompression experiments to investigate the role of crystal shape on permeability development and pore pathway geometry. Experiments were performed on hydrous rhyolitic glass (76.3 wt.% SiO2) seeded with variable amounts of equant (aspect ratio ∼1.8 ± 0.6) corundum crystals and elongate (aspect ratio ∼10 ± 5.5) wollastonite crystals to approximate natural phenocryst and microphenocryst/microlite populations, respectively. We measured total porosity, connected pore volume and permeability directly from the experimental charges by applying Archimedes' principle to determine bulk density, helium-pycnometry to measure connected porosity, and a custom-made permeameter to measure permeability. The experimental samples developed permeability at a critical melt porosity (ϕc-melt, above which degassing is enhanced due to bubble coalescence) of ∼55 vol.% vesicles for the corundum experiments and ∼48 vol.% for the wollastonite-bearing experiments; these values are considerably lower than the ϕc-melt>63 vol.% for prior crystal-free experiments (Lindoo et al., 2016; deGraffenried et al., 2019). Critical porosity is reduced when crystals comprise at least ∼20 vol.%, regardless of shape. Connected porosity increases and average bubble size decreases with increasing abundance of elongate wollastonite crystals, explained by the onset of yield strength behavior induced by loosely touching crystal frameworks that form at decreasing crystallinities with increasing elongation of crystals comprising the network. When the population of high-aspect-ratio crystals reaches random loose packing, the resulting reduction in interstitial melt available for unimpeded bubble expansion forces the bubbles to connect at lower total vesicularity. It therefore seems likely that crystal-bearing intermediate magmas experience an abrupt increase in degassing efficiency when crystallinity attains random loose packing. In hydrous magmas, the efficiency of decompression-driven degassing and resulting formation of anisotropic groundmass crystals is controlled by magma composition and decompression rate. Enhanced gas loss in slowly ascending (and crystallizing) magma may aid the development of dense conduit plugs, thus increasing the possibility of violent Vulcanian explosions.
In 1999–2001, Guagua Pichincha volcano, Ecuador, produced a series of cyclic explosive and effusive eruptions. Rock samples, including dense blocks and pumiceous clasts collected during the eruption sequence, and ballistic bombs later collected from the crater floor, provide information about magma storage, ascent, decompression, degassing, repressurization, and regassing prior to eruption. Pairs of Fe-Ti oxides indicate equilibrium within 1.2–1.5 log units above the NNO oxidation buffer and equilibrium temperatures from 805 to 905 °C. Melt inclusions record H 2 O contents of 2.7–4.6 wt% and CO 2 contents (uncorrected for CO 2 segregation into bubbles) from 19 to 310 ppm. Minimum melt inclusion saturation pressures fall between 69 and 168 MPa, or equilibration depths of 2.8 and 6.8 km, the lower end of which is coincident with the maximum inferred equilibration depths for the most vesicular breadcrust bombs sampled. Amphibole phenocrysts lack breakdown rims (except for one sample) and plagioclase phenocrysts have abundant oscillatory compositional zones. Plagioclase areal microlite number densities ( N a ) range over less than one order of magnitude (8.9×10 3 –8.7×10 4 mm -2 ) among all samples, with the exception of a dense, low crystallinity sample ( N a = 3.0×10 3 mm −2 ) and a pumiceous sample erupted on 17 December 1999 ( N a = 1.7×10 3 mm −2 ). Plagioclase microlite shapes include tabular, hopper, and swallowtail forms. Taken together, the relatively high plagioclase microlite number densities, the high number of oscillatory zones in plagioclase phenocrysts, the presence of CO 2 in groundmass glass, seismicity, and time-varying tilt cycles provide a picture of sudden evacuation of magma residing at different levels in the shallow conduit. Explosive eruptions punctuate inter-eruptive repose periods marked by time-varying rates of degassing (volatile fluxing) and re-pressurization. Shallow residence time in the conduit was sufficient to allow precipitation of silica-phase in the groundmass, but insufficient to allow breakdown of hornblende phenocrysts, with the one exception of the final dome sample from 2000, which has the longest preceding repose time. These results support a model of cyclic pressure cycling, volatile exsolution and regassing, and magma decompression decoupled from ascent.
Understanding the mechanical evolution of magmatic systems requires careful assessment of their rheological characteristics, particularly in light of the growing evidence that magma reservoirs are dominated by magma‐mush surrounded by thermally‐altered host‐rock. To address this complexity, we develop models for volcano deformation based on a poroviscoelastic source within a thermo‐viscoelastic host. We use Finite Element modeling to investigate the rheological and mechanical response to melt injection in a Maxwell poroviscoelastic reservoir hosted in a temperature‐dependent standard linear solid viscoelastic (“thermo‐viscoelastic”) crust. Our models consider the competing roles of poroelastic diffusion, and viscoelastic creep and relaxation. All cause time‐dependent post‐injection deformation. Post‐injection deformation of a poroviscoelastic reservoir in an elastic crust is dominated by poroelastic diffusion, a consequence of the short relaxation timescale of a hot and relatively low viscosity mush. For cooler, more viscous mush, the magnitude of viscoelastic deformation increases, supplementing the deformation caused by post‐injection poroelastic diffusion. Thermo‐viscoelasticity of the crust amplifies the poroelastic deformation response of the magma‐mush, leading to increased time‐dependent deformation both during and after melt injection. The rate of post‐injection surface deformation decreases at a rate proportional to the reservoir temperature. Crucially, our model sensitivity analysis demonstrates that the wall rock thermo‐viscoelastic response contributes more to surface deformation than the viscous effect of the magma‐mush. For this reason, neglecting the viscoelastic properties of the host rock and the poroelastic properties of the reservoir in interpretations of surface deformation data could produce errors in inferred processes (e.g., injection duration) and subsurface characteristics (e.g., reservoir compressibility, shape and depth).
Pululahua is an active volcano located 15 km north of Quito, Ecuador, that comprises sixteen dacitic-andesitic lava domes and a 13 km2 sub-rectangular depression formed between ~ 2.6 and ~ 2.3 ka. We use a detailed study of 70 flow and fall deposits that make up the pyroclastic sequence to show that the depression, previously classified as a caldera, was formed by numerous Vulcanian to (sub-) Plinian eruptions that destroyed both earlier and co-eruptive lava domes. We support this interpretation with field work, analysis of grain size distributions, density and components of 24 key deposits, supplemented by textural and petrologic analyses of 16 juvenile pyroclasts from throughout the pyroclastic sequence. These data document an alternation of (sub-) Plinian and Vulcanian eruptions dominated by denser juvenile material that preserves microtextural variations indicating changes in shallow level magma storage accompanying Vulcanian explosions. An exploratory examination of phenocryst textures and plagioclase and amphibole rim compositions suggests that much of the eruptive activity was driven by repeated inputs of less evolved magma into the Pululahua magmatic system. The inferred sequence of events provides a new hypothesis for the formation of the current morphology of Pululahua, including multiple episodes of both effusive and explosive eruptions accompanied by vent migration. Our findings offer an important insight into Pululahua’s potential future hazard scenarios, which could affect millions of people.
When volcanic eruptions involve interaction with external water (hydrovolcanism), the result is an ash-rich and energetic volcanic plume, as illustrated dramatically by the January 2022 Tonga eruption. The origin of the high explosive energy of these events remains an important question. We investigate this question by studying Prince Rupert’s Drops (PRDs)—tadpole-shaped glass beads formed by dripping molten glass into water—which have long fascinated materials scientists because the great strength of the head contrasts with the explosivity of the metastable interior when the tail is broken. We show that the fragment size distribution (FSD) produced by explosive fragmentation changes systematically with PRD fragmentation in air, water, and syrup. Most FSDs are fractal over much of the size range, scaling that can be explained by the repeated fracture bifurcation observed in three-dimensional images from microcomputed tomography. The shapes of constituent fragments are determined by their position within the original PRD, with platey fragments formed from the outer (compressive) shell and blocky fragments formed by fractures perpendicular to interior voids. When molten drops fail to form PRDs, the glass disintegrates by quench granulation, a process that produces fractal FSDs but with a larger median size than explosively generated fragments. Critically, adding bubbles to the molten glass prevents PRD formation and promotes quench granulation, suggesting that granulation is modulated by heterogeneous stress fields formed around the bubbles during sudden cooling and contraction. Together, these observations provide insight into glass fragmentation and potentially, processes operating during hydrovolcanism.
The scarcity of historical rhyolite eruptions means that volcanological and petrological studies of past eruptions are a key tool for assessing the potential for future hazardous activity and improving interpretations of unrest signals. For the last 18 ky, the Laguna del Maule (LdM) volcanic complex in Chile has erupted primarily rhyolites but with differing magma compositions, eruption styles and eruptive volumes. Rapid surface uplift and episodic seismic activity at LdM over the last two decades has emphasized the need to understand both the recent evolution of the magmatic system and the most likely future eruption scenarios. Using mineral composition, geothermobarometry and MELTS modeling, we assess the influence of the magma storage and ascent conditions on the magnitude and styles of three LdM rhyolites. Magmas of the first and largest Plinian-ignimbrite eruption (LdM: rdm; >17 km(3) DRE) form a distinct mineral assemblage with An(2)(8-)(60) plagioclase, amphibole and quartz derived from a magma plumbing system over a large pressure range (90-350 MPa). We suggest that the rdm eruption was triggered by magma recharge and overpressure within a similar to 90 MPa magma chamber of high-silica (>76.5 wt.% SiO2) rhyolitic melt. The rdm eruption appears to have reset the LdM storage conditions, such that subsequent rhyolite eruptions have been smaller (<4 km(3) DRE), involved less evolved melt (<75.8 wt.% SiO2) and produced (sub)Plinian-effusive eruption sequences. Of these, we have studied the earliest (Los Espejos: rle) and the most recent (Las Nieblas: rln). Both have mineral assemblages with An(20)(-3)(4) plagioclase and biotite formed in water-saturated crystal-poor rhyolite batches over limited pressure ranges (Delta P similar to 50 MPa) within a rhyodacitic mush reservoir. We suggest that rle and rln were triggered by injection of water-rich magma and volatile exsolution; the transition to effusive behavior occurred because of changes in magma temperature (rle) or magma decompression rate (rln). Similarities in the limited pressure range and high volatile content inferred for the current low-density magma body with the petrologically determined source conditions of magmas that fed past subplinian-effusive eruptions suggest that the next LdM eruption will be similar.
The breaking apart of magma into fragments is intimately related to the eruptive style and thus the nature and footprint of volcanic hazards. The size and shape distributions of the fragments, in turn, affect the efficiency of heat transfer within pyroclastic plumes and currents and the settling velocity, and so the residence time, of particles in the atmosphere. Fundamental work relating the glass transition to the fragmentation of magmas remains at the heart of conceptual and numerical models of volcanic eruptions. Current fragmentation criteria, however, do not predict the sizes and shapes of the resulting fragments, or fully account for the multiphase nature of magmas or ways in which magma can break in a fluidal manner or by thermal stress. The pulsatory, non-steady state nature of some eruptions, and related interactions with these fragmentation criteria, also requires further investigation. Here, we briefly review some recent advances in the field of magma fragmentation and provide a perspective on how integrated field, experimental and numerical modelling studies can address key outstanding challenges.
Flowing lava and water have dramatically different physical properties but can form similar hydraulic structures, including undular hydraulic jumps, or standing wave trains. In water flows, undular hydraulic jumps are evidence of critical flow (Froude number ∼1) and open‐channel hydraulic theory provides a powerful tool for estimating flow depth and velocity. Monitoring these parameters in an active lava channel is inherently challenging, but essential for calculating lava discharge (effusion rate), a primary control on the rate of flow front advance and ultimate flow runout distance. We analyze undular hydraulic jumps in both water and lava flows to assess the conditions under which they form and, by extension, the potential use of critical flow theory to estimate, in real time, lava flow velocity, depth, and discharge. Experimental data for water flows show that these structures mark the transition from supercritical to subcritical flow. Undular hydraulic jumps in the near‐vent lava channel of the 2018 lower East Rift Zone eruption of Kīlauea, Hawaiʻi also reflect critical flow conditions; their wavelengths scale with flow depth and velocity, consistent with hydraulic theory. Calculated lava effusion rates are similar to estimates made using more traditional approaches (Jeffreys', 1925, https://doi.org/10.1080/14786442508634662 , equation based on lava viscosity, density, and channel slope) and with lava volumes derived from topographic‐change mapping. From this we conclude that critical flow phenomena show great potential to track flow dynamics and inform hazard assessment for a wide range of geophysical fluids.
Open-vent, persistently degassing volcanoes—such as Stromboli and Etna (Italy), Villarrica (Chile), Bagana and Manam (Papua New Guinea), Fuego and Pacaya (Guatemala) volcanoes—produce high gas fluxes and infrequent violent strombolian or ‘paroxysmal’ eruptions that erupt very little magma. Here we draw on examples of open-vent volcanic systems to highlight the principal characteristics of their degassing regimes and develop a generic model to explain open-vent degassing in both high and low viscosity magmas and across a range of tectonic settings. Importantly, gas fluxes from open-vent volcanoes are far higher than can be supplied by erupting magma and independent migration of exsolved volatiles is integral to the dynamics of such systems. The composition of volcanic gases emitted from open-vent volcanoes is consistent with its derivation from magma stored over a range of crustal depths that in general requires contributions from both magma decompression (magma ascent and/or convection) and iso- and polybaric second boiling processes. Prolonged crystallisation of water-rich basalts in crustal reservoirs produces a segregated exsolved hydrous volatile phase that may flux through overlying shallow magma reservoirs, modulating heat flux and generating overpressure in the shallow conduit. Small fraction water-rich melts generated in the lower and mid-crust may play an important role in advecting volatiles to subvolcanic reservoirs. Excessive gas fluxes at the surface are linked to extensive intrusive magmatic activity and endogenous crustal growth, aided in many cases by extensional tectonics in the crust, which may control the longevity and activity of open-vent volcanoes. There is emerging abundant geophysical evidence for the existence of a segregated exsolved magmatic volatile phase in magma storage regions in the crust. Here we provide a conceptual picture of gas-dominated volcanoes driven by magmatic intrusion and degassing throughout the crust.
Volcanic ash transport and dispersion models (VATDMs) are necessary for forecasting tephra dispersal during volcanic eruptions and are a useful tool for estimating the eruption source parameters (ESPs) of prehistoric eruptions. Here we use Ash3D, an Eulerian VATDM, to simulate the tephra deposition from the ~ 7.7 ka climactic eruption of Mount Mazama. We investigate how best to apply a VATDM using the ESPs characteristic of a large magnitude eruption (M ≥ 7). We simplify the approach to focus on the distal deposit as if it were formed by a single phase of Plinian activity. Our results demonstrate that it is possible to use modern wind profiles to simulate the tephra dispersal from a prehistoric eruption; however, this introduces an inherent uncertainty to the subsequent simulations where we explore different ESPs. We show, using the well-documented distal Mazama tephra, that lateral umbrella cloud spreading, rather than advection–diffusion alone, must be included in the VATDM to reproduce the width of the isopachs. In addition, the Ash3D particle size distribution must be modified to simulate the transport and deposition of distal fine-grained (< 125 µm) Mazama ash. With these modifications, the Ash3D simulations reproduce the thickness and grain size of the Mazama tephra deposit. Based on our simulations, however, we conclude that the exact relationship between mass eruption rate and the scale of umbrella cloud spreading remains unresolved. Furthermore, for ground-based grain size distributions to be input directly into Ash3D, further research is required into the atmospheric and particle processes that control the settling behaviour of fine volcanic ash.
Tephra is a unique volcanic product with an unparalleled role in understanding past eruptions, long-term behavior of volcanoes, and the effects of volcanism on climate and the environment. Tephra deposits also provide spatially widespread, high-resolution time-stratigraphic markers across a range of sedimentary settings and thus are used in numerous disciplines (e.g., volcanology, climate science, archaeology). Nonetheless, the study of tephra deposits is challenged by a lack of standardization that inhibits data integration across geographic regions and disciplines. We present comprehensive recommendations for tephra data gathering and reporting that were developed by the tephra science community to guide future investigators and to ensure that sufficient data are gathered for interoperability. Recommendations include standardized field and laboratory data collection, reporting and correlation guidance. These are organized as tabulated lists of key metadata with their definition and purpose. They are system independent and usable for template, tool, and database development. This standardized framework promotes consistent documentation and archiving, fosters interdisciplinary communication, and improves effectiveness of data sharing among diverse communities of researchers.
The study of historic volcanic eruptions is often complicated by the lack of recorded primary data and observations of such events. In the case of large-magnitude historic eruptions, these types of data are important to better understand not only the physical nature of these rare events but also the volcanic and social impacts that follow. In this paper, we compile contemporary data on the Santa María Plinian eruption of 1902, in Guatemala. The data supplement those presented in the original research article [1] but individually provide an interesting and useful compilation of eyewitness testimonies, scientific studies and newspaper reports. We identify key contemporary sources containing quantitative data as well as various qualitative reports that we convert to quantitative measurements through a simple classification scheme. We also compile wind reanalysis data from the time of the eruption to display wind direction and speed with height. Both the data and the description of the methods of data analysis can aid future studies of qualitative (historic, eyewitness) to quantitative data conversion, as well as studies investigating this important eruption.
Laboratory experiments investigating syn-eruptive crystallization are fundamental for interpreting crystal and vesicle textures in pyroclasts. Previous experiments have advanced our understanding by varying decompression and cooling pathways, volatile components, and melt composition. However, they have largely failed to produce the high crystal number densities seen in many cryptodome and dome samples. This is feasibly due to the relatively simple decompression pathways employed in experimental studies. In this study, we approach the problem by exploring non-linear decompression pathways. We present two series of experiments: (1) decompression from low initial starting pressure and (2) a compression-and-release step after the initial decompression. The purpose of each series was to simulate (1) decompression of magma that stalls during ascent and (2) pressure cycling that occurs in non-erupted magma during episodic explosive activity. The experiments were carried out on a synthetic rhyodacite (SiO2 = 69 wt%) held initially at 50 MPa and 885°C then decompressed at rates of 0.026 and 0.05 MPa s−1 to 10 MPa A subset of experiments was then subjected to a compression step to 110 MPa followed by near-instantaneous release back to 10 MPa. A substantial volume fraction of dendritic microlites (ϕxtl = 0.27–0.32, Na = 4.79 × 103 mm–2) formed during the initial hold at 50 MPa; additional crystallization during subsequent decompression to ≥ 10 MPa was minimal, as evidenced by only small increases in crystallinity (ϕxtl = 0.28–0.33) and comparable crystal number densities (4.11–7.81 × 103 mm–2). Samples that underwent recompression followed by a second decompression showed no increase in crystal volume fraction but did show extensive disruption of the initial dendritic, box-work microlite structures that produced high number densities (Na = 43.5–87.2 × 103 mm–2) of small individual crystals. The disruption was driven by a combination of rapid vesiculation, expansion and resulting shear along the capsule walls. From these results, we suggest that high crystal number densities may be a signature of rapid deformation occurring after magma stalling in the subsurface, perhaps related to pressure cycling and accompanying rapid changes in vesicularity during repeated small and shallow-sourced explosions. We compare our experiments to pyroclasts from shallow intrusions that preceded the 18 May 1980 eruption of Mount St Helens. These pyroclasts were erupted both prior to 18 May, during episodic precursory explosive activity, and by the 18 May initial lateral blast. The pattern of precursory activity indicates multiple episodes of pressurization (prior to explosive events) and rapid decompression (during explosive events) that we use to illustrate the significance of our experimental results.
Large-magnitude volcanic eruptions are rare; for this reason, those that have occurred in recent history provide important case studies of syn- and post-eruptive impacts. One under-studied example is the 1902 Plinian eruption of Santa Maria volcano, Guatemala. Sources from the time tell us that volcanic ash from the eruption travelled thousands of kilometres and that associated hazards may have caused several thousand fatalities. Published estimates of erupted volume range from 4.3-48 km(3); the maximum estimates would make the fall deposit the largest of the 20th century. To improve constraints on the deposit extent and thickness, as well as on the immediate impacts of the eruption on local populations, we add to published accounts by compiling contemporary records reported in newspaper articles and telegrams quoted therein. We use these records to extend existing isopach maps and to calculate a fall deposit volume of at least 11.4 km(3); this is larger than fall deposits from Pinatubo (Philippines, 1991) and Quizapu (Chile, 1932), but smaller than the fall deposit produced by the 1912 eruption of Katmai (Alaska, USA). We also provide evidence that supports both high fatality estimates and intentional government suppression of the true impact of the eruption. (C) 2020 Published by Elsevier B.V.
Over the last 20 years, new concepts have emerged into understanding the processes that lead to build up to large silicic explosive eruptions based on integration of geophysical, geochemical, petrological, geochronological and dynamical modelling. Silicic melts are generated within magma systems extending throughout the crust by segregation from mushy zones. Segregated melt layers become unstable and can assemble into ephemeral upper crustal magma chambers rapidly prior to eruption. In the next 10 years, we can expect major advances in dynamical models as well as in analytical and geophysical methods, which need to be underpinned in field research.
Studies of magmatic systems have long used the textures of erupted samples to infer processes that control the location and duration of magma storage and drive volcanic eruptions from these storage regions. Models of volcanic processes and magmatic systems have evolved substantially over the past decades, in large part because of advances in analytical and experimental techniques. Cooling- and decompression-experiments have greatly enhanced our understanding of crystal textures produced by crystallization associated with volcanic eruptions, while advances in compositional mapping, isotopic analysis and diffusion chronometry provide the tools to unravel complex histories of individual crystals. Experiments, however, have failed to replicate the full range of groundmass textures observed in volcanic samples and the recognition that magma commonly includes both indigenous (grown from the transporting liquid) and exogenous (incorporated from elsewhere in the system) crystals complicates interpretation of crystal populations in volcanic samples. Analysis and interpretation of crystal size distributions (CSDs) and other physical measures of crystal populations, in particular, have yet to fully account for crystal populations with diverse origins and growth histories. Here I assess the extent to which experiments replicate observed crystal populations and thus can be used to improve understanding of volcanic processes. I then review conditions under which the size characteristics of crystal populations can be reasonably interpreted, examine possible reasons for experimental failure to achieve the very high crystal number densities that characterize some eruptive samples, and suggest ways to link CSD analysis to other techniques that seek to constrain the origin of the complex crystal populations. Finally, I show that compositionally based crystal size measurements are critical for interpreting different stages of crystal growth and can be yield well constrained growth histories if linked to diffusion time scales and phase constraints on crystallization conditions.
Lower-crustal seismicity is commonly observed in continental rift zones despite the crust at such depths being ductile enough to prohibit brittle failure. The source of such deep seismicity across the East African Rift remains an outstanding question. Here we present analysis of an isolated cluster of lower-crustal earthquakes located on the eastern border faults of the Main Ethiopian Rift, near the Corbetti caldera. Lower-crustal earthquakes have not previously been observed in this area. Phase arrival times were determined using an automated picking approach based on continuous wavelet transform and statistical changepoint detection methods. We overcome misinterpretations from large hypocenter depth errors by considering mixture distributions for all events and their associated uncertainties. These mixture distributions represent probability density functions of any event occurring at a given depth. The mixture distribution mode for a variety of different velocity models and error parameters remained stable at a depth of 28-32 km, with the vast majority of maximum likelihood estimates for individual hypocenters located at depths of 25-35 km. Most events occur over a 2 month period, with 90% of cumulative seismic moment occurring during March and April 2012. The ephemeral and localized nature of this seismicity, combined with low event magnitudes and regional hydrothermal/magmatic activity, suggests that these lower-crustal events are likely related to fluid or magmatic processes. Plausible mechanisms include the movement of magma and/or exsolution of volatiles at depth causing transient high strain rates and pore fluid pressures that induce seismicity.
Physical interactions between bubbles and crystals affect gas migration and may play a major role in eruption dynamics of crystal-rich magmas. Strombolian eruptions represent an end member for bubble-crystal interactions, in which large bubbles (significantly larger than the crystal size) rise through a crystal-rich near-surface magma. Indeed, volcanoes that produce Strombolian eruptions often generate ejecta with > 30 vol% (often > 45 vol%) average crystallinity. At Stromboli Volcano, Italy, average crystallinity can reach 55 vol%, which is approaching the eruptibility limit for magmas. At such high crystallinities the solids interact mechanically with each other and with bubbles. This complex rheology complicates the two-phase (liquid-gas) slug flow model often applied to Strombolian eruptions. To examine the effect of crystals on bubble rise, we performed analogue experiments in which large bubbles rise in a vertical tube filled with silicone oil and polypropylene particles. The particles have a slightly lower density than the oil, and therefore form a layer of oil + particles at the upper surface. We varied surface pressure, particle volume fraction, length of the particle-bearing cap, and bubble size to examine the ways in which these parameters influence Strombolian-type eruptions. We show that in experiments, suspended solids begin to affect bubble rise dynamics at particle volume fractions as low as 30 vol% (or, when divided by the random close packing value, a normalized particle fraction φ=0.64). Bubbles in experiments with higher particle contents deform as they rise and burst through a small aperture, generating surface fountains that begin abruptly and decay slowly, and longer-lasting acoustic signals of lower amplitude than in particle-poor experiments. Particle fractions > 38 vol% (φ>0.80) generated strong deformations on fast-expanding bubbles that applied a high stress on the cap, but they trapped bubbles that were less overpressured. Qualitatively, the gas release behavior observed in particle-rich experiments is consistent with observations of Strombolian eruptions. Moreover, we estimate that the observed crystallinity of pyroclasts at Stromboli volcano represents φ>0.8. From this we suggest a "weak plug" model for Strombolian eruptions that evolves towards a low-viscosity equivalent of Vulcanian-style plug failure with a more crystalline, stronger, and less permeable plug. Importantly, this model allows the rise of several bubbles in the conduit at the same time and suggests that longer-lasting, more pulsatory and complex eruptions may reveal an increase in near-surface crystallinity, shedding some light on changing conduit conditions that could help determine the different gas rise regimes involved in passive degassing, puffing, and different expressions of Strombolian explosions.
The sedimentation rate of volcanic ash through the atmosphere influences its travel distance, with important implications for aviation and health. The fall velocity of a particle depends on its size and density, but also shape, and volcanic ash is not spherical. To capture the sedimentation of ash, atmospheric dispersion models use empirical drag equations calibrated using geometric shape descriptors. However, particle shape data are scarce and there is no standard method of shape measurement. In addition, shape measurements are not always available during an eruption, when dispersion models are used operationally to forecast ash hazard. We assess the variability in the shape of volcanic ash from Icelandic eruptions using X-ray computed tomography. To consider how good different drag equations and shape descriptors are at representing the sedimentation of volcanic ash we compare calculated fall velocities to measured fall velocities of volcanic ash in air in a settling column. We then suggest the best drag equations and shape descriptors for use in atmospheric dispersion models. We find that shape-dependent drag equations produce more accurate results than a spherical approximation. However, accurate drag calculations based on the shape descriptor sphericity, which is a function of surface area, require the imaging resolution to be within the range of 10(2)- 10(5) voxels per particle (where a voxel is a volumetric pixel) as surface area is sensitive to imaging resolution. We suggest that the large-scale form of the particle impacts sedimentation more than small-scale surface roughness. Shape descriptors based on ratios between principal axis lengths are more practical as they are less variable among particle size classes and much less sensitive to imaging resolution. Finally, we use particle shape data from this study and literature sources to make recommendations on default values for use with atmospheric dispersion models where no shape data are available. Crown Copyright (C) 2020 Published by Elsevier B.V.