Significance of limb trauma as an initiating factor in chronic leg ulceration

Objectives: To assess differences in clinical outcomes between patients with traumatic and spontaneous leg ulcers. Methods: Consecutive leg ulcer follow-up patients seen between April 2004 and October 2005 in a specialist leg ulcer clinic were asked about the mechanism of the original ulceration. Twenty-four-week healing and 12-month recurrence rates were calculated using Kaplan-Meier analysis and outcomes were compared between groups with traumatic and spontaneous ulcers. Results: Of the 300 patients assessed, 38 were excluded (incomplete data). In the remaining 262 patients, cause of ulceration was traumatic in 116/262 (44%) and spontaneous in 146/262 (56%). Age, ankle brachial pressure index <0.85 and venous reflux were equally distributed between groups with traumatic and spontaneous ulcers (P = 0.470, 0.793, 0.965 respectively, Chi-square test). Twenty-four-week healing rates were 81% for traumatic and 67% for spontaneous ulcers (P = 0.015, Log-Rank test). Twelve-month recurrence rates were 32% for traumatic and 33% for spontaneous ulcers (P = 0.970, Log-rank test). Patients with traumatic ulcers suffered a total of 53 ulcer recurrences (median 0, range 0-4) compared with 89 in patients with spontaneous ulcers (median 0, range 0-8) (P < 0.001, Mann-Whitney U test). Conclusion: Approximately half of all leg ulcer patients recall a traumatic event. When managed in leg ulcer clinic, traumatic ulcers heal faster and recur less frequently than spontaneous ulcers.