Stability and quantization-error analysis of haptic rendering of virtual stiffness and damping

AbstractThe stable, quantization-error noise-free, rendering of high-stiffness dynamics can be challenging using impedance-type haptic displays. In this paper we examine a canonical, one degree of freedom, haptic display rendering a virtual spring and damper, including the effects of the device and human dynamics, sampling, position quantization, time delay, and the low-pass filter operating on the device velocity estimate. We construct various stability and quantization-error regions as a function of the system parameters and show the necessary trade-offs that occur between them. Although we apply the quantization-error analysis to virtual spring and damper rendering, it applies to a general virtual environment. We present sufficiency for quantization-error passivity, necessity for no malicious-touch limit cycles, and necessity for no uncoupled-touch limit cycles. Using these results, aided by the presented supplementary code, we find control parameters to render the largest, renderable, virtual stiffness for a given haptic display. The analytical results are experimentally verified using a Phantom Premium 1.5 haptic device.