Sexual isolation with and without ecological isolation between sympatric isopods Jaera albifrons and J. praehirsuta

Sexual isolation is often coupled with other barriers, and sexual isolation mechanisms can be intrinsically tied to ecological conditions or natural selection against heterospecific gene flow. The independence and relative strength of sexual isolation are thus difficult to assess. Here we take advantage of a pair of isopod species (Jaera albifrons and J. praehirsuta) that show sexual isolation and coexist in populations where they share the same habitat or not (i.e. without or with ecological isolation). Using no-choice trials and a free-choice experimental population, we estimated the strength of sexual isolation between J. albifrons and J. praehirsuta individuals originating from these different ecological contexts. We found that sexual isolation is strong in presence and absence of ecological isolation, but that it is asymmetric and fails to prevent gene flow entirely. Post-zygotic barriers were low, and there was no sexual isolation within J. praehirsuta across habitats. The J. albifrons / J. praehirsuta species pair thus provides an example where the role of sexual isolation as a barrier to gene flow i) does not depend upon current ecological isolation, ii) seems to have evolved independently of local ecological conditions and hybridization costs, but iii) is unable to complete speciation entirely on its own.