Learning Unknown Service Rates In Queues: A Multiarmed Bandit Approach

Consider a queueing system consisting of multiple servers. Jobs arrive over time and enter a queue for service; the goal is to minimize the size of this queue. At each opportunity for service, at most one server can be chosen, and at most one job can be served. Service is successful with a probability (the service probability) that is a priori unknown for each server. An algorithm that knows the service probabilities (the "genie") can always choose the server of highest service probability. We study algorithms that learn the unknown service probabilities. Our goal is to minimize queue regret: the (expected) difference between the queue lengths obtained by the algorithm and those obtained by the "genie." Because queue regret cannot be larger than classical regret, results for the standard multiarmed bandit problem give algorithms for which queue regret increases no more than logarithmically in time. Our paper shows surprisingly more complex behavior. In particular, as long as the bandit algorithm's queues have relatively long regenerative cycles, queue regret is similar to cumulative regret and scales (essentially) logarithmically. However, we show that this "early stage" of the queueing bandit eventually gives way to a "late stage," where the optimal queue-regret scaling is O(1/t). We demonstrate an algorithm that (orderwise) achieves this asymptotic queue regret in the late stage. Our results are developed in a more general model that allows for multiple job classes as well.