Comparison of a glycoprotein E-based ELISA with a varicella-zoster whole-virus ELISA for the quantification of varicella vaccine immune responses in young children.

Antibody response against varicella-zoster virus (VZV) is frequently assessed by whole-virus- (anti-VZV) or glycoprotein-based ELISAs. This study compared antibody concentrations measured by an assay quantifying anti-VZV glycoprotein E (anti-gE) and anti-VZV ELISA in 12–23-month-olds, receiving two varicella vaccine doses in a phase III trial (NCT02570126). Samples (pre- and 42 days post-each vaccination) initially tested with anti-VZV ELISA were re-tested with anti-gE ELISA. Of 1138 samples from 397 children, 757 were positive by anti-VZV (antibody concentration ≥25 mIU/mL) and 758 by anti-gE ELISA (≥97 mIU/mL). There were 375 double-negative and only 11 discrepant samples. The overall agreement was 99.03% (95% confidence interval: 98.28–99.52; McNemar p-value = 1). The ratio between antibody geometric mean concentrations (anti-gE/anti-VZV) for the 752 double-positive samples was 3.78 overall, 4.75 post-first, and 3.01 post-second vaccination. The anti-gE ELISA is a valid alternative for trials assessing antibody response to new varicella vaccines versus established ones, used as control.