Goal-Based Error Estimation for the Multi-Dimensional Diamond Difference and Box Discrete Ordinate (S-N) Methods

Goal-based error estimation due to spatial discretization and adaptive mesh refinement (AMR) has previously been investigated for the one dimensional, diamond difference, discrete ordinate (1-D DD-S-N) method for discretizing the Neutron Transport Equation (NTE). This paper investigates the challenges of extending goal-based error estimation to multi-dimensions with supporting evidence provided on 2-D fixed (extraneous) source and K-eff eigenvalue (criticality) verification test cases. It was found that extending Hennart's weighted residual view of the lowest order 1-D DD equations to multi-dimensions gave what has previously been called the box method. This paper shows how the box method can be extended to higher orders. The paper also shows an equivalence between the higher order box methods and the higher order DD methods derived by Hebert et al. Though, less information is retained in the final solution in the latter case. These extensions allow for the definition of dual weighted residual (DWR) error estimators in multi-dimensions for the DD and box methods. However, they are not applied to drive AMR in the multi-dimensional case due to the various challenges explained in this paper.