Investigation of a Prevascularized Bone Graft for Large Defects in the Ovine Tibia

In vivo bioreactors are a promising approach for engineering vascularized autologous bone grafts to repair large bone defects. In this pilot parametric study, we first developed a three-dimensional (3D) printed scaffold uniquely designed to accommodate inclusion of a vascular bundle and facilitate growth factor delivery for accelerated vascular invasion and ectopic bone formation. Second, we established a new sheep deep circumflex iliac artery (DCIA) model as an in vivo bioreactor for engineering a vascularized bone graft and evaluated the effect of implantation duration on ectopic bone formation. Third, after 8 weeks of implantation around the DCIA, we transplanted the prevascularized bone graft to a 5 cm segmental bone defect in the sheep tibia, using the custom 3D printed bone morphogenic protein 2 (BMP-2) loaded scaffold without prior in vivo bioreactor maturation as a control. Analysis by micro-computed tomography and histomorphometry found ectopic bone formation in BMP-2 loaded scaffolds implanted for 8 and 12 weeks in the iliac pouch, with greater bone formation occurring after 12 weeks. Grafts transplanted to the tibial defect supported bone growth, mainly on the periphery of the graft, but greater bone growth and less soft tissue invasion was observed in the avascular BMP-2 loaded scaffold implanted directly into the tibia without prior in vivo maturation. Histopathological evaluation noted considerably greater vascularity in the bone grafts that underwent in vivo maturation with an inserted vascular bundle compared with the avascular BMP-2 loaded graft. Our findings indicate that the use of an initial DCIA in vivo bioreactor maturation step is a promising approach to developing vascularized autologous bone grafts, although scaffolds with greater osteoinductivity should be further studied. Impact statement This translational pilot study aims at combining a tissue engineering scaffold strategy, in vivo prevascularization, and a modified transplantation technique to accelerate large segmental bone defect repair. First, we three-dimensional (3D) printed a 5 cm scaffold with a unique design to facilitate vascular bundle inclusion and osteoinductive growth factor delivery. Second, we established a new sheep deep circumflex iliac artery model as an in vivo bioreactor for prevascularizing the novel 3D printed osteoinductive scaffold. Subsequently, we transplanted the prevascularized bone graft to a clinically relevant 5 cm segmental bone defect in the sheep tibia for bone regeneration.