You Can't Learn What's Not There - Self Supervised Learning and the Poverty of the Stimulus.

Diathesis alternation describes the property of language that individual verbs can be used in different subcategorization frames. However, seemingly similar verbs such as drizzle and spray can behave differently in terms of the alternations they can participate in (drizzle/spray water on the plant; *drizzle/spray the plant with water). By hypothesis, primary linguistic data is not sufficient to learn which verbs alternate and which do not. We tested two state-of-the-art machine learning models trained by self supervision, and found little evidence that they could learn the correct pattern of acceptability judgement in the locative alternation. This is consistent with a poverty of stimulus argument that primary linguistic data does not provide sufficient information to learn aspects of linguistic knowledge. The finding has important consequences for machine learning models trained by self supervision, since they depend on the evidence present in the raw training input.