Strong sensitivity of watershed-scale, ecohydrologic model predictions to soil moisture

It is currently unclear how changes to modeled soil water simulations influence key predictions in complex, ecohydrologic models, particularly beyond hydrology. We assessed sensitivity to soil moisture in the Soil and Water Assessment Tool by artificially perturbing simulated soil moisture and analyzing targeted prediction change. Results demonstrated a strong, process-dependent sensitivity of model predictions to perturbations in soil moisture. At the basin scale, the absolute values of differences from a baseline simulation for surface runoff, evapotranspiration, and nitrate loss ranged from 42% to 107%, 29%–76%, and 19%–369%, respectively, for soil moisture changes between 0.5 and 2 standard deviations. Landscape-scale results illustrated the impact of modeled land management actions, notably fertilizer applications, on determining the magnitude of the change. The findings highlight and motivate the need to improve soil moisture simulations, suggesting possible accuracy improvement for key model predictions by more precisely simulating soil moisture.