Greater local adaptation to temperature in the ocean than on land

Abstract Warming threatens biodiversity but there is considerable uncertainty in which species and ecosystems are most vulnerable. Moreover, our understanding of organismal sensitivity is largely centered on species level assessments, which do not consider variation across populations. Here, we used meta-analysis to quantify differentiation in thermal tolerance across 413 populations from 105 species living in terrestrial, marine, and freshwater realms. Strikingly, we found strong differentiation in heat tolerance across populations in marine and intertidal taxa but not terrestrial or freshwater taxa. This is counter to the expectation that increased dispersal potential in the ocean should reduce intraspecific variation. Our findings are consistent with the “Bogert effect” operating in terrestrial but not marine ecosystems, which predicts that behavioral thermoregulation constrains evolution. Such adaptive differentiation in the ocean suggests that there may be standing genetic variation at the species level to buffer climate impacts. Assessments of organismal vulnerability to warming, especially in marine species, should account for variation in thermal tolerance among populations or risk under- or overestimating climate vulnerability.