Experimental Approach Alters N and P Addition Effects on Leaf Traits and Growth Rate of Subtropical Schima superba (Reinw. ex Blume) Seedlings

Nitrogen (N) and/or phosphorus (P) addition has controversial effects on tree functional traits and growth; however, this experimental approach may clarify these controversial results. In this study, field and pot experiments were designed with +N (100 kg N ha(-1) yr(-1)), +P (50 kg P ha(-1) yr(-1)), +NP (100 kg N plus 50 kg P ha(-1) yr(-1)), and a control (no N or P addition) to comparatively investigate the effects of N and P addition on 24 leaf traits and the growth rate of Schima superba (Reinw. ex Blume ) seedlings in subtropical China. We found that the experimental approach alters N and P addition effects on leaf traits and tree growth. Nitrogen addition strongly altered leaf biochemical and physiological traits and limited tree growth compared to P addition in the pot experiment, while the effects of N and P addition on leaf traits and tree growth were weaker in the field, since the seedlings might be mainly limited by light availability rather than nutrient supplies. The inference from the pot experiment might amplify the impact of N deposition on forest plants in complicated natural systems. These findings will help guide refining pot fertilization experiments to simulate trees in the field under environmental change. Future directions should consider reducing the confounding effects of biotic and abiotic factors on fertilization in the field, and refinement of the control seedlings' genetic diversity, mycorrhizal symbiont, and root competition for long-term fertilization experiments are required.