Minor differences in peptide presentation between chicken MHC class I molecules can explain differences in disease susceptibility

The highly polymorphic classical major histocompatibility complexes (MHCs) can confer resistance or susceptibility to diseases. The chicken MHC is known to confer decisive resistance or susceptibility to various economically-important pathogens, including the iconic oncogenic herpesvirus that causes Marek’s disease (MD). Only one classical class I gene, BF2, is expressed at a high level in chickens, so it was relatively easy to discern a hierarchy from well-expressed thermostable fastidious specialist alleles to promiscuous generalist alleles that are less stable and expressed less on the cell surface. The BF2*1901 is more highly expressed and more thermostable than the closely-related BF2*1501, but the data for peptide repertoire available did not obviously correlate as expected. Here, we confirm for newly-developed chicken lines that the chicken haplotype B15 confers resistance to MD compared to B19. Using gas phase sequencing of peptide pools, and using immunopeptidomics involving mass spectroscopy, we find that the BF2*1901 binds a greater variety of amino acids in some anchor positions than BF2*1501. However, by X-ray crystallography, we find that the peptide-binding groove of BF2*1901 is narrower and shallower. Though the self-peptides bound to BF2*1901 may appear more various than those of BF2*1501, the structures show that the wider and deeper peptide-binding groove of BF2*1501 allows it to tightly accept many more peptides overall, correlating with the expected hierarchies for expression level, thermostability and MD resistance. Moreover, the α2 helix of BF2*1901 is higher than BF2*1501, potentially reducing the number of T cell clones that can recognize this fastidious class I molecule. IMPORTANCE Disease susceptibility mechanism is complicated, but chicken infection of Marek’s disease (MD) is one of ideal models, considering the only one highly expressed classical MHC class I, BF2. The different susceptibility of the two close alleles BF2*1901 and BF2*1501 with minor difference of expression and thermostability is still unfathomed. Here, we confirm B15 chicken confers resistance to MD compared to B19. But the BF2*1901 binds a broader variety of anchoring peptides than BF2*1501. This mystery was solved by the structural determination of the two molecules with one similar peptide. The wider and deeper peptide-binding groove of BF2*1501 allows it to tightly accept many more peptides overall, which is concordant to the expected hierarchies for expression level, thermostability and MD resistance.