On the Satellite Plane Problem

We study the Satellite Plane Problem (SP) of the Milky Way (MW) by using the recently published simulation data of TNG50-1. Here, we only consider the satellite plane consisting of the brightest 14 MW satellites (11 classical satellites plus Canes Venatici I(CVn I), Crater II and Antlia II). Only one (among 231 candidates) MW-like halo (haloID=395, at z=0, hereafter halo395 ) possesses a satellite plane as spatially thin and kinematically coherent as the observed one has been found. Halo395 resembles the MW in a number of intriguing ways: it hosts a spiral central galaxy and its satellite plane is almost ($\sim 87^{\circ}$) perpendicular to the central stellar disk. In addition, halo395 is embedded in a sheet plane, with a void on the top and bottom, similar to the local environment of MW. More interestingly, we found that the major subset (11 of 14) of the satellite plane of halo395 arise precisely from the peculiar geometry of its large-scale environment (e.g. sheet and voids). However, the other three members just appeared at the right places with the right velocities by chance at z=0. Although the satellite plane of halo395 is transient and came into existence at z=0, the MW-like Large-scale environment indeed promotes the formation of the satellite plane. Our results support previous conclusions: SP is not a serious challenge to the $\Lambda$CDM model and its formation is ascribed to the right environment.