Falling for phishing attempts: An investigation of individual differences that are associated with behavior in a naturalistic phishing simulation.

•We investigated individual differences in cybersecurity behavior in a naturalistic phishing simulation.•We found that lower phishing email detection accuracy only modestly predicted riskier cybersecurity behavior.•Instead, fewer employment years and lower employee satisfaction and loyalty were most predictive of riskier behavior.•These results suggest that newer employees are more vulnerable to phishing attempts.•Furthermore, interventions that increase employee satisfaction might be effective at reducing risky cybersecurity behavior.