Human Performance Consequences of Normative and Contrastive Explanations: an Experiment in Machine Learning for Reliability Maintenance.
ARTIFICIAL INTELLIGENCE(2023)
Abstract
Decision aids based on artificial intelligence and machine learning can benefit human decisions and system performance, but can also provide incorrect advice, and invite operators to inappropriately rely on automation. This paper examined the extent to which example-based explanations could improve reliance on a decision aid that is based on machine learning. Participants engaged in a preventive maintenance task by providing their diagnosis of the conditions of three components of a hydraulic system. A decision aid based on machine learning provided advice but was not always reliable. Three explanation displays (baseline, normative, normative plus contrastive) were manipulated within-participants. With the normative explanation display, we found improvements in participants' decision time and subjective workload. With the addition of contrastive explanations, we found improvements in participants' hit rate and sensitivity in discriminating between correct and incorrect ML advice. Implications for the design of explainable interfaces to support human-AI interaction in data intensive environments are discussed.
MoreTranslated text
Key words
Human-AI interaction,Explainable AI,Automation reliance behavior,Automation transparency
求助PDF
上传PDF
View via Publisher
AI Read Science
AI Summary
AI Summary is the key point extracted automatically understanding the full text of the paper, including the background, methods, results, conclusions, icons and other key content, so that you can get the outline of the paper at a glance.
Example
Background
Key content
Introduction
Methods
Results
Related work
Fund
Key content
- Pretraining has recently greatly promoted the development of natural language processing (NLP)
- We show that M6 outperforms the baselines in multimodal downstream tasks, and the large M6 with 10 parameters can reach a better performance
- We propose a method called M6 that is able to process information of multiple modalities and perform both single-modal and cross-modal understanding and generation
- The model is scaled to large model with 10 billion parameters with sophisticated deployment, and the 10 -parameter M6-large is the largest pretrained model in Chinese
- Experimental results show that our proposed M6 outperforms the baseline in a number of downstream tasks concerning both single modality and multiple modalities We will continue the pretraining of extremely large models by increasing data to explore the limit of its performance
Upload PDF to Generate Summary
Must-Reading Tree
Example

Generate MRT to find the research sequence of this paper
Related Papers
INTERNATIONAL JOURNAL OF HUMAN-COMPUTER STUDIES 2025
被引用0
Fairness and Explainability for Enabling Trust in AI Systems
Human–Computer Interaction Series A Human-Centered Perspective of Intelligent Personalized Environments and Systems 2024
被引用0
Data Disclaimer
The page data are from open Internet sources, cooperative publishers and automatic analysis results through AI technology. We do not make any commitments and guarantees for the validity, accuracy, correctness, reliability, completeness and timeliness of the page data. If you have any questions, please contact us by email: report@aminer.cn
Chat Paper
GPU is busy, summary generation fails
Rerequest