Hydrosedimentary behavior of a field combining surface drains and tile drains

In agricultural fields, soil erosion is usually associated to surface runoff. However, in drained fields, tile drains are additional pathways for soil particles. Few studies have quantified erosion in drained fields and they mainly focused on tile drained fields, without considering fields combining surface and tile drainage. These studies show high inter-site and inter-annual variabilities that highlight the need for more annual quantifications of erosion in drained fields. Consequently, it is still difficult to quantify the relative importance of the factors affecting soil erosion in drained fields. In addition to a comprehensive review of the existing studies of erosion through drainage, this study aims at quantifying surface and subsurface erosion in a 5 ha cultivated field combining surface and tile drainage. Suspended sediments (SS) and water fluxes have been monitored during two years (2019-2020 and 2020-2021) at a high temporal resolution (1 min), both at the outlet of the tile drain network and at the outlet of the surface drainage rill. SS yield was 0.49 t ha-1 and 1.08 t ha-1 in 2019-2020 and 2020-2021, respectively. During 2019-2020 and 2020-2021, tile drainage contribution to the total runoff was 46% and 21%, respectively and its contribution to SS yield was 9% and 11%, respectively. High temporal resolution measurements of runoff and SS concentrations showed the suspended sediment concentration in the surface drain runoff only increase by 17% from the first to the second study year. Conversely, for tile drainage, average suspended sediment concentrations increased by 260%. These variations and the increase of surface runoff rate suggest a shift in water and sediment connectivity at the field scale. Cropping practices could have generated a slumping of the soil surface during the second year and, at the same time, the development of a macropore network in the subsoil. Cropping practices induced changes of surface horizon characteristics and their impact on the hydrosedimentary behavior of drained soils need to be further studied. This study confirms previous results concerning the temporal dynamics of SS exports in a drained context under temperate climate and adds a new quantification of hydrosedimentary fluxes in a surface and tile drained field separating surface drains and tile drains contributions.