External quality assessment for detection of colorectal cancer by Septin9 DNA methylation in clinical laboratories

Background and aims: The incidence and mortality rate of colorectal cancer (CRC) are increasing worldwide. Septin9 methylated (mSEPT9) DNA in circulation can be used as a non-invasive detection method to assist in the early diagnosis of CRC; however, the detection methods and procedures are complicated. This study aimed to evaluate the ability of clinical laboratories to detect Septin9 methylation in plasma cell-free DNA (cfDNA). Materials and methods: We prepared a sample panel consisting of positive and negative Septin9 methylation cells and CRC cells. Three positive samples with different methylation levels, one negative sample and one duplicate sample, two samples containing interference, three different CRC cell samples, and a fictitious case report were included. The panel was distributed to 59 laboratories for mSEPT9 analysis, result comparison, and scoring. Results: The sample panel, validated by National Medical Products Administration (NMPA)-approved tests and targeted bisulfite sequencing, met expectations and could be used for external quality assessment (EQA). Among the 59 laboratories, 55 (93.22%) correctly reported the mSEPT9 results for all samples, while four (6.79%) reported 15 false negatives and were considered improvable. All false negatives originated from four laboratories using laboratory-developed tests (LDTs), with three failing to detect weakly positive samples, samples containing interference, and samples from different CRC cells, and one reported erroneous results on all positive samples. Conclusion: Our results illustrated that the detection of mSEPT9 in cfDNA is satisfactory in China. EQA is indispensable because it can help improve the diagnostic capability and quality management of the laboratories, and provide suggestions for the problems existing in mSEPT9 detection.