Value vs. vulnerability: exploring asynchronous commenting in lecture-capture video recordings for undergraduate medical and dental students and its impact on learning through a pre and post survey design

Engagement through the use of technology requires a level of vulnerability and trust amongst teachers and learners. The emotional and social aspects of engagement can be significantly affected by the nuances of the learning setting. The study goal was to explore learner needs related to uploaded lecture-captured recordings and examine how the use of a commenting feature might enhance learning experiences. Building on self-determination theory, we postulated that affording commenting opportunities would increase engagement (relatedness), with learners choosing to engage in the potential learning value from comment over the vulnerability that could come with making public comments (autonomy), and improved learning outcomes (competence). Using a pre/post survey design, 100