A comprehensive study on combined organic fouling and gypsum scaling in reverse osmosis: Decoupling surface and bulk phenomena

Reverse osmosis (RO), as an energy efficient desalination technology that is critical to mitigate water scarcity, encounters feedwater containing both organic foulants and inorganic scalants. However, comparing with extensive studies on individual fouling or scaling, our knowledge of the behavior and mechanisms associated with combined organic fouling and mineral scaling is still lacking. Due to the potential occurrence of mineral formation in both bulk solution and on the membrane surface, a complete, mechanistic understanding of combined fouling and scaling requires decoupling of surface and bulk phenomena. Herein, our study employed a comprehensive investigation to delve into the intricate interplay of gypsum scaling and organic fouling in RO process. Our systematic approach is accomplished through three sets of experiments that include static experiments and two types of dynamic experiments (i.e., (1) combined fouling and scaling, and (2) gypsum scaling on foulant-conditioned membranes). A variety of model foulants including humic acid, alginate, bovine serum albumin (BSA), and lysozyme were used to investigate the effects of foulant type. Our results demonstrate that the behavior of combined organic fouling and gypsum scaling aligns more with that of gypsum scaling on foulantconditioned membranes rather than static experiments where bulk nucleation occurs, indicating the predominance of surface nucleation in RO. BSA exhibited a remarkable hindering effect on gypsum scaling, whereas other foulants displayed an additive effect. The lack of scaling mitigation by lysozyme suggests that molecular properties of protein must play a role in regulating the behavior of combined fouling and scaling. Results from multiple characterization techniques reveal the foulant-scalant interactions by delineating the morphological and chemical features of the fouling/scaling layers. Our study not only elucidates the mechanisms of combined organic fouling and gypsum scaling but also sheds light on potential strategies for membrane scaling control in RO desalination.