Effect of Passaging on Bovine Chondrocyte Gene Expression and Engineered Cartilage Production

Tissue engineering strategies show great potential for repairing osteochondral defects in osteoarthritic joints; however, these approaches often rely on passaging cells multiple times to obtain enough cells to produce functional tissue. Unfortunately, monolayer expansion culture causes chondrocyte dedifferentiation, which is accompanied by a phenotypical and morphological shift in chondrocyte properties that leads to a reduction in the quality of de novo cartilage produced. Thus, the objective of this study was to evaluate transcriptional variations during in vitro expansion culture and determine how differences in cell phenotype from monolayer expansion alter development of functional engineered cartilage. We used an unbiased approach to explore genome-wide transcriptional differences in chondrocyte phenotype at passage 1 (P1), P3, and P5, and then seeded cells into hydrogel scaffolds at P3 and P5 to assess cells' abilities to produce cartilaginous extracellular matrix in three dimensional (3D). We identified distinct phenotypic differences, specifically for genes related to extracellular organization and cartilage development. Both P3 and P5 chondrocytes were able to produce chondrogenic tissue in 3D, with P3 cells producing matrix with greater compressive properties and P5 cells secreting matrix with higher glycosaminoglycan/DNA and collagen/DNA ratios. Furthermore, we identified 24 genes that were differentially expressed with passaging and enriched in human osteoarthritis (OA) genome-wide association studies, thereby prioritizing them as functionally relevant targets to improve protocols that recapitulate functional healthy cartilage with cells from adult donors. Specifically, we identified novel genes, such as TMEM190 and RAB11FIP4, which were enriched with human hip OA and may play a role in chondrocyte dedifferentiation. This work lays the foundation for several pathways and genes that could be modulated to enhance the efficacy for chondrocyte culture for tissue regeneration, which could have transformative impacts for cell-based cartilage repair strategies. Impact statement Biological repair strategies that rely on expansion culture of allogenic chondrocytes result in significant changes in cell behavior, which impact tissue production. Findings from this study show how expansion culture causes chondrocytes from juvenile bovines, which are younger and healthier than human cell sources used in biological procedures such as matrix-induced autologous chondrocyte implantation, to behave like cells from osteoarthritic cartilage. Furthermore, we prioritized several pathways and genes that could be modulated to improve the success of chondrocyte culture for tissue regeneration. These findings have important implications for the development of effective cell-based replacements for cartilage defects.