Evaluation of PlanetScope-detected plant-specific phenology using infrared-enabled PhenoCam observations in semi-arid ecosystems

Phenology detection from remotely sensed data remains challenging in semi-arid ecosystems due to the unique spatial heterogeneity and irregular temporal growth in plants. PlanetScope imagery, with fine spatial and temporal resolutions, is revolutionizing the earth observation sector. It has demonstrated its effectiveness in monitoring phenology dynamics across various terrestrial ecosystems. However, the quality and accuracy of PlanetScope data for depicting plant growth development and detecting phenological metrics (phenometrics) in semi-arid environments have not been systematically examined. In this study, we evaluated the capability of PlanetScope for monitoring plant-specific phenology across the semi-arid western United States, by comparing phenometrics (onsets of greenup, maturity, senescence, and dormancy) retrieved from time series of two PlanetScope vegetation indices (VI), which are EVI2 (two-band Enhanced Vegetation Index) and NDVI (Normalized Difference Vegetation Index), with a set of PhenoCam observations at 15 sites. To conduct a comprehensive comparison, PhenoCam time series and phenometrics were extracted from infrared-enabled PhenoCam EVI2 and NDVI, as well as commonly used PhenoCam GCC (Green Chromatic Coordinate). Our results show that (1) time series of PlanetScope VI were consistent with PhenoCam GCC and VI time series during greenup phase but moderately comparable during senescence phase, with an average R2 of 0.67 and 0.57 for greenup and senescence phases, respectively; (2) phenometrics derived from PlanetScope VI exhibited better agreement with those from PhenoCam GCC and VI in greenup phase (greenup and maturity onsets) than in senescence phase (senescence and dormancy onsets), with an average R2 of 0.81, 0.84, 0.72, and 0.53 for greenup, maturity, senescence, and dormancy onsets, respectively; (3) PlanetScope-detected senescence onset and dormancy onset were systematically later than PhenoCam-based retrievals with a mean systematic bias of 12.6 days and 18.2 days, respectively; (4) phenometrics derived from PlanetScope VI were more comparable with PhenoCam VI retrievals than with PhenoCam GCC retrievals, which are reflected in better correlations and smaller bias between phenometrics, especially during senescence phase; and (5) PlanetScope and PhenoCam EVI2 time series produced the most comparable phenometrics, suggesting that EVI2 is an optimal index for vegetation phenology detections from different sensors. In summary, this study suggests PlanetScope has the ability to detect plant-specific phenology and to improve our understanding of phenology dynamics in heterogeneous semi-arid ecosystems at fine scales.