Sensitivity of the airway smooth muscle in terms of force, shortening and stiffness

Eight pig tracheal strips were stimulated to contract with log increments of methacholine from 10-8 to 10-5M. For each strip, the concentration-response was repeated four times in a randomized order to measure isometric force, isotonic shortening against a load corresponding to either 5 or 10% of a reference force, and average force, stiffness, elastance and resistance over one cycle while the strip length was oscillating sinusoidally by 5% at 0.2Hz. For each readout, the logEC50 was calculated and compared. Isotonic shortening with a 5% load had the lowest logEC50 (-7.13), yielding a greater sensitivity than any other contractile readout (p<0.05). It was followed by isotonic shortening with a 10% load (-6.66), elastance (-6.46), stiffness (-6.46), resistance (-6.38), isometric force (-6.32), and average force (-6.30). Some of these differences were significant. For example, the EC50 with the average force was 44% greater than with the elastance (p=0.001). The methacholine sensitivity is thus affected by the contractile readout being measured.