Analysis and diagnosis of abnormal SLR validation results for BeiDou-3 SECM-B MEO C225 and C226 satellite orbits

Satellite laser ranging (SLR) is the only stand-alone and external tool for verifying the accuracy of microwave-based GNSS orbits. On February 2, 2023, the International Laser Ranging Service initiated the SLR global tracking campaign for the complete BeiDou-3 medium Earth orbit (MEO) constellation. This initiative provides an opportunity to unveil the potential issue for BeiDou-3 MEO orbit modeling. An examination of the SLR validation results of precise BeiDou-3 MEO orbits across different IGS/Multi-GNSS Experiment (MGEX) analysis centres (ACs) reveals that the SLR residual standard deviation for BeiDou-3 SECM-B MEOs C225 and C226 orbits reaches 18 cm. This figure is approximately four to nine times those for other BeiDou-3 MEOs. This contradicts the fact that the orbit quality of C225 and C226 is comparable to other satellites. By analyzing the correlation between SLR residuals and de-trend clock residuals, detector-specific bias performance, and the distribution characteristics of SLR residuals relative to satellite azimuth and nadir angles, we diagnose that abnormal SLR validation results for C225 and C226 originate from a large deviation in the official horizontal offsets for the laser retroreflector arrays (LRAs) in the satellite reference frame. LRA horizontal offsets for C225 and C226 are estimated based on SLR residuals. With our adjusted LRA offset estimates, the SLR residual metrics for C225 and C226 orbits (across various IGS/MGEX ACs) are comparable to the results obtained for other BeiDou-3 MEOs. Additionally, our adjustments enable the identification of their orbit modeling errors across different IGS/MGEX ACs according to the pattern of SLR residual variation. From the study, spacecraft manufacturers should be encouraged to conduct a comprehensive review of ground calibrations for BeiDou LRA offsets. This is crucial for optimizing BeiDou orbit model and enhancing its applications in high-precision geosciences.