Knowledge co-production (KCP) between science and practice is essential to address complex social-hydrogeological challenges. However, there is a need to clarify and operationalize KCP within collaborative research. This study characterizes KCP and evaluates its impact on developing sustainable groundwater management strategies based on two case studies in Europe, where transdisciplinary research enabled scientists and stakeholders to collaboratively develop sustainable groundwater management strategies. Utilizing workshop evaluations, ethnographic field notes, an interdisciplinary interview, and reflection meetings, the study identifies when, where, and how KCP occured within the transdisciplinary processes. Moreover, the study evaluates the value of interdisciplinary collaboration between natural and reflexive sciences to enhance groundwater management. The results reveal that KCP can be characterized by specific instances where diverse knowledge converged, occurring at interdisciplinary (within science), intersectoral (among stakeholders), and transdisciplinary (between science and stakeholders) levels. The study found that interdisciplinary KCP enhanced comprehensive system knowledge among scientists, while transdisciplinary KCP established a normative foundation for sustainable groundwater management. Intersectoral KCP improved collaboration efficiency among stakeholders. The collaboration between natural and reflexive science supported a critical examination of methods, objectives, and approaches employed, fostering a deeper understanding of site-specific groundwater-related challenges and enabling the development of tailored management actions. Evaluation of the collaborative research processes deepened the understanding and impacts of KCP, informing future research design for sustainability problem-solving. However, facilitating and evaluating KCP requires sufficient resources. The presented design of a transdisciplinary process, including KCP instances and evaluation principles, can guide other case studies to enable, evaluate, and sustain KCP.
The article focuses on the development of a risk management plan for small-scale water reuse system in Wei ss enberge, Germany. The reuse system comprises of wastewater treatment ponds, cloth filter, activated carbon biofilter, sandfilter, UV disinfection and a hydroponic tomato cultivation. Multi-stakeholder consultations, pre-validation and preliminary monitoring led to a low-risk perception during the risk assessment. Technical and non-technical barriers before and after the point of compliance resulted in a high level of safety confirmed during the operation. Remaining challenges in implementing EU regulation 2020/741, such as validation monitoring are discussed. Experiences made during the operation of the water reuse system as well as a review of scientific publications indicate that hydroponic cultivation does not have any increased risk compared against other cultivation methods.
Human health is fundamental to the lives of individuals and societies. The dramatic decline in biodiversity is one of the most fundamental threats to the foundations of human life. Collected, cultivated and purchased plants have traditionally been used for their therapeutic, preventive or palliative effects on human health and well-being, and are deeply intertwined with culture and history. The IPBES report on the sustainable use of wild species in 2022 highlights the importance and contribution of the use of wild plants to global biodiversity conservation. However, there is still little reliable knowledge about the exact relationship between biodiversity and human health. In this paper, we argue that the example of knowledge and use of medicinal plants could be very well suited for a better understanding of the relations and interactions between biodiversity and health. From the perspective of Social Ecology, we advocate an inter- and transdisciplinary research approach that can provide both: system knowledge and transformation knowledge. We present the results of a conceptual study on knowledge and practices of medicinal plants in relation to their impact on human health and biodiversity in Germany. Community gardening, sustainable wild collection practices, and sharing of valuable local traditional knowledge can be possible pathways to conserve plant populations and knowledge. We argue that the practices around medicinal plants can create a reciprocal relationship between humans and these plants, leading to increased well-being and appreciation for them. To fully understand the impact of medicinal plants on health and biodiversity, it is necessary to move beyond a knowledge-focused analysis that has dominated literature to date and analyse the practices, benefits, and relationships between people, medicinal plants, and their ecosystems.
Per- und polyfluorierte Alkylsubstanzen (PFAS) sind langlebige Chemikalien, die vielfältig eingesetzt werden, sodass weltweit Menschen gegenüber PFAS exponiert sind. Dies bestätigt auch das deutsche Human-Biomonitoring-Programm, das PFAS in allen Proben nachweisen konnte. Der Beitrag untersucht anhand des deutschen Human-Biomonitorings Faktoren, die Ungleichheiten in der PFAS-Exposition bedingen (sozioökonomischer Status, Bildung, Alter, Geschlecht, Lebensstilfaktoren), und geht der Frage nach, ob sich entgegen der Annahme einer ubiquitären Verteilung ungleich verteilte Risiken finden lassen. Studien zur Gesundheitsgeographie oder Umweltgerechtigkeit verweisen darauf, dass Umweltlasten oft ungleich zulasten ärmerer Bevölkerungsschichten verteilt sind. Im Fall von PFAS zeigen jedoch Human-Biomonitoring-Daten, dass vor allem die Bevölkerung mit einem höheren sozioökonomischen Status (mit höherem Einkommen und besserer Bildung) stärker exponiert ist. Das wird auch auf Lebensstilfaktoren zurückgeführt, wie zum Beispiel die Verwendung von hochpreisigen Konsumprodukten, die PFAS enthalten. In diesem Beitrag wird darüber hinaus aufgezeigt, dass eine räumliche Analyse, welche ein feineres Bild von Ungleichheiten in der Exposition von PFAS ermöglicht, bislang im deutschen Kontext nur in begrenztem Umfang berücksichtigt wird. Denn oft sind es Punktquellen wie Produktionsstätten oder (Militär‑)Flughäfen, die zu Expositionen führen und in deren Nähe häufig wiederum ärmere Bevölkerungsschichten leben. Vor dem Hintergrund, dass das deutsche Human-Biomonitoring-Programm Gefahren und besonders belastete Gruppen früh erkennen soll, argumentiert der Beitrag, dass die Berücksichtigung von räumlichen Kontaminationsdaten dazu beitragen kann, umfassendere Aussagen zu treffen.