Recent efforts in AI ethics have been dominated by the proliferation of high-level principles intended to guide responsible development and deployment. Yet persistent implementation failures suggest that principlism and tool-based approaches alone do not cultivate the moral capacity required to govern sociotechnical systems. This article advances a formation-based framework for AI ethics that situates moral agency throughout the developmental conditions of design, use, and the AI lifecycle. Drawing on Aristotelian-MacIntyrean virtue ethics applied to media ecology, and sociotechnical responsibility, the argument reframes AI as a formative environment that shapes patterns of attention, judgment, delegation, and accountability over time. Against claims that complexity produces responsibility gaps, the paper develops a relational and procedural account of responsibility that is traceable across the AI lifecycle. It further introduces opportunity cost as a neglected ethical category, highlighting the cognitive and moral capacities forfeited when optimization and seamless delegation displace deliberation or self-governance. By integrating character formation, responsibility, and opportunity-cost analysis, the article offers a conceptual framework for ethical intervention across design, professional formation, and governance. The conclusion outlines implications for AI education and institutional oversight and calls for future empirical, interdisciplinary, and cross-cultural development of formation-based ethics.
A growing acceptance that many nonhuman animal communities have distinct cultures – group-variable patterns of behavior and information sustained over time by social learning – is beginning to reshape thinking about animal conservation. Culture, in this sense, can significantly influence how different populations interact with their environment and respond to environmental changes, and, therefore, has important implications for conservation. The literature on animal culture and conservation has led to valuable insights about how to protect endangered cultural animals. It has also led to some challenging questions. Should protecting animal cultural diversity become a new conservation goal, along the lines of preserving biodiversity? Should culture be an important consideration in prioritizing populations for conservation? Should we be designating animal “cultural heritage sites” for special protection, analogous to heritage sites of special significance for humans? This paper explores these questions and various arguments for preserving animal culture that have been offered in the literature. These include both instrumental arguments and arguments that suggest that animal cultures are of intrinsic value in their own right. These arguments raise important considerations, but they do not address all the ways in which animal cultures matter. We argue for more sustained attention to animals’ own interests in culture: animal cultures matter first and foremost because they matter to the animals themselves. Animals’ interests with respect to culture are not only about preserving practices or geographical locations, but include more abstract interests in protecting opportunities for agency, self-determination, and changing cultural traditions.
Feedback is a cornerstone of academic development, particularly in marketing education, where skill development often requires iteration and applied practice. While instructors spend considerable time providing effective feedback, artificial intelligence (AI) tools can significantly reduce this burden by generating timely, tailored responses. For example, AI-based chatbots can supplement instruction, providing students with timely feedback and reducing instructors' workload. This study examines how marketing students perceive feedback quality based on its source, specifically whether it is delivered by an AI system or a human instructor. Through a scenario-based experiment, we investigate student perceptions of feedback quality and effectiveness based on the source (AI vs. Instructor) or valence (positive vs. negative). Our findings provide guidance for professors who want to incorporate AI tools into their teaching practices. Understanding student perceptions of feedback source is crucial for marketing educators who want to leverage AI systems to enhance the educational experience without compromising the human component that students value.
This study investigates the impact of Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) usage, social media exposure, and their interaction on consumer financial stress, using a large, nationally representative dataset of U.S. households. Financial stress is measured by self-reported financial insecurity, credit card debt, and the use of check-cashing services. To address endogeneity and strengthen causal inference, the study employs a triangulated identification strategy that combines Propensity Score Matching, Doubly Robust Estimation, Extended Regression Models, and Conditional Mixed Process estimation. Across all methods, BNPL and social media independently exacerbate financial stress, while their joint exposure-conceptualized as digital co-exposure-compounds these effects, particularly by increasing unsecured debt and reliance on alternative financial services. For example, the propensity score matching results indicate that joint exposure to BNPL use and social media increases financial insecurity by approximately 0.34 points and unsecured debt by about 1.46 points, relative to comparable non-users. These findings support a behavioral amplification mechanism in which algorithmic targeting and frictionless credit access jointly erode financial self-regulation. For financial practitioners, the results underscore the importance of integrating behavioral and digital indicators into risk models, especially when assessing younger or financially vulnerable consumers. The study also informs regulatory and design interventions, including mandatory BNPL credit reporting, algorithmic transparency, and the use of digital nudges to mitigate impulsive spending. As fintech and social media ecosystems increasingly converge, understanding their interactive influence is essential for promoting consumer financial resilience.
ABSTRACT This article reviews the recent historiography of loyalism in revolutionary era Pennsylvania. Despite the British occupation of Philadelphia, few Pennsylvanians embraced outright loyalism, while many found themselves disaffected by the revolution. Historians have debated the extent to which Pennsylvania’s tightly knit communities created a revolutionary atmosphere of victimization or leniency for those disaffected. Recent studies also emphasize the victory of moderate politics by the revolution’s end, which returned many of these citizens to active political participation.