
OBJECTIVE Patient navigation is an evidence-based approach for increasing colorectal cancer (CRC) screening. Research examining common navigator activities to support cancer screening emphasizes helping patients address barriers to screening. Understanding the techniques navigators employ to resolve specific barriers to CRC screening could more precisely define the mechanisms by which navigation works and inform the design and evaluation of future programs. The Colonoscopy Outreach for Rural Communities trial assessed a patient navigation program to increase colonoscopy completion. In this article, we explore how the Colonoscopy Outreach for Rural Communities study navigator was able to help patients resolve barriers to completing primary screening colonoscopy, and under what circumstances the navigator was not successful. METHODS We used qualitative thematic analysis supported by the Framework Method to analyze navigator notes and interview transcripts to understand navigator resolution techniques. We conducted a descriptive analysis of navigation data to assess the proportion of barriers that were resolved for each participant in the program. RESULTS We identified eight navigation techniques for primary screening colonoscopy barrier resolution: educating about colonoscopies (colonoscopy education), providing information about the health care system (system education), facilitating patient conversations with health care teams or insurance (facilitation), bridging to the health care system to coordinate care on behalf of the patient (bridge), helping the patient with accountability (accountability), providing emotional support (support), brainstorming solutions with patients (brainstorming), and helping with interpretation and translation (interpretation). These techniques were particularly successful in resolving scheduling (88%), knowledge (98%), transportation (82%), and language (83%) barriers. CONCLUSIONS Understanding eight distinct techniques a navigator uses to support primary screening colonoscopy completion for colorectal cancer screening advances our understanding of how navigators can help patients resolve barriers to colonoscopy completion, and in what settings the techniques may be most effective. They may also offer a framework for design of navigation programs delivered both within and outside of the clinic setting. TRIAL REGISTRATION ClinicalTrials.gov. Identifier: NCT05453630. Registered July 6, 2022.
Objective: This study explored primary care physicians’ perspectives on Clinical Integration (CI) program performance, quality metrics, and incentive structures within a Physician Hospital Organization (PHO) serving a medically underserved urban community. The objective was to complement existing CI performance data by identifying contextual factors that influence physician performance and participation in value-based care programs. Methods: A qualitative study using a general inductive approach was conducted within a single PHO on Chicago’s South Side. All 10 independent primary care physicians participating in the PHO’s CI program completed semistructured interviews. Interview questions focused on social determinants of health, staffing, incentive structures, quality measurement, barriers to performance, and support needs. Interviews were transcribed and independently coded by two researchers. Through iterative coding and thematic analysis, preliminary codes were consolidated into higher-order themes. Results: Six major themes emerged. Physicians reported that low health literacy, socioeconomic hardship, and patient nonadherence reduced their ability to achieve quality targets and earn incentives. Staffing shortages and turnover hindered quality improvement activities and population health management. Participants viewed incentive structures as insufficient, poorly understood, and misaligned with the effort required to improve performance. Physicians also believed that CI performance metrics often failed to reflect the quality of care delivered to high-needs populations. Additional barriers included limited specialty care access, transportation challenges, patient mistrust of the health care system, and other social determinants affecting care engagement. Respondents identified increased administrative support, dedicated CI-focused staff, and improved specialty access as important facilitators of success. Conclusions: Standardized CI metrics and incentive structures may inadequately account for the realities of delivering primary care in underserved communities. PHOs, payers, and health system leaders should consider transparent incentive models, context-adjusted performance measures, enhanced staffing support, and investments in patient engagement and specialty care access to promote equitable performance assessment and strengthen value-based care programs.
Objective: Patient navigation is an evidence-based approach for increasing colorectal cancer (CRC) screening. Research examining common navigator activities to support cancer screening emphasizes helping patients address barriers to screening. Understanding the techniques navigators employ to resolve specific barriers to CRC screening could more precisely define the mechanisms by which navigation works and inform the design and evaluation of future programs. The Colonoscopy Outreach for Rural Communities trial assessed a patient navigation program to increase colonoscopy completion. In this article, we explore how the Colonoscopy Outreach for Rural Communities study navigator was able to help patients resolve barriers to completing primary screening colonoscopy, and under what circumstances the navigator was not successful. Methods: We used qualitative thematic analysis supported by the Framework Method to analyze navigator notes and interview transcripts to understand navigator resolution techniques. We conducted a descriptive analysis of navigation data to assess the proportion of barriers that were resolved for each participant in the program. Results: We identified eight navigation techniques for primary screening colonoscopy barrier resolution: educating about colonoscopies ( colonoscopy education ), providing information about the health care system ( system education ), facilitating patient conversations with health care teams or insurance ( facilitation ), bridging to the health care system to coordinate care on behalf of the patient ( bridge ), helping the patient with accountability ( accountability ), providing emotional support ( support ), brainstorming solutions with patients ( brainstorming ), and helping with interpretation and translation ( interpretation ). These techniques were particularly successful in resolving scheduling (88%), knowledge (98%), transportation (82%), and language (83%) barriers. Conclusions: Understanding eight distinct techniques a navigator uses to support primary screening colonoscopy completion for colorectal cancer screening advances our understanding of how navigators can help patients resolve barriers to colonoscopy completion, and in what settings the techniques may be most effective. They may also offer a framework for design of navigation programs delivered both within and outside of the clinic setting. Trial: registration: ClinicalTrials.gov. Identifier: NCT05453630. Registered July 6, 2022.
OBJECTIVES:The Michigan Region VII Area Agency on Aging (AAA) conducted a community care transition initiative (CCTI) for rural, low-income older adults to reduce hospital readmission rates. The AAA CCTI included a community health worker (CHW) home visit, pharmacist telehealth comprehensive medication review, and follow-up after discharge. Our study aimed to conduct a formative evaluation of the AAA CCTI to identify areas for program refinement. Identified strategies for program refinement add to the development, implementation, and evaluation of rural care transition program literature. METHODS:We conducted a qualitative study using semistructured interviews with key AAA CCTI informants via Zoom. Qualitative content analysis was used to identify categories related to existing resources, inputs needing adjustment, delivery of planned procedures, suggested procedural changes, and client responses. RESULTS:Five AAA CCTI staff members participated in an interview. The program's resources included AAA reputation, qualified CHWs, and strong external networks. The inputs needing adjustment were funding sustainability, CHW preparation, and the availability of key personnel. The implemented procedures were: CHWs receiving standard training, connecting clients with diverse external resources; an efficient combination of CHW home visits and telehealth pharmacist visits; in-depth CHW home visits; promoting the program to strengthen partnerships; serving older adults at considerable risk of readmission; streamlining recruitment; and person-centered care. The suggested procedure changes included adjusting the follow-up duration and frequency, implementing strategies to improve sustainability, and providing the program to broader populations. Most clients accepted and were satisfied with the program, while a few declined home visits. CONCLUSIONS:Our study provided a formative evaluation of the AAA CCTI to inform program refinement. Recommended refinements include adding pharmacist personnel, providing ongoing CHW training, and advocating for pharmacist-led care transitions. Our findings suggest including pharmacist telehealth during CHW home visits, in-person recruitment, and community resource referrals in rural care transition programs.