
On May 2, 1444, the city of Soest declared a feud against its lord, the Archbishop of Cologne, in order to submit to the Count of Cleves and Mark. This triggered a series of conflicts, especially since Cleves wanted to ally itself with the new Burgundian realm. The attempt by the Cologne archbishop Dietrich of Moers to establish a dominant power on the Rhine was thus thwarted. Many political parties participated therefore in this conflict. – The complicated language of the declaration of feud is rather typical for documents of this period. This may be due to the shift of the legal language from Latin to German and the uncertainty of finding equivalents for the unambiguous legal terms of Latin. Furthermore, the legal conflict resolution mechanisms, especially in the Soest case, demonstrate a lack of efficiency. The authorities of the Pope and Rome and the king in Austria failed to make a sufficient impact in the lawsuit of Soest and its parties. Despite the increasing papal diplomacy and the important figures deployed in this area, such as Nicholas of Cusa, the Pope failed to persuade the parties to make sufficient concessions. Similarly, the imperial court seemed to decide less according to law than according to the interests of the politically dominant parties. The laws used in this case came from different periods and contexts and seem to be used in favor of those in power. Arbitration remained the only means of resolving disputes, which, however, resulted in endless negotiations rather than clear results. This case illustrates that the imperial legal structures of the 12th and 13th centuries had lost their effectiveness, while the need for an imperial reform like that of 1495 gradually became apparent.