
Jhering's intellectual transformation from formalism to realism - manifested as a methodological transition from his early adherence to `conceptual jurisprudence' to his later advocacy of `teleological jurisprudence' - constitutes a profound response to the political and social upheavals of nineteenth-century Germany. In his early thought, Jhering maintained that legal formalism could effectively resist political arbitrariness and safeguard individual liberty, thereby providing the foundation for a lawful liberal state. He sought to replace the absence of constitutional governance with a systematic and autonomous science of private law that would secure a `system of freedom'. However, amid the unification wars and Bismarck's Realpolitik, Jhering came to recognize that rigid legal forms often proved inadequate to address the complexities of social and political reality. Consequently, he began to emphasize the role of `powerful personalities' and political decision-making, contending that in states of emergency, necessary acts of will could compensate for the limitations of legal form. Nevertheless, Jhering did not abandon his earlier ideals; he remained acutely wary of unchecked political power and insisted that such decisions must be justified and strictly constrained. Throughout his oeuvre, Jhering sought to reconcile form and will by advocating the institutionalization of political decision-making within a normative legal order. He underscored that freedom must be realized through the law and called upon political actors to embody classical virtues to ensure the legitimacy and moral integrity of their decisions.
Summary This article analyzes judicial practice in rape cases in socialist Czechoslovakia from a gender perspective. Based on case analysis and legal-historical research, it identifies key asymmetries in the interpretation and application of the rape offence, particularly in marital and group contexts. The study shows how courts often reclassified acts to lesser offences, thereby weakening protection of women’s sexual autonomy. It reveals how gendered stereotypes and traditional norms influenced evidentiary standards, sentencing, and perceptions of victim credibility. The findings highlight the gap between the formal legal framework and its real-world implementation.
Summary This article offers a critical review of Filippo Bonin’s book1 on the organization of justice between Diocletian and Constantine, reconstructing its methodological framework, argumentative structure, and principal findings. It focuses in particular on key problematic issues addressed by the author – as the configuration of cognitio vice sacra , the system of appeals, and the reform of the praetorian prefecture – evaluating the proposed interpretations against the available sources and current historiographical debate. The article highlights the work’s significance as contribution to the scholarship on late Roman procedure and the evolution of imperial judicial structures.
In the shadow of Paris, Belgian publishers built a remarkable industry: the mass reprinting of French literary and legal works. This article examines the phenomenon of Belgian contrefacon-the systematic reprinting of French works between 1815 and 1854. In the absence of international copyright conventions, Belgian publishers lawfully reproduced French texts, selling them at a fraction of Parisian prices across Europe and the Americas. The article distinguishes reprinting (r & eacute;impression) from counterfeiting in the criminal sense, demonstrating that Belgian practice operated within the legal framework of the era. Drawing on the works of Dopp, Hen, Hellemans, and Verbeke, the study analyses the industry's institutional structure, its patronage by Belgium's political and judicial elite, and its suppression through the bilateral convention of 22 August 1852. The article identifies a significant gap in existing scholarship: the extent to which Belgian editorial modifications to reprinted French legal treatises may have influenced the transnational reception of French legal thought.
Summary This research critically examines the assumed universality of the Roman legal rule superficies solo cedit by examining its application – or lack thereof – in Roman Egypt. Drawing on papyrological evidence, we argue that local traditions permitted the separate ownership of land and buildings, encompassing divided ownership within a single structure. These practices persisted after the Roman annexation and were recognised by Roman authorities. Thus, this study considers Egypt as a case of legal pluralism within the Empire, illustrating how Roman legal traditions coexisted with local norms rather than fully replacing them.