
European party politics has been realigning around a transnational dimension of competition that pits cosmopolitan parties — favouring immigration, European integration, and climate policy — against radical right parties that oppose these. Radical right parties are sometimes equated with nationalist parties. However, nationalism is highly diverse in Europe’s multinational democracies. Multinational democracies are characterised by a salient centre-periphery conflict, in which majority nationalist parties confront minority nationalists representing peripheral nations. While majority nationalists can be expected to converge on the particularist pole of the transnational cleavage, minority nationalists have strategic reasons to adopt more cosmopolitan stances: they need international allies and seek to differentiate themselves from majority nationalists, their main domestic opponents. The analysis draws on the 2023 edition of an expert survey designed to measure nationalist ideology separately from cultural values, and to differentiate majority from minority nationalism. Analysing 89 nationalist parties in 21 countries confirms that while majority nationalists position themselves on the particularist pole of the transnational cleavage, minority nationalists are more pro-European and more in favour of climate policy — but not more in favour of immigration — than majority nationalists. Interestingly, cosmopolitanism appears also among majority nationalists in smaller peripheral countries, like Bosnia and Herzegovina or Kosovo.
Politicians have to adjudicate between competing policy claims, making judgments as to which to advocate for and which to disregard. Given time and resource constraints, politicians are likely to rely on a deservingness heuristic when making such judgements. However, little is known about how politicians conceive of the deservingness of different policy claims and how this varies by ideology. This paper analyses over 500 interviews with politicians about which characteristics of policy claims prompt them (not) to respond. It explores the circumstances under which politicians spontaneously invoke deservingness as a guiding principle, and how they determine a claim’s deservingness. We find that deservingness is a prevalent criterion that politicians apply to a wide range of policy domains. Further, we find ideological differences in how politicians apply deservingness evaluations: those further from the ideological centre are more likely to make pronounced judgments about whether specific social groups are (un-)deserving. Overall, we reveal that many politicians filter policy claims through moral and political judgments about social groups, highlighting that responsiveness to policy claims is neither equal nor consistent across these different groups.
Climate institutions, including climate laws and advisory bodies, have proliferated globally. But do they matter? Existing work either analyses quantitatively how these institutions correlate with policy outcomes, like stringency or emissions reductions, or qualitatively examines a single type of institution. Neither strand provides tools to systematically identify, analyse, and compare the effects of these institutions on the policymaking process itself. We therefore develop a framework which provides replicable criteria to identify climate institutions and traces how institutions' formal functions interact with country-specific moderating variables to address strategic challenges in climate policymaking. Applying the framework to qualitatively compare climate institutions in Germany, the United Kingdom, Sweden, and Australia, we show they support agenda-setting, increase transparency, signal commitment, and hold governments accountable. By conceptualising a new class of effects, we show how climate institutions can matter and provide a tool for comparative analysis of meso-level institutions.
EU citizens hold equal welfare rights across Member States, but national bureaucracies implement these rights unequally. We ask whether representative bureaucracy can reduce this inequality, while considering its intersectional nature. Theoretically, we distinguish additive intersectional representation, where shared traits accumulate, from categorical intersectional representation, where specific identity configurations matter. We show how to test both quantitatively. A conjoint experiment with 2,402 public employees in four Western European countries examines their responses to hypothetical social welfare applicants, varying by age, gender, French or Bulgarian origin and integration effort – traits that can match bureaucrats’ own lived experiences. We find that male, Bulgarian and poorly integrated applicants are less likely to be prioritised overall, and that single-trait matches leave prioritisation largely unchanged. However, prioritisation rises from 49 to 56 per cent as applicants share up to five traits with bureaucrats. Male Bulgarian applicants benefit specifically when assessed by male bureaucrats with a migration background. Both intersectionality models therefore yield distinct and valuable insights, rather than one being analytically superior to the other. Differentiated implementation of EU social rights thus also arises within administrations, through individual bureaucrats’ discretion. Intersectional representative bureaucracy may help address resulting inequities – but policy implications require more investigation.