
Abstract For females to persist alongside cosexual individuals in gynodioecious populations, they must gain a reproductive advantage—either by producing more seeds, higher-quality seeds, or both. While most studies have focused on seed quantity as a driver of female advantage, the contribution of seed quality remains unresolved. Limited taxonomic coverage, fragmented fitness measurements, and methodological constraints have yielded inconsistent results and have hindered our understanding of the processes underlying female differences in seed quality. We performed a global, phylogenetically informed hierarchical mixed-effects meta-analysis of 196 effect sizes from 38 species to assess patterns of gender differences in seed-quality traits. We further explored whether these patterns varied with reproductive investment patterns, plant growth form, and offspring life stage—moderators that may provide indirect insights into the processes underlying differences between females and cosexuals. Females produced higher-quality seeds than cosexuals and had higher outcrossing rates. Seed quality advantages were greater in woody species and became more pronounced after germination, but were unrelated to reproductive investment patterns. These patterns point to inbreeding avoidance as a plausible contributor to female differences in seed quality, whereas we found no evidence that a simple resource-reallocation scenario associated with floral trait differences explains these differences. Our findings identify seed quality as an underappreciated component of female advantage, providing a basis for future studies investigating the mechanisms underlying gender differences in seed quality and their potential contribution to the maintenance of gynodioecy.
Abstract Sex chromosomes have evolved repeatedly across eukaryotes and are frequently associated with chromosome-wide regulatory mechanisms that modulate gene expression in a sex-, tissue-, and stage-specific manner. In somatic tissues, dosage compensation is often invoked to counteract gene dose imbalances arising from Y or W chromosome degeneration, whereas in the germline, sex chromosomes are commonly downregulated or silenced during gametogenesis. These processes have traditionally been studied in isolation and in just a handful of model organisms. However, recent comparative work across diverse taxa reveals substantial variation in both their extent and underlying mechanisms, and has challenged canonical views derived from model systems. Here, we synthesize current knowledge of sex chromosome regulation across animals and highlight key unresolved questions. First, it remains unclear which expression imbalances dosage compensation actually corrects, and why its outcomes vary from gene-specific to chromosome-wide and from partial to complete compensation. Second, the evolutionary drivers and functional consequences of germline downregulation, including meiotic sex chromosome inactivation and alternative mechanisms, are still poorly understood despite their widespread occurrence. Third, the origins of chromosome-scale regulatory systems remain elusive, with emerging evidence suggesting repeated co-option or rewiring of preexisting regulatory pathways. We further consider whether somatic and germline regulatory systems are mechanistically and evolutionarily linked and how existing regulatory architectures constrain or facilitate sex chromosome turnover and gene content evolution. Finally, we address the largely unexplored fate of regulatory systems after they become redundant following sex chromosome transitions. Resolving these questions will require the combination of comparative genomics, functional assays, and cytological analyses across a broad diversity of nonmodel organisms. Such efforts are essential for establishing general principles governing the evolution of chromosome-wide regulatory systems and their role in shaping genome evolution.
Sex ratios are of fundamental importance for population ecology, social structure, evolution of life-histories and sex roles. In vertebrates, biased sex ratios often arise from an unbiased primary sex ratio because of mortality differences between males and females linked to life-history variation. Yet, the mechanisms that cause these sex-specific mortalities are poorly understood. Using demographic models informed with data collected from captive and wild precocial chicks, we examined the developmental origin of an emerging sex ratio bias in ruffs Calidris pugnax. This lekking shorebird is characterized by strong sexual dimorphism and features aggressive male-male mating contests and highly selective females. The differences in conventional sex roles may already impact males and females before maturation. We show that juvenile male ruffs of the ancestral and most common morph take longer to develop than females, prolonging male vulnerability to ground predators. On average, juvenile females fledged three days earlier than males due to expedited wing development, despite a higher absolute rate of wing growth observed in males. Both, sex-specific survival and fledging age, contributed about equally to the increasing sex ratio bias from hatching to fledging. We argue that sex differences in growth, development, and offspring survival are likely the result of strong pre-reproductive selection on males to achieve dominance, which helps to enforce the Darwinian sex roles observed in this species.
Neo-sex chromosomes have proven powerful for studying the early stages of sex chromosome evolution and differentiation, yet if these dynamic processes could contribute to the emergence of new species remains unclear. The mountain pine beetle (Dendroctonus ponderosae), a major forest pest, is suspected of harboring neo-Y diversity that contributes to cryptic species boundaries. Here, we generated six chromosome-level assemblies (male and female from the three neo-Y populations) to examine the evolutionary processes contributing to differences between, and within, the neo-X and neo-Y chromosomes. Using comparative genomics approaches, we find the large sex chromosomes formed through sequential fusions with three large autosomes, with recombination cessation occurring between the neo-X and neo-Y at multiple distinct time points (similar to 4.3 to similar to 8.6 MYA). Comparative analyses reveal that while the neo-X chromosomes remain largely collinear across populations, only similar to 65% of the highly rearranged neo-Y can be aligned to the neo-X. We find dramatic structural divergence between the three neo-Ys which likely contributes to the extensive degeneration despite only moderate accumulation of repeats. All populations retain a single pseudoautosomal region (PAR), though PAR size and gene content also vary due to neo-Y specific rearrangements. We document a pattern of rapid, ongoing, and variable gene loss across neo-Y chromosomes in the mountain pine beetle. Some genes undergoing degeneration are associated with early-stage reproductive isolation phenotypes previously characterized in crossing experiments. Together, these results highlight how rapid genome restructuring through chromosomal fusions and Y chromosome degeneration can occur at evolutionary time scales relevant to the evolution of new species.
Evolutionary theory predicts that coevolutionary specialization between mutualistic lineages is beneficial, increasing the evolution of cooperative benefits. However, many mutualists interact with temporally variable partners, which can limit opportunities for sustained reciprocal selection. Few empirical studies have directly examined how this partner heterogeneity affects mutualistic evolution, largely because tracking partner dynamics over evolutionary timescales is challenging in natural systems. We circumvent this constraint via experimental evolution with an engineered resource sharing mutualism in Baker's yeast (Saccharomyces cerevisiae), which allows precise control of partner heterogeneity across generations. We compared low temporal partner heterogeneity (consistent pairings) with high temporal partner heterogeneity (temporally rotating partners) across 54 rounds of selection (similar to 378-426 generations). Low partner heterogeneity produced the strongest mutualistic benefits (7.2% increased growth over controls), while high partner heterogeneity yielded only modest benefits (2.2% increase). Mutualistic benefits in the low partner heterogeneity treatment were consistent with increased resource exchange. Time-shift experiments indicate that coevolution may have enhanced the evolution of mutualistic benefits but was not strictly necessary: benefits also evolved through one-sided adaptation. Genomic analyses revealed parallel evolution in amino acid metabolism and starvation response genes. Surprisingly, low-heterogeneity lineages evolved as generalists rather than specialists, cooperating equally well with all partners tested. Overall, these results demonstrate that sustained interactions between specific partner lineages facilitate the rapid evolution of mutualistic benefits but are not strictly required.