
Interest in behavioral public policy has grown rapidly, but some have raised concerns that behavioral interventions may undermine human agency. Many of these interventions rely on top-down processes in which policymakers and experts define both policy goals and the shape of the interventions themselves. This top-down stance raises concerns about paternalism, limited stakeholder buy-in and reduced effectiveness in complex, large-scale societal challenges. In this paper, we argue that co-creation – the active involvement of relevant stakeholders at all stages of policy development – offers a path forward for bottom-up behavioral public policy. This paper moves bottom-up behavioral public policy two steps forward. Step one is conceptual. We clarify how bottom-up co-creation allows behavioral public policy to address agency as both a subjective experience and a social phenomenon founded on participation and active inclusion. Drawing on philosophical and policy scholarship, we argue that concerns about autonomy and paternalism cannot be fully addressed without attending to how citizens are involved in shaping the interventions that affect them. Step two is methodological. We outline how co-creation processes can be systematically integrated with behavioral insights, which mitigates ethical concerns while potentially bolstering intervention effectiveness and public trust. By foregrounding citizens as active partners and contributors, a co-creation agenda can enhance both the legitimacy and impact of behavioral public policy.
Abstract Behavioural research can inform effective responses to global challenges, but its application across sectors remains uneven and poorly coordinated. This survey study aimed to map the current ecosystem of behavioural research across UK sectors to identify priorities for its application, capability needs and opportunities for strategic integration to address these challenges. Invitations were distributed via mailing list, website, social media and snowball sampling. We received 657 responses from people who conduct or use behavioural research in public, private and voluntary sectors. Respondents reported conducting applied (93 per cent) and/or pure (27 per cent) research across the UK. Current priorities for the application of behavioural research centred on climate action, health, methodological advances and artificial intelligence. Perceived capability gaps differed across sectors and include technological abilities and knowledge relating to intervention design, implementation and evaluation. Broader barriers to conducting behavioural research include lack of confidence, limited funding and training, access to expert support and limited acceptance of behavioural research. Findings highlight a need to increase capability through addressing skills and knowledge gaps, leadership engagement and increasing resources for collaborative translation of behavioural research into practice. Approaches to addressing findings are being explored through sector-specific workshops to inform future survey waves.
Abstract Behaviour-change interventions unfold in social systems where people learn from others. We develop a stylised agent-based model to examine how four canonical social learning rules – conformist transmission, informational prestige-biased copying, payoff-biased copying and random copying – shape the impact of a simple seeding intervention. Two arms evolve under identical conditions and learning rules, differing only in initial adoption: both start with exactly 5% baseline adopters and the treatment arm additionally seeds 20% of the remaining non-adopters, yielding an exact 25% vs 5% contrast at t equals 0 $t = 0$ t = 0 . Across homogeneous populations, 70/30 mixed ecologies and sweeps over the share of payoff-biased learners, we track adoption trajectories and treatment–control lift; we also vary payoff parameters, prestige informativeness and conformist thresholds in robustness analyses. We find that the same seeding intervention can stall, drift or cascade depending on the learning ecology. In the baseline specification, conformist dynamics exhibit threshold effects that erase treatment gains, prestige-biased and random copying can preserve positive final lift when diffusion remains incomplete and payoff-biased copying mainly changes the diffusion regime rather than preserving large end-point gaps. Robustness checks show that negative payoff premia suppress diffusion, weak or noisy payoff signals can generate treatment advantages, prestige effects depend on how informative prestige is and conformist treatment effects are concentrated in narrow threshold-boundary regions. These results motivate policy heuristics that evaluate interventions relative to local diffusion potential, make successful outcomes visible when payoff cues matter and tailor seeding to the prevailing mix of learning rules.
Recent developments in behavioural public policy emphasise the potential of transparent nudging interventions, such as nudge+ or boosts, to engage people with their decisions. However, the current state of research on transparent nudging is fraught with methodological critiques, and only a handful of studies examine differences between types of transparency messages or 'disclosures'. Using a vignette survey experiment (n = 1916), we measure the influence of transparency, operationalised through different types of disclosures, on both the effectiveness of the nudging technique and the perceived autonomy of those subjected to the nudge. We employ a salience nudge to promote sustainable food choices and present four different disclosures. Results indicate that, while the nudge proved effective in promoting sustainable food choices, the disclosures neither enhanced nor reduced its effectiveness. At the same time, the nudge led to a small but significant decrease in perceived autonomy, which the disclosures did not offset. Overall, differences between the types of disclosures were not substantial enough to yield significant effects in either behavioural outcomes or perceived autonomy. These findings suggest that while disclosures can be applied to increase transparency without compromising nudge effectiveness, they are not sufficient to mitigate concerns about autonomy in nudging interventions.
This study investigates how behavioral interventions affect prosocial decision-making in dictator and trust games, examining immediate and persistent effects. We conducted a two-round experiment with five treatments (defaults, sanctions, social norms, anchoring, moral persuasion) vs control, separated by an unrelated task to measure persistence. We explored how self-efficacy and gender moderate treatment effectiveness. Sanctions were initially most effective for increasing prosocial behavior across both games. When interventions were removed in round two, sanctions continued influencing trust game participants but showed gender-specific patterns in the dictator game, with effects observed only among women. Social norms affected only women across both rounds, significantly in the Trust Game and marginally in the Dictator Game. Additionally, we found self-efficacy and moral persuasion interactions among women only: higher self-efficacy increased giving in the dictator game but decreased giving in the trust game, with effects persisting into round two. No significant relationships emerged for men. Our findings demonstrate important policy implications. While sanctions effectively promote immediate prosocial behavior, interventions affect demographic groups differently. Understanding these differential impacts is crucial for policymakers evaluating behavioral intervention outcomes, suggesting that effective regulatory design must account for individual characteristics rather than assuming universal responses across populations.