
Service rejection is common in the service sector and a routine part of commercial interactions. As artificial intelligence (AI) becomes increasingly integrated into service delivery, it is important to understand how AI-driven rejections affect customer satisfaction compared with rejections made by human agents. This research shows that consumers are generally less satisfied when an AI agent, rather than a human agent, rejects their applications. This is because consumers are more likely to assign greater blame to AI agents, perceiving them as having lower decision-making ability. We also examine how explanations shape consumer responses to AI-driven rejections. Our findings indicate that providing a teleological explanation, clarifying why a rejection occurred, effectively mitigates negative reactions compared with providing a mechanistic explanation, which clarifies how the rejection was made, or providing no explanation at all. This research contributes to the ongoing discussions about consumer responses to AI-based decisions, particularly when those decisions deliver unfavorable outcomes.
Consumer vulnerability research treats harm and agency as oppositional: vulnerability arises when restricted access to marketplace resources erodes agency, and restoring agency is assumed to reduce harm. Current research also presumes that vulnerable consumers occupy a stable, if constrained, legal position. Through an ethnography of UK-based transgender consumers, we problematize both assumptions and develop the concept of ambiguous consumer vulnerability: a condition in which harm arises not only when market access is withdrawn and agency is constrained, but also when consumers assert their agency by participating in the marketplace. Because the marketplace is inescapable and central to identity and well-being, exiting is not an option; consumers instead engage in the volitional absorption of harm to maintain market access. We show how this co-constitution of agency and harm is intensified by legal precarity, which renders the ambiguity persistent and unevenly distributed across services. We identify three strategies—circumventing, educating, and conforming—through which consumers navigate, rather than resolve, ambiguous consumer vulnerability, and then explore how legal precarity complicates the efficacy of these navigation strategies. We contribute to service research by reexamining the relationship between vulnerability, agency, and harm, and offer managerial guidance—seamless service inclusion and inconsequential fluidity—for more inclusive services.
Transformative Service Initiatives (TSIs) aim to reduce consumer vulnerability (CV), yet they can reproduce the harm they seek to address. We investigate this paradox in TSIs offering entrepreneurship support to refugees. Study 1, drawing on interviews with forty-two managers from thirty-three TSIs, identifies three service models (access-dominant, balanced-constrained and control-dominant) that organise consumers’ access to resources and control over their use. Each model positions consumers differently, as passive recipients, conditional agents or autonomous strivers, and sustaining each position makes a distinct CV pattern likely: a recurrent form of constrained agency or unmet need. Study 2, a three-year ethnography of a TSI provider (70 interviews, 144 observational sessions), shows how consumers contest their assigned positions within the service relationship: testimonial repositioning (making the lived costs of service participation visible) and prefigurative repositioning (demonstrating what greater enabling resources could make possible). It then traces how these acts contributed to service-model reconfiguration under particular organisational and institutional conditions. Theoretically, findings explain how service models can recurrently pattern vulnerability through consumer positioning and how consumers’ within-relationship responses may contribute to service-model reconfiguration. Managerially, the typology enables managers to diagnose CV risks in their service models and develop organisational capacity for service reconfiguration.
Designing service ecosystems is a collective endeavor in which interdependent actors intentionally reconfigure the social structures coordinating their value cocreation. Because actors experience structures differently, however, they often disagree about how to reconfigure them. Although reflexivity has been identified as a key enabler for service ecosystem design, research has primarily treated it as an individual capacity. Yet transformation guided only by reflexive individuals risks unintended consequences for others and rupturing the relations on which value cocreation depends. In response, we examine how reflexive relations can be stewarded to support service ecosystem design in pursuit of desirable collective outcomes. We define reflexive relations as a form of interaction in which differently positioned actors jointly render the institutionalized social structures coordinating their value cocreation observable, contestable, and open to reconfiguration. Through a two-year cooperative inquiry in Norwegian child welfare, we explicate connected friction as the core dialectic dynamic through which reflexive relations emerge, with uniformity and rupture as hindering dynamics. We also identify four situated conditions—practical distance, actor perspectives, emotional effort, and institutional legitimacy—that require continual attunement to steward reflexive relations in practice. This research reconceptualizes reflexivity as emerging through actors’ relations and shows how ongoing stewardship can leverage conflicting interdependencies as a generative resource for designing service ecosystems.