
Abstract This article develops a theoretical and critical reconstruction of reparation within restorative justice (RJ). Prevailing accounts have narrowly restricted reparation to material and symbolic acts undertaken primarily by the person responsible for the harm. This article advances a multidimensional theory of repair encompassing material, symbolic, relational and procedural forms and theorizes reparation as a distributed practice involving persons responsible, persons harmed, communities and justice institutions. It further situates reparation in RJ within a broader ethical and political conception of justice as the repair of relational coexistence rather than merely an outcome of dispute resolution. By clarifying conceptual boundaries while retaining normative depth, the framework contributes to theoretical debates on justice.
Abstract This article develops the concept of gacaca judgecraft as a decolonial tool to critique the human rights discourse that was imposed on Rwanda’s gacaca courts. International human rights stakeholders have vehemently critiqued gacaca judges for lacking legal knowledge and impartiality. Adopting a decolonial lens, I critique this rights corpus using interviews with 80 Rwandan lay judges. I argue that community knowledge and emotions are essential elements of gacaca judgecraft. It is only by delinking from the rights paradigm that we can begin to see gacaca judges as producers of legal knowledge in their own right. I conclude that the concept of gacaca judgecraft can expand the possibilities for non-Western forms of (semi) legal reasoning.
Based on qualitative data from Norway, we examine how men labelled as gang members draw on multiple narrative resources to construct and contest meanings of self and social position during a time of heightened 'gang talk', which we refer to as gangmood. Building on scholarship highlighting the performative dimensions of gang identity and street codes, we foreground the role of ambiguity in narrative practice as a response to asymmetry, showing how ambiguous stories generate new layers of interpretation, adjustment and negotiation, making gang identity not a fixed status, but an ongoing and situated process. Ambiguity, then, should not be seen as simply a lack of clarity or stable selfhood, but as a mechanism through which selves are made and remade across situations and audiences.
Abstract This paper contributes to narrative victimology by theorizing how victims/survivors may create a narrative that is not centred on victimization. As proposed by Kelly and her colleagues, the paper aims to debunk the victim/survivor dichotomy to appreciate the wholeness of victims’/survivors’ lives, which constantly evolve beyond the victimization or survival. To this end, the paper presents the ‘Becoming Model’ of narrative generation, drawing on Deleuze and Guattari’s notion of the rhizome, and uses a romance fraud victim’s/survivor’s case to illustrate the Model’s applicability. The current study contributes to narrative victimology by criticizing the idealization of active and decisive agency as a desirable feature for victims/survivors and the negative connotation attached to passivity.
Medical deviance-non-criminal departures from professional, ethical or clinical norms by doctors-represents a significant governance challenge in UK private healthcare, yet it has received little systematic criminological attention. Drawing on qualitative interviews with 19 senior professionals across eight independent hospital groups, this article examines how private healthcare organizations define, monitor and respond to borderline conduct. Three findings are developed: deviance is socially constructed through pattern data and assessments of practitioner insight; grey areas are structurally produced by professional hierarchies, collegial solidarity and regulatory fragmentation; and commercial logics operate as a governance filter-a mechanism through which financial considerations modulate institutional tolerance for misconduct. The article extends normalization of deviance theory, the process by which repeated tolerance of departures from standards renders them routine, by showing how market pressures shape the gradient of institutional drift in a commercially organized healthcare setting.