
Very few political science articles have been retracted. We argue that this surprisingly low number of retractions does not indicate greater a priori honesty within our profession compared to other disciplines. Instead, we identify three alternative explanations: (1) data access and transparency requirements that deter research misconduct, (2) the dominance of observational data analyses and causal models, in which undetectable tweaks to research designs and model specifications are the fraudulent method of choice for producing desired results, and (3) the paucity of institutionalized checks and balances that help with detecting fraud, such as meta-analyses, replication studies, and robustness tests that are not carefully selected by the authors themselves. We suggest that the low number of retractions is best accounted for by the second and third explanations, which combine to create an environment where highly problematic research practices persist without leading to formal retractions.
Abstract This study examines how Czech civic education teachers navigate neutrality in relation to controversial and sensitive (CaS) topics, understood as issues that provoke disagreement and emotional responses and vary across contexts and classrooms. Drawing on qualitative interviews and a focus group, the study explores teachers’ reasoning and pedagogical responses in secondary technical and vocational schools located in two regions with the country’s lowest educational outcomes. These schools represent contexts of double disadvantage shaped by cumulative regional and institutional constraints. Using a grounded theory approach, this research investigates the teachers’ strategies to balance institutional expectations, societal pressures, and student engagement in civic education. The findings reveal that teachers adopt four distinct approaches – strategic avoidance, structured neutrality, value-based advocacy, and transparent facilitation – each shaped by external constraints and personal pedagogical beliefs. Rather than representing fixed pedagogical orientations, these approaches reflect teachers’ situational responses to perceived risks and contextual constraints. By conceptualising established typologies as flexible repertoires rather than fixed teacher positions, the study refines and extends previous frameworks and contributes to a more context-sensitive understanding of neutrality and decision-making in civic education.
Abstract This article studies two civil disobedience campaigns directed at the Fidesz government that controlled Hungary from 2010 to 2026. Representing two different kinds of civil disobedience, they both failed to deliver their immediate intended effects of changing or moderating the populist government’s illiberal policies and practices. The latter was due to the control the government held over the media, the legislature, and the courts, and its ability to react decisively to the challenges of civilly disobedient citizens and reinforce its illiberal policies and practices instead of yielding to the pressure. Short term, the campaigns thus produced perverse effects compared to those intended. Long-term, they may have had positive effects. Through the collective experience of diverse social resistance spanning several decades, they contributed to the reinforcement of the self-respect of the opposition and increased its learning and its organisational capacity.
Abstract This article discusses the respective rights and duties of citizens and civil servants to form alliances to counter populist parties in and out of government. It argues that civil servants under certain circumstances have a stronger role-specific responsibility to protect democratic rights and institutions than citizens in general. It also shows that the general requirement for actions undertaken to defend or restore democratic rights and institutions to be effective depends on how non-ideal circumstances are in terms of non-compliance with democratic principles and whether a course of action entails the violation of democratic rights. More broadly, the article demonstrates the need to combine empirical studies with normative theory to formulate legitimate responses to the populist challenge to democracy, as well as the difficulty of doing so.
This article presents a theoretical framework for studying the effectiveness of opposition to populist parties by civil society actors. Effective opposition to populist parties is the achievement of the goals of opposition without achieving perverse effects. Goals of opposition to populist parties are reducing support for populist parties; diminishing their material, organizational, and moral resources; ideological moderation; and, where relevant, curbing their ability to implement illiberal or undemocratic policies. Perverse effects, from the point of view of opponents, are increased support for populist parties boosting populist party resources; and ideological radicalization. Civil society actors can achieve these goals in three main ways: By disrupting the daily activities, civil society actors may reduce party support and organizational resources, while disruptive protests create social leverage, exploiting dependency of populist governments on political stability and consent. Civil society actors can form alliances with others, such as political parties able to use their governing resources against populist parties, or through litigation. Secondly, public critique at home and abroad, media campaigns and demonstrations may persuade others not to support populist parties and damage moral resources. Avoiding these negative consequences provides incentives for ideological moderation. Perverse effects may follow the effective mobilization of populist counter-discourses, linking opponents to elites or 'others' denigrated in populist discourse, boosting organizational cohesion and encouraging radicalization. The article contributes to research on 'democratic resilience' by identifying 'diagonal accountability' mechanisms, showing how these both shape incentives and work through persuasion.