
Contemporary psychiatry often assumes that more precise diagnosis will yield more effective care. Biomarkers, digital phenotyping, artificial intelligence and related tools promise better diagnosis, treatment selection and outcomes. Yet this expectation is clinically incomplete: objectively valid information may not improve treatment when patients experience it as impersonal, imposed or disconnected from their concerns. Collaborative/Therapeutic Assessment (C/TA) complements precision psychiatry by engaging patients as partners in meaning-making rather than passive recipients of expert conclusions. It can transform technically precise findings into personally useful knowledge, making diagnosis more likely to foster engagement and meaningful change instead of merely producing refined classification.
Aims and method We aimed to compare differences in DIALOG scale patient-reported experience measures and patient-reported outcome measures scores between different patient groups accessing adult mental health services. Pooled anonymised data of 11 198 DIALOG scores from 5007 unique patients were disaggregated (based on age, gender, ethnicity and socioeconomic deprivation) and analysed. We compared statistical differences between groups in their means scores, and carried out regression analysis converting data to a binomial for satisfaction to control for variables. Results Asian and Black patients had greater levels of satisfaction across several domains compared with White British patients. Women, younger patients and those living in more deprived areas had poorer levels of satisfaction. Clinical implications Disaggregated large routinely collected outcome data can offer useful intelligence on monitoring of health inequity. Overall health inequity assessment needs a nuanced interpretation and triangulation of outcome data with access experience, including coercion and physical health.
Diagnostic classifications (DSM, ICD and other system frameworks) make distress legible for clinical and institutional action. That is their strength. Yet classification is not a mirror of lived suffering: it necessarily prioritises operationalisable criteria over the cultural, relational and moral meanings through which people experience distress and decide whether help is needed. Building on Kleinman’s distinction between illness (lived experience), disease/disorder (practitioner/system categories) and sickness (social recognition and response), this paper argues that cross-cultural failures in mental healthcare often reflect ‘layer misalignment’: disorder labels, illness meanings and sickness recognition diverge. Using taijin kyofusho, in which concerns about offending others can be mistranslated into standard self-focused social anxiety, as an illustrative case, this paper outlines a practical approach to reduce miscommunication: eliciting explanatory models, translating idioms into meanings, three-layer formulation, alignment checks and culturally safer service design.
Clinical guidelines aid decision-making, but their simplifying strength becomes a limitation in complex, value-laden situations. Once meant to summarise evidence, they now function as prescriptive standards used in quality and legal assessments. Overly rigid directives can undermine autonomy, hide uncertainty and restrict clinical judgement. Using complexity science and ‘wicked problem’ theory, we introduce ‘wicked complexity’ to better match guidelines design to real clinical challenges. Applying this to deprescribing psychoactive drugs, we show how traditional, adherence-focused guidance can prompt defensive practice. Guidelines for wicked complexity should instead clarify risks, support moral deliberation and support shared, iterative decision-making across healthcare.
Franz Kafka has often been posthumously diagnosed with anorexia nervosa, but recent research impels a re-evaluation of his disordered eating. This study presents a qualitative analysis of Kafka’s diaries, correspondence, medical reports and fiction, focusing on appetite, diet, somatic symptoms, and cognitions concerning food and fasting. Diagnostic indicators are matched against DSM-5 criteria for anorexia nervosa and avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder. Kafka’s clinical profile, which is characterised by diminished appetite, anorexia, selective intake, obsessive mastication, low body weight and undernourishment needing repeated sanatorium admissions, suggests a presentation more consistent with avoidant/restrictive food intake disorder. These disturbances are reflected in his fiction, in which food operates as a symbolic register of alienation, ontological anxiety and existential resistance, most notably in The Metamorphosis and A Hunger Artist. Integration of medical and literary perspectives demonstrates the clinical value of phenomenological evidence in capturing lived experience of eating disorders, enriching diagnostic insight by foregrounding cognitive, psychosocial and cultural contexts.