
Justice may be compromised when experts fail to provide courts with the information needed to properly evaluate their opinions. Although prior research has examined whether expert reports and testimony include recommended categories of content, less attention has been paid to whether that information addresses the substantive topics needed for rational evaluation. Using the Expert Persuasion Expectancy (ExPEx) framework, this study audits reports and testimony from a multi-expert, multidisciplinary criminal case for information relevant to eight key attributes. Although the evidence was typically detailed, information relevant to expert ability and consistency attributes was often absent. The information present for other attributes tended to be cursory or generic, illustrating that nominal coverage does not guarantee sufficiency. These finding show how expert evidence may appear conventionally complete while remailing logically opaque. As a historically situated, case-based audit, this study provides a point of comparison for future research and demonstrates the importance of examining the content and quality of expert evidence in contemporary prosecutions.
Establishing a 'quality mistakes are blame-free' culture makes mistakes opportunities for learning and improvement. A blame-free culture prioritizes the employee over punitive consequences resulting from a well-meaning mistake, while recognizing the opportunity for quality improvement and supporting a learning environment. Assigning fault and imposing punishment create barriers to early reporting; hence blame is removed. Blame is replaced by scrutiny, early mistake detection, support, accountability, and continuous improvement, making quality everyone’s responsibility without the punitive barrier of blame. The results include improved trust, a better working environment, and improved quality.
Dark particulate developers remain the most widely applied means of visualizing latent fingermarks. Manganese cobalt oxide (MnCo2O4) nanoparticles were prepared by alkaline coprecipitation at 80 °C and characterized by XRD, FTIR, FESEM, and EDS, which indicated the formation of the cubic spinel phase of MnCo2O4 with a crystallite size of approximately 21 nm, a particle size of approximately 50 nm, and particle aggregation. Sebaceous and natural fingermarks on ten substrates were developed by powder dusting, visually graded, and scored using NIST Fingerprint Image Quality 2 (NFIQ 2). Sebaceous marks received grades of 4 or 5 on eight substrates, whereas natural marks achieved these grades on five substrates. NFIQ 2 scores correlated with visual grades (Spearman ρ = 0.69) and were higher for sebaceous marks (median 33.5 versus 15.0). Substrate texture inflated the automated minutiae counts, and microscopy showed particle deposition largely confined to the ridges.
How should a laboratory combine opinions when examiners disagree about whether fingerprint evidence supports a definitive conclusion? We examine this question through an archival reanalysis of 17,121 responses from 169 examiners across 744 fingerprint pairs in the FBI latent-print Black Box Study. Comparison-stage inconclusive rates increased from 17.2% for comparisons rated obvious to 53.8% for those rated very difficult. A one-level increase in difficulty was associated with 1.58 times the odds of an inconclusive response after accounting for mating status and clustering by examiner and pair. Examiner inconclusive rates ranged from 5.7% to 81.2%, correlated across mated and non-mated comparisons (r = 0.61), and varied more than expected under pair-conditioned permutations. These patterns establish persistent response tendencies but do not separate perceptual ability from decision criteria. In exact retrospective calculations across 738 eligible fingerprint pairs, requiring a strict majority of all panelists reduced erroneous definitive conclusions from 3.80% for one examiner to 0.58% for seven. A majority taken only among definitive responses increased coverage but raised error to 9.88%, mainly through false exclusions. No-value and inconclusive responses remain distinct decision stages; they have the same voting effect only under the two rules examined. Larger absolute error reductions occurred on pairs with more dispersed responses, although the entropy measure does not distinguish uncertainty from contradictory conclusions. The findings illustrate how aggregation rules change error and coverage in a historical response distribution. They do not establish an optimal verification procedure or validate these rules for contemporary expanded conclusion scales.