
Tri-Agency-funded researchers in Canada will soon be required, with few exceptions, to deposit data and make them available, including for possible reuse by others. These new requirements will upend the data management practices of sociologists in Canada, especially qualitative researchers. In this essay, I review the emerging Tri-Agency requirements and explore current data management practices of sociologists in Canada through a scan of CRS articles. I situate data deposit and availability in the broader context of open science, and then explore debates-epistemological and ethical-among qualitative researchers outside of Canada where data deposit mandates are already in place. I briefly raise issues that require the attention of (especially qualitative) sociologists in Canada relating to community-based research and to data access. I conclude the essay by recommending sociologists-especially qualitative sociologists-assess our readiness for the new data regime.
Despite being admitted to Canada as "the best and the brightest," immigrants often face underemployment and poverty. Few studies on immigrant labour market integration consider the role of local policy actors such as human resource management (HRM) professionals, who make and influence hiring decisions. Drawing on interviews and Relational Inequality Theory, this paper examines how HRM professionals in Alberta categorically define and evaluate immigrant candidates. Findings reveal that HRM professionals fail to recognize immigrants as legally entitled and preferred workers based on their permanent residency, instead treating them as temporary migrants who are administrative burdens or financial risks. Strategic HRM logics provide non-racial justifications for exclusion, yet evaluations are guided by cultural fit criteria that serve as proxies for Whiteness. These insights reframe the problem as also a recognition of legal status, showing how immigration categories and cultural racism intersect to reproduce inequality in Canada's labour market. Bien qu'ils soient accueillis au Canada comme & laquo; les meilleurs et les plus brillants & raquo;, les immigr & eacute;s sont souvent confront & eacute;s au sous-emploi et & agrave; la pauvret & eacute;. Peu d'& eacute;tudes sur l'int & eacute;gration des immigrants sur le march & eacute; du travail prennent en compte le r & ocirc;le des acteurs politiques locaux, tels que les professionnels de la gestion des ressources humaines (GRH), qui prennent et influencent les d & eacute;cisions d'embauche. S'appuyant sur des entretiens et sur la th & eacute;orie de l'in & eacute;galit & eacute; relationnelle, cet article examine comment les professionnels de la GRH en Alberta d & eacute;finissent et & eacute;valuent de mani & egrave;re cat & eacute;gorique les candidats immigr & eacute;s. Les r & eacute;sultats r & eacute;v & egrave;lent que les professionnels de la GRH ne reconnaissent pas les immigrants comme des travailleurs l & eacute;galement habilit & eacute;s et privil & eacute;gi & eacute;s en raison de leur statut de r & eacute;sident permanent, mais les traitent plut & ocirc;t comme des migrants temporaires repr & eacute;sentant une charge administrative ou un risque financier. Les logiques strat & eacute;giques de la GRH fournissent des justifications non raciales & agrave; cette exclusion, mais les & eacute;valuations sont guid & eacute;es par des crit & egrave;res d'ad & eacute;quation culturelle qui servent de substituts & agrave; la & laquo; blancheur & raquo;. Ces observations recadrent le probl & egrave;me en y int & eacute;grant & eacute;galement la reconnaissance du statut juridique, montrant ainsi comment les cat & eacute;gories d'immigration et le racisme culturel s'entrecroisent pour reproduire les in & eacute;galit & eacute;s sur le march & eacute; du travail canadien.
Recent debates in sociological literature have questioned whether 'professions' and 'non-professional occupations' remain analytically distinct concepts. This article engages with longstanding scholarship on work, occupations and professions to address this question. Drawing primarily on the work of Adams (2018), Saks (2021) and their associated neo-Weberian approaches, I argue that professions are socially constructed and historically, geographically and temporally contingent. As such, the contemporary macrostructural conditions (re)shaping professional work in the Anglo-American context-most notably emerging subjective forms of precariousness-should not be interpreted as signalling the demise of professions. Rather, they represent the latest iteration of professional work and its ongoing effort to maintain hegemony amid shifting economic structures. Although professional and non-professional occupations appear to be converging in some of the respects traditionally separating them, I argue that professions remain analytically distinct from non-professions. This distinction persists because professionals continue to benefit from the economic and symbolic advantages they have secured through state legitimation, social closure, and the enduring cultural representations of themselves and their work that promote the ideological 'common-senseness' of their elevated social and economic status. The article therefore concludes that professions are not experiencing a 'crisis' but are instead entering a new phase of their ongoing reconstruction. Des d & eacute;bats r & eacute;cents dans la litt & eacute;rature sociologique ont remis en question le fait que les & laquo; professions & raquo; et les & laquo; m & eacute;tiers non professionnels & raquo; constituent encore des concepts distincts sur le plan analytique. Cet article s'appuie sur une longue tradition de recherches consacr & eacute;es au travail, aux m & eacute;tiers et aux professions pour aborder cette question. En m'appuyant principalement sur les travaux d'Adams (2018) et de Saks (2021), ainsi que sur leurs approches n & eacute;o-w & eacute;b & eacute;riennes, je soutiens que les professions sont des constructions sociales et qu'elles sont contingentes sur les plans historique, g & eacute;ographique et temporel. & Agrave; ce titre, les conditions macrostructurelles contemporaines qui (re)fa & ccedil;onnent le travail professionnel dans le contexte anglo-am & eacute;ricain - notamment les formes subjectives & eacute;mergentes de pr & eacute;carit & eacute; - ne doivent pas & ecirc;tre interpr & eacute;t & eacute;es comme annon & ccedil;ant la disparition des professions. Elles repr & eacute;sentent plut & ocirc;t la derni & egrave;re it & eacute;ration du travail professionnel et son effort continu pour maintenir son h & eacute;g & eacute;monie au milieu de structures & eacute;conomiques en mutation. Bien que les professions et les m & eacute;tiers non professionnels semblent converger sur certains des aspects qui les s & eacute;paraient traditionnellement, je soutiens que les professions restent analytiquement distinctes des non-professions. Cette distinction persiste car les professionnels continuent de b & eacute;n & eacute;ficier des avantages & eacute;conomiques et symboliques qu'ils se sont assur & eacute;s gr & acirc;ce & agrave; la l & eacute;gitimation de l'& Eacute;tat, & agrave; la fermeture sociale et aux repr & eacute;sentations culturelles durables d'eux-m & ecirc;mes et de leur travail, qui promeuvent le & laquo; bon sens & raquo; id & eacute;ologique de leur statut social et & eacute;conomique & eacute;lev & eacute;. L'article conclut donc que les professions ne traversent pas une & laquo; crise & raquo;, mais entrent au contraire dans une nouvelle phase de leur reconstruction continue.
This article explores mistrust as a socially situated phenomenon by using the care trajectories of injured immigrant workers in Qu & eacute;bec as a conceptual entry point. Rather than focusing on the individual characteristics of trusters, it examines how mistrust emerges from a subjective evaluation of environments perceived as threatening. Drawing on a body of work on mistrust and trust, the article proposes a two-tiered model distinguishing between underlying mistrust, rooted in generalized social vulnerability, and directed distrust, focused on specific actors. The study identifies four key factors shaping perceptions of environmental threat: precariousness, lack of support, diminished recognition, and limited agency. Ethnographic cases highlight how these factors interact to produce mistrust, and how their presence or absence modulates its expression. The article also incorporates a distinction between mistrust and distrust to refine conceptual clarity. Though grounded in a specific empirical context-immigrant workers navigating Quebec's work injury rehabilitation system-the model is offered as a more generalizable analytical tool. By treating mistrust not as a deficit or pathology but as a rational, context-responsive orientation, this article contributes to the development of a situated theory of mistrust applicable across diverse social fields. Cet article explore la m & eacute;fiance en tant que ph & eacute;nom & egrave;ne socialement situ & eacute;, en prenant comme point d'entr & eacute;e conceptuel les parcours de soins des travailleurs immigr & eacute;s bless & eacute;s au Qu & eacute;bec. Plut & ocirc;t que de se concentrer sur les caract & eacute;ristiques individuelles des personnes qui font confiance, il examine comment la m & eacute;fiance & eacute;merge d'une & eacute;valuation subjective d'environnements per & ccedil;us comme mena & ccedil;ants. S'appuyant sur un corpus de travaux consacr & eacute;s & agrave; la m & eacute;fiance et & agrave; la confiance, l'article propose un mod & egrave;le & agrave; deux niveaux distinguant la m & eacute;fiance sous-jacente, enracin & eacute;e dans une vuln & eacute;rabilit & eacute; sociale g & eacute;n & eacute;ralis & eacute;e, et la m & eacute;fiance dirig & eacute;e, centr & eacute;e sur des acteurs sp & eacute;cifiques. L'& eacute;tude identifie quatre facteurs cl & eacute;s qui fa & ccedil;onnent les perceptions de menace environnementale : la pr & eacute;carit & eacute;, le manque de soutien, la reconnaissance r & eacute;duite et l'autonomie limit & eacute;e. Des cas ethnographiques mettent en & eacute;vidence la mani & egrave;re dont ces facteurs interagissent pour produire de la m & eacute;fiance, et comment leur pr & eacute;sence ou leur absence module son expression. L'article int & egrave;gre & eacute;galement une distinction entre la m & eacute;fiance et la d & eacute;fiance afin d'affiner la clart & eacute; conceptuelle. Bien qu'ancr & eacute; dans un contexte empirique sp & eacute;cifique - celui des travailleurs immigr & eacute;s & eacute;voluant au sein du syst & egrave;me qu & eacute;b & eacute;cois de r & eacute;adaptation professionnelle apr & egrave;s un accident du travail -, le mod & egrave;le est pr & eacute;sent & eacute; comme un outil analytique plus g & eacute;n & eacute;ralisable. En traitant la m & eacute;fiance non pas comme un d & eacute;ficit ou une pathologie, mais comme une orientation rationnelle et adapt & eacute;e au contexte, cet article contribue au d & eacute;veloppement d'une th & eacute;orie situ & eacute;e de la m & eacute;fiance applicable & agrave; divers champs sociaux.
How credibility is constructed under conditions of epistemic uncertainty is a central question in the sociology of knowledge. Telepathic animal communication (TAC) represents a field in which knowledge claims are inherently non-verifiable, yet services are actively marketed and consumed. This study examines how TAC practitioners construct credibility on their websites. Drawing on Grounded Theory, websites offering TAC services in Germany were qualitatively analyzed. Findings identify three central mechanisms of credibility construction. First, practitioners employ professionalized presentations, including structured services, therapeutic terminology, and biographical self-legitimation. Second, credibility is reinforced through emotional and relational appeal, including personalized communication, expressions of care, and perceived closeness between practitioner and client. Third, strategic non-verifiability emerges as a distinctive mechanism: the inherent unverifiability of TAC is actively mobilized to protect claims from falsification through interpretative flexibility. The findings show how credibility can be stabilized through professional, relational, and epistemic strategies despite the absence of empirical validation. La mani & egrave;re dont la cr & eacute;dibilit & eacute; se construit dans un contexte d'incertitude & eacute;pist & eacute;mique constitue une question centrale en sociologie de la connaissance. La communication animale par t & eacute;l & eacute;pathie (CAT) repr & eacute;sente un domaine dans lequel les affirmations relatives aux connaissances sont intrins & egrave;quement inv & eacute;rifiables, alors que les services sont activement commercialis & eacute;s et consomm & eacute;s. Cette & eacute;tude examine comment les praticiens de la CAT construisent leur cr & eacute;dibilit & eacute; sur leurs sites web. En s'appuyant sur la th & eacute;orie ancr & eacute;e, les sites web proposant des services de CAT en Allemagne ont fait l'objet d'une analyse qualitative. Les r & eacute;sultats mettent en & eacute;vidence trois m & eacute;canismes centraux de construction de la cr & eacute;dibilit & eacute;. Premi & egrave;rement, les praticiens ont recours & agrave; des pr & eacute;sentations professionnelles, comprenant des services structur & eacute;s, une terminologie th & eacute;rapeutique et une auto-l & eacute;gitimation biographique. Deuxi & egrave;mement, la cr & eacute;dibilit & eacute; est renforc & eacute;e par un appel & eacute;motionnel et relationnel, notamment une communication personnalis & eacute;e, des manifestations d'attention et une proximit & eacute; per & ccedil;ue entre le praticien et le client. Troisi & egrave;mement, la non-v & eacute;rifiabilit & eacute; strat & eacute;gique appara & icirc;t comme un m & eacute;canisme distinctif: la non-v & eacute;rifiabilit & eacute; inh & eacute;rente & agrave; la TAC est activement mobilis & eacute;e pour prot & eacute;ger les affirmations contre toute falsification gr & acirc;ce & agrave; une flexibilit & eacute; interpr & eacute;tative. Les r & eacute;sultats montrent comment la cr & eacute;dibilit & eacute; peut & ecirc;tre stabilis & eacute;e par le biais de strat & eacute;gies professionnelles, relationnelles et & eacute;pist & eacute;miques malgr & eacute; l'absence de validation empirique.