
OBJECTIVEThis study investigated the contributions that persons with serious mental illness make to their families according to both clients and family respondents.METHODSThe sample consisted of 725 clients with serious mental illness and 725 family respondents living in rural counties or counties with small urban areas in Wisconsin. Clients were in contact with family respondents at least three times a year; 23.7 percent of them lived with the respondent. Clients returned a questionnaire, and family respondents completed a telephone interview; both rated the amount of help the client gave in eight areas such as household chores, shopping, and companionship.RESULTSOverall, the clients, especially those who lived with their families, provided substantial help. For the total sample, clients were most likely to contribute by providing companionship; family respondents reported that 59 percent of clients gave such help. For clients who lived with respondents, between 50 and 80 percent helped by doing household chores, shopping, listening to problems, providing companionship, and providing news about family and friends, according to family respondents.CONCLUSIONSMany persons with severe mental illness play positive roles in their families. Recognition of clients' contributions by providers, researchers, and clients and families themselves could help reduce stigma and expand community opportunities for persons with severe mental illness.
OBJECTIVE:The authors' aim was to test the relationship between receipt of desired community mental health services by homeless mentally ill forensic clients and whether the clients returned to jail within six months.METHODS:Mentally ill homeless clients leaving jail were randomly assigned to three service conditions: intensive case management provided by an assertive community treatment team, intensive case management provided by individual case managers, and referral to a community mental health center. Data on whether clients' service needs were met were analyzed using discriminant function and chi square analyses.RESULTS:Thirty-two percent of the 105 clients interviewed at six months were reincarcerated during the six-month study period. Jail recidivism was related to receipt of fewer services that clients reported they needed, specifically to receipt of fewer services for developing independent living skills. Service condition was not significantly related to return to jail.CONCLUSIONS:Case management, a flexible community-based service that does not lend itself to clearly prescribed procedures, may easily deteriorate into providing monitoring rather than rehabilitative services for forensic clients and thus may facilitate reincarceration.
Rochester mental health providers and planners are convinced that capitation is an effective financing mechanism that allows care to be tailored to the needs of the individual and that can drive development of needed services. Some of the problems encountered involved the stability of the financing mechanism, new assumption of costs not previously borne by mental health dollars, the appropriateness of stop-loss mechanisms, methods of incorporating Medicaid and Medicare funds, and definition of capitation rate groups as well as parameters for movement in and out of groups. Many of the contractual and administrative obstacles would be ameliorated if mechanisms were available at higher levels of government to allow for capitation financing and incorporation of other financing and reimbursement sources. The clinical benefits of capitation in Rochester were most demonstrable in the development of systems of care targeted to persons with serious and persistent mental illness and the transfer of care to the community for most of these persons. Whether capitation programs provide incentives for underserving enrollees was not really adequately tested in this demonstration project, as the capitation rates were generally adequate to support the needed care. The question has been asked whether we would implement another capitation program if given the opportunity. The answer is a resounding "You bet!"
OBJECTIVE:The treatment of suicidal patients contributes to escalating mental health expenditures. Fiscal realities necessitate that cost-containment measures be implemented wherever possible. The authors reviewed the literature to delineate factors that impede cost containment for the treatment of suicidal patients and to outline strategies for controlling costs while improving the quality of care.METHODS:Psychological Abstracts and MEDLINE databases were reviewed. Retrieval and analysis focused on literature published between 1982 and 1992.RESULTS AND CONCLUSIONS:Five factors unique to the treatment of suicidal patients that impede cost containment were identified: the lack of a specific and cost-effective screening method to determine true risk of suicide, the high number of parasuicidal and malingering patients, revolving-door admissions of involuntary patients who become noncompliant with treatment after discharge, the adverse clinical consequences of further increases in existing discriminatory mental health benefits, and the medicolegal liability incurred in treating suicidal patients. The low frequency of completed suicides in relation to attempts and reported ideation indicates that most inpatients labeled suicidal are hospitalized unnecessarily. Thus inpatient treatment should be reserved for patients who make attempts of high lethality and patients with suicidal ideation who are at high risk because of other factors. Ideally, suicidal patients should be committed not to an inpatient facility but to a treatment network in which they can move appropriately between inpatient, day hospital, and outpatient care.