
Self-employed individuals who operate through a business entity can often dictate how much employment tax they pay, if any. That’s because the rules permit them to control whether their earnings count as labor income – which is subject to employment tax – or the returns on any capital invested in their business – which is not subject to the tax. The GILTI rules enacted as part of the 2017 Tax Act assume that capital investments generally earn a 10 percent annual rate of return. That same assumption can be used to allocate the earnings of a self-employed individual between the income from their labor and the return on any capital invested in the business. Such a mandatory rule would eliminate the abusive practices that self-employed individuals currently utilize. It would also raise considerable revenue while permitting the entire tax system to operate in a more consistent and equitable way.
Copyright litigation involving hit songs like Robin Thicke’s “Blurred Lines,” Justin Bieber and Usher’s “Somebody to Love,” and Led Zeppelin’s “Stairway to Heaven” caused many in the music industry to vex over the line between homage and infringement. When are the two works too similar? To many courts and scholars, substantial similarity is “bizarre,” “ad hoc,” and “a virtual black hole in copyright jurisprudence.” Every creative work borrows some inspiration from other works, whether copyrighted or not. Judging when defendants appropriated too much is an inherently opaque and subjective enterprise, but unraveling its mysteries is critical for the flourishing of diverse, creative ecosystems like architecture, literature, movies, and software. The scholarly debate has focused on doctrinal tests and litigation venues without accounting for factors actually impacting case outcomes and those that do not. Unaddressed, plaintiffs will continue to face abysmal odds without really knowing why. This Article reveals potentially malignant features in copyright law that may inhibit the growth of creativity and technology, and other features that are conventionally thought to impact case outcomes but are surprisingly irrelevant. This Article’s most important finding is substantial similarity’s silent death through pretrial motions and the prevalence of non-rival defendants. This Article also uncovers the irrelevance of willful infringement and the nature of the copyrighted works at issue to case outcomes. Beyond copyright law, this Article underscores the consequences of shunting jury trials, affirms how empirical research realigns theoretical work to real-world outcomes, and demonstrates how cross-fertilization within copyright doctrines and beyond copyright law is critical to addressing seemingly intractable doctrinal puzzles like substantial similarity.
The Tax Cuts and Jobs Act of 2017 introduced the first ever excise tax imposed on the investment income of university endowments. While it is a relatively small tax, this new law is a first step towards the exploration of taxing non-profit entities on the vast sums of wealth they hold in their endowments. In this Essay I take the new tax as a starting place for investigating the justification for tax exemption for universities and thinking through the consequences of changing our approach, both in the form of the new excise tax and possible alternatives. There remain reasons to be skeptical both about the design of the current tax and its ability to withstand the political efforts of the powerful set of universities who will be subject to it. Nonetheless, this new tax opens the door to a discussion of whether it is time to treat universities’ endowments more like the private equity funds they increasingly resemble.