
To what extent do macro-institutional characteristics influence the equalization of educational outcomes by social origin? Motivated by this long-debated question, I investigate the relationship between the destandardization , or decreasing standardization, of educational systems and socioeconomic inequality in secondary educational attainment across 27 low- and middle-income countries (LMICs). Here, destandardization captures the degree to which educational policies and responsibilities are not uniform across subnational authorities or schools within a country. I combine unique country-level measures of destandardization with cumulative cross-sectional household survey data comprising 931,749 observations across 414 country-cohorts, observed near the age of secondary-education completion, covering 1990 to 2017. Contrary to proponents’ expectations, the findings suggest that in highly destandardized subnational systems, the attainment gap between the richest and poorest individuals is substantially wider than in systems with minimal destandardization. This association is weaker at the school than at the subnational level. These results remain consistent across multiple specifications, including alternative definitions of age groups and cohort exposure. I argue that macro-institutional changes alone may be insufficient to overcome the foundational challenges facing LMIC education systems, such as poverty and underinvestment, and to address socioeconomic disparities in educational outcomes.
This study extends seasonal comparison research by examining learning losses across not just summer breaks but multiple breaks of varying length, timing, and reliance on learning support. We used digital trace data from a reading app to track weekly reading-speed growth in a cohort of 8,921 Danish students from fourth grade (2019) to the end of sixth grade (2022), comparing growth during school and breaks, including Covid-19 closures. Results show consistent learning losses or stagnation following short breaks, indicating that traditional seasonal comparison designs may underestimate schools' effects on learning. Notably, learning stagnation during the Covid-19 closures persisted even after schools reopened. We found indications of compensatory school effects by socioeconomic status in fourth grade but not in later grades. Results also suggest schools may narrow achievement gaps between students with immigration backgrounds and students from the ethnic majority population.
Despite decades of reform, racial disparities in vertical transfer between community colleges and universities continue to persist. In this article, I conceptualize vertical transfer as an opportunity structure shaped by relational racial, spatial, and organizational processes within a stratified higher-education system. Leveraging a latent space approach to network analysis, I examine transfer ties between 113 community colleges in California and nine University of California campuses between 2012 and 2022. The results highlight how organizational scale and geographic proximity operate as racialized resources. Organizational scale is associated with amplified transfer opportunities for community colleges that serve larger proportions of Black and Latine students, and geographic proximity to different four-year sectors (i.e., regional state vs. public “elite” universities) shapes transfers in both diversionary and racially differentiated ways. The findings demonstrate a racialized geographies of transfer opportunity and suggest how relational racial, spatial, and organizational processes interplay to stratify transfer and higher-education opportunities.
This article builds on sociological research on categorical inequalities in middle and high school course placements to investigate the distribution of students across classrooms within North Carolina elementary schools. Consistent with qualitative evidence suggesting that educators seek to create demographically balanced classrooms, we find that students are distributed quite evenly across their schools’ classrooms based on race, ethnicity, and family economic background. However, we find that some elementary schools create classrooms in which students are clustered based on their prior achievement as well as their eligibility for gifted education or special education services. This clustering is most prominent in large schools, schools with highly experienced teachers, and schools in which parents have a high degree of influence. Skills-based classroom clustering is associated with inequalities in student access to high-quality teaching. Our findings suggest that in some contexts, the categorical inequality processes associated with curricular tracking emerge in elementary school.
Prior research suggests teachers’ evaluations may be influenced by students’ socioeconomic background, yet most evidence comes from experimental settings that overlook biases arising in real student-teacher interactions. This article exploits a 2016 Danish reform that introduced external evaluation of a ninth-grade essay exam to examine whether teachers grade socioeconomically advantaged students more favorably than do external examiners. Using a difference-in-differences design comparing assessments affected and unaffected by the reform, I find that teacher involvement increases the socioeconomic grading gap by 15 percent to 20 percent. Further analyses show this effect is largely explained by objective measures of prior academic performance, suggesting it reflects not socioeconomic bias per se but teachers’ reliance on academic reputations when assigning grades.